Skip to main content

We know the most popular cocktails — Try these underrated drinks instead

Try some alternatives to the most popular cocktails

Cocktails
M.S. Meeuwesen/Unsplash

Recently, we wrote an article about the 10 most popular cocktails in the US. Not surprisingly, it was littered with classic drinks like the Mojito, Margarita, Old Fashioned, and Moscow Mule. But drinking cocktails isn’t a popularity contest. Just because many people seem to enjoy Espresso Martinis doesn’t mean you have to stop drinking your classic Dirty Martini.

But, if you take a moment to peruse the list of the 10 most popular drinks, you might see a few you like and others you aren’t sure about. That’s okay. Lucky for you, we’re here to help. That’s why today we’re all about the underdogs.

Recommended Videos

Instead of drinking your way through the top 10 list of drinks everyone loves, why not give the slightly less beloved (but equally delicious) cocktails a chance? We’re talking about the underrated cocktails you should try if you enjoy all (or any) of the 10 most popular cocktails in the US.

What makes a drink underrated?

Cocktail
Stanislav Ivanitskiy / Unsplash

If a drink is popular at all, it’s probably not underrated. It’s just that, compared to some of the most popular drinks, it might not get as much attention as it deserves. Many underrated cocktails are still household names. It’s simply that you might not order them, instead opting for a more well-known mixed drink. If you do this, you’re doing yourself a disservice because you’re missing out on some amazing, nuanced, complex cocktails.

The 10 most popular cocktails and underrated options

Cocktails
Moritz Mentges/Unsplash

We recently wrote about the 10 most popular cocktails based on NielsonIQ polling. Not surprisingly, there are many well-known classic cocktails as well as some more contemporary picks. While there’s nothing wrong with drinking your way through this list, if you already like these drinks and want to try something new, there are complementary options available. Keep scrolling to see the best, underrated cocktails to drink if you like the 10 most popular mixed drinks.

10.)French 75 instead of a Bellini

French 75
Stephen Harlan / Unsplash

While a Bellini is known for its sweet peach flavor that pairs well with Prosecco or any other sparkling wine, we think a great option to drink instead is the French 75. While not as sweet as the Bellini, it ticks the sparkling wine box and also has gin, lemon juice, and simple syrup.

9.) Harvey Wallbanger instead of a Mimosa

harvey wallbanger
Cyrus McCrimmon / Getty Images

If you like a Mimosa in the morning, you might enjoy a Harvey Wallbanger. Popular in the 1970s, this take on the Screwdriver is made with vodka, Galliano (a sweet herbal liqueur), and fresh orange juice. It doesn’t have Champagne, but the booze and fresh orange juice should hit the spot.

8.) Aperol and grapefruit soda instead of Spritz

Paloma
Kateryna T / Unsplash

While you might enjoy the effervescence of a great Aperol spritz, it’s likely the bittersweet flavors that bring you back for more. This is why we suggest imbibing a simple drink of Aperol and grapefruit soda. Yes, it is as simple as that.

7.) Rum and Cola instead of Long Island Iced Tea

Rum and cola
Blake Wisz / Unsplash

The iconic Long Island Iced Tea might taste like boozy iced tea, but it gets this flavor from a ridiculous number of ingredients. The list includes gin, vodka, white rum, tequila, cola, and more. Instead, opt for a simple rum and cola. It’s easy to make and less likely to give you an epic hangover the next day.

6.) Southside instead of a Mojito

Southside
iStock

If you enjoy the fresh, clean, herbal, minty flavor of a well-made Mojito, you’ll love a classic Southside cocktail. It’s very similar to the Mojito, except it swaps out rum for gin. The rest of the ingredients include lemon juice, simple syrup, and, of course, mint.

5.) Vieux Carre instead of Old Fashioned

Vieux Carre
Paige Ledford / Unsplash

When it comes to classic whiskey-based cocktails, it’s difficult to beat the appeal of an Old Fashioned. But if you want to try something similar, we suggest a Vieux Carre made with rye whiskey, cognac, sweet vermouth, Bénédictine, and Peychaud’s bitters.

