Skip to main content

The Manual may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site.

Product Review: This Is the Only Flannel Shirt You Need for Fall 2020

California Cowboy Flannel Shirt
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Being an outdoor writer, flannel shirts have long played a role in my wardrobe, especially come fall, when they become my go-to shacket. After all, nothing beats the warm, soft embrace in this predominately plaid material during cooler mornings and evenings. And you don’t have to be a lumberjack or urban hipster to appreciate this menswear staple, which looks great on just about everybody. But I thought I had a solid collection of flannel shirts until I discovered the High Sierra from California Cowboy, which claims that it “hugs you like a unicorn.” While I can’t attest to that, I can easily say that this should probably be your new favorite flannel shirt. Here’s why.

Materials

I was intrigued from the first moment I saw the High Sierra on the brand’s website. Yes, its main selling point is the luxe Portuguese flannel exterior, but the shirt also comes with plenty of thoughtful details that justify a hard-won place in your closet. It’s lined with a proprietary thermal fabric that really does feel like a unicorn’s hug (if that was possible). And for all of your après activities, the shirt comes with a water-resistant dry pocket for safely stashing your phone and a bottle pocket for your bevies, keys, and other small items. During colder temps, the shirt comes with a hidden glove loop to store your mittens. There’s also a sunglass loop to help secure your shades. Simply put, this shirt is comfortable and functional.

Recommended Videos

Fit

The High Sierra sports a slim fit. I typically wear large long-sleeve shirts but opted to size up to an XL for a more comfortable fit, and it still accommodates a t-shirt or base layer for extra warmth.

California Cowboy Shirt
Image used with permission by copyright holder

How to Wear It

I’m currently wearing my High Sierra with shorts and sandals while weather permits. But once temperatures drop even further, they’re great to wear with dark jeans and a solid pair of dress boots. And while you can tuck the shirt in, it’s designed to be worn untucked so you have easy access to your bottle pocket, water-resistant tech storage, and the glove loop for quick deployment.

Value

The High Sierra retails for $148, which is a bit more expensive than flannel offerings from bigger brands like L.L. Bean and Everlane, but the premium fabrics and quality amenities more than justify its price point. Plus, it’s a shirt and a shacket so you’re getting two products for the price of one. And while you can readily secure an economy flannel shirt, isn’t the reinforced bottle pocket enough incentive to splurge?

Clay Abney
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Clay Abney is a PR guru and freelance writer living in the wild and wonderful state of West Virginia, where he spends his…
An Honest Review of Untuckit and the No-Tuck Shirts for Men
untuckit no tuck shirt review

I can't remember when I started seeing ads for Untuckit — UNTUCKit (note the proper capitalization), if you're in the know. It seems the company’s glossy full-page marketing has been in every travel, lifestyle, and men’s magazine for the last decade. The brand proposition is simple: Premium button-up shirts made to be worn untucked. Since most men's dress shirts are designed to be tucked in, they often look long and sloppy when untucked. Untuckit promises to solve that problem with an entire catalog of no-tuck shirts.

To put it charitably, I initially thought the idea was silly. Why would anyone pay a premium — sometimes 200-300% more — just to wear a shorter shirt? Like the hot dog toaster before it, it seemed to me like a non-problem that didn't need solving. I wasn't alone. One needn't peer far down the rabbit hole of Untuckit reviews to find a similar sentiment. Esquire skewered the brand with the headline "Don't Waste Money on an 'Untucked' Shirt. Just Un-Tuck Your Damn Shirt." The New Yorker likewise gave it the classic, snark-filled New Yorker treatment. The Wall Street Journal protested, though largely because it just hates the concepts of untucked shirts and business casual period. The list goes on.

Read more
An Honest Review of Unbound Merino, the Travel Shirt That Stays Fresh
unbound merino button down shirt

What if we told you there was a shirt you never have to wash? Could you imagine how beneficial it would be for lightening your on-the-go wardrobe baggage? On top of that, you wouldn't have to worry about giving up your travel time to do laundry.

Unbound Merino is one of the few companies that tout its theoretical never-wash ability. Since the brand recently added button-down shirts to its collection, we had to see what the hype was all about.

Read more
Celebrate a British legend with Turnbull & Asser’s Churchill Collection
150 years after his birth, one legend nods to another in sartorial tribute
Churchill statue and English flags

Imagine being able to get your hands on the shirts made for George Washington. Maybe you want to get a bespoke suit made by the same guys who outfitted Abraham Lincoln. We look up to our historically beloved leaders because they stayed calm in the face of danger and turmoil and never blinked in the face of oblivion. Eighty years after he led his country through one of the darkest times England has ever seen, Sir Winston Churchill is still thought of today as one of the great legends of English history. He stood toe to toe against the evils of the Nazi party and never faltered in the face of destruction from Adolf Hitler and the German Army. Because he has such a legendary status, men have always looked to his style as something to emulate, and Turnbull & Asser are there to help. They don't just understand outfitting men like Churchill; they were involved in outfitting the man himself. With the Turnbull & Asser Churchill Collection, the iconic brand nods to another British legend.
Celebrating the life and style of an English legend

Churchill is credited with developing the onesie in World War II. Now, go with us here, we're not talking about the kind you wore as kids, or the kind your mechanic wears, but the concept was similar. He developed what became known as the Siren Suit, an easy-to-throw-on suit that kept you prepared and on the move during a night raid during the war, all while keeping your modesty. Turnbull & Asser made him his most famous green velvet Siren Suit, and they were a favorite of his when he needed dress shirts to meet with the likes of Eisenhauer, Stalin, and the Queen. With the Churchill Collection, you can choose from your pick of a few dress shirts, slacks, a bow tie, and even a robe and nightshirt.
Turnbull & Asser Churchill Collection

Read more