4.) White Russian instead of Espresso Martini

white russian cocktail
Dan Baker / The Manual

While it doesn’t have the same caffeine kick as an Espresso Martini, if you enjoy the indulgent, dessert-like aspect of the drink, you’ll enjoy a classic White Russian. This favorite of Jeffrey Lebowski is made with vodka, fresh cream, and coffee liqueur.

3.) Penicillin instead of Moscow Mule

penicillin
Brent Hofacker / Getty Images

Who doesn’t love a refreshing, spicy, sweet Moscow Mule, right? Well, if you’re looking for something different that still has the ginger spice element, we suggest Penicillin. A little more complex and complicated than a Moscow Mule, this drink is made with blended Scotch whisky, fresh lemon juice, honey ginger syrup, and peated single malt Scotch whisky.

2.) Martinez instead of Martini

Martinez
iStock/Sanny11

The classic Martini is simple, boozy, and elegant. It’s difficult to find a suitable replacement. But, if you’re looking for something slightly different, we suggest a Martinez. This richer and most robust version of the iconic cocktail is made with gin, sweet vermouth, maraschino cherry liqueur, and Angostura bitters.

1.) Caipirinha instead of Margarita

cachaca caipirinha cocktail
Paulo Leandro Souza De Vilela Pinto

We completely understand why the Margarita is the most popular cocktail. When made with fresh ingredients, it has tequila sweetness and tart, sweet citrus working in perfect unison. A tremendous complementary cocktail is a Caipirinha. The national cocktail of Brazil is made with Cachaça, sugar, and lime wedges.

Bottom line

Godfather cocktail
Ambitious Studio* - Rick Barrett/Unsplash

Branch out and try something different. There’s nothing wrong with liking what you like, but it’s always a good idea to broaden your palate by trying something new from time to time.

Christopher Osburn
Christopher Osburn is a food and drinks writer located in the Finger Lakes Region of New York. He's been writing professional
Why rum deserves the spotlight in your summer drink lineup
Rum cocktails to drink this summer
Daiquiri on a table

While we don't usually make it our business to tell you that one spirit is better than another when it comes to summer drinking, there's an argument to be made for rum as the true hero of the warmer months. This is especially true when it comes to mixed drinks. There are great, refreshing vodka, gin, tequila, and whiskey-based cocktails, but there's something special about a classic, flavorful rum-based cocktail on a hot, sunny summer day.

In my years of writing about alcohol, I've been lucky enough to imbibe my fair share of rum-based drinks. I understand the prowess of this aged (or un-aged) sugarcane-based spirit when it comes to warm-weather mixology.
Why is rum great for summery cocktails?

Read more
The Baby Negroni is a fun-sized take on Italy’s most iconic cocktail
trio of negroni cocktails at Lele's Roman

The Negroni cocktail is an Italian favorite. Sweet yet bitter and complex, sipping a Negroni is the start or finish to many a great Italian meal. But if you're looking for a modern take on this classic, a "tiny" cocktail is a unique format. Basically, a smaller serving of the same drink, tiny cocktails have started to appear on some bar menus. Since the Negroni is Italian, we spoke to Joseph Isola, the food and beverage manager at Ace Hotel Brooklyn, home to Lele's Roman restaurant for insight into these tiny Negroni cocktails.

"At Lele's, we wanted to take a timeless Italian cocktail and present it in a more playful, approachable way," explains Isola. "The Negroni is a natural fit — its balance is iconic, and its versatility allows us to introduce guests to a classic in a fresh format."

Read more
Old Forester is set for the annual release of one of its most popular whiskeys
Old Forester is relaunching an experiemental whiskey
Whiskey glass

Fans of Old Forester eagerly await its limited-edition expressions. They were probably excited to learn that the iconic Kentucky-based brand announced the relaunch of one of its most popular annual releases: Old Forester 1910 Extra Extra Old.
Old Forester 1910 Extra Extra Old
Old Forester 1910 Extra Extra Old Old Forester

Part of its 117 Series of whiskeys, Old Forester 1910 Extra Extra Old gets its name because, after its initial maturation, this double-barreled bourbon is matured for an extra 24 months in a heavily charred secondary oak barrel. First released in spring 2021, this expression was originally an experimental whiskey made by aging 1910 Old Fine Whisky for an extra finishing period. The distillers liked the results enough to bottle it, and, clearly, so did Old Forester drinkers.

Read more