Skip to main content

We Tried the Menlo Club Subscription So You Don’t Have To

Delivers Fashionable Wardrobe Staples Without Breaking the Bank

Men are creatures of habit. We work hard. We address the world’s problems, and the vast majority of our brainpower is dedicated to making the world a better place. Because of that, what we wear falls to the back of our minds. We like our comforts. More importantly, we love it — whatever “it” is — to be easy.

One of the traits of a man who shops for himself is that when he finds something he likes, he doubles down. He triples down, and so do the rest of us. If we like the fit, the comfort, and the way something makes us feel, we will buy it in every color available. If this sounds like an efficient way to fill a wardrobe, it is, but the side effect is an entire wardrobe of the same thing. One of the best ways to combat that is through a subscription service, and one of the best out there is the Menlo Club, brought to you by the Five Four Group.

If you are debating the Menlo Club, here is all you need to know about it before you sign up.

How the Menlo House Subscription Works

Menlo Club
Menlo Club

When you sign up for a subscription service, there is almost always a quiz you take to allow the company to get an idea of your likes and dislikes. The quiz for the Menlo Club subscription service is by far the simplest and the fastest. The first step is picking from some fundamental looks to get an idea of your style. There are four pages you will navigate through. The first three will address your style preferences by having you choose between a few looks. The last page will ask for your sizes. The great thing about this service’s sizing questions is that they provide pictures to help you decide on the fits you like.

Once you have selected your preferences, you sign up. Pro tip: They almost always have specials and signup bonuses. At the time of this writing, you can join for less than half the price of the monthly box. Other times, they will give you extra items as a bonus.

The regular signup cost is $60, and you’ll get your first package immediately. Then around the middle of every month, you’ll receive your next package with two or three new items for your closet.

What Is in the Menlo Box?

A denim shirt, T-shirt, and pants from Menlo Club
Image used with permission by copyright holder

When the subscription service began, it was called the Five Four Club. As it grew to be one of the biggest competitors in the clothing subscription industry, it acquired more brands to offer its members. Of course, it couldn’t be called the Five Four Club while sending brands from New Republic and Melrose Place, so it rebranded in 2018 when it hit 100,000 active members. Now the membership is called the Menlo Club under the Five Four Group, with Menlo House being its online store.

These new brands elevated the offerings to include shoes, jackets, and many styles that can make each package feel different. It can expand a wardrobe from something stale and uniform to expressive and colorful. Most deliveries include a top, like a button-down or a T-shirt, a pair of pants (like denim, shorts, or even joggers), and shoes or outerwear.

How Does It Stack Up?

Menlo Club box with clothing
Image used with permission by copyright holder

There are dozens of subscription boxes for men to upgrade their lives. Some upgrade their wardrobe, some upgrade their gear, but nearly all have upsides and downsides. The Menlo Club subscription is no different. While the service is enjoyable overall, it isn’t immune to its share of disadvantages.

The pros of the service begin with the price. While other subscriptions can get supremely expensive, even going as high as a couple of hundred dollars a month, Menlo Club is pretty affordable at $60 a month. Even for that small of an amount, you still get some high-quality pieces perfect for rounding out your closet.

When the service first started, users were limited to Five Four brand clothing. Adding more brands, specifically New Republic shoes, elevated the service’s options significantly. Lastly, the service keeps track of what it has sent in the past so that you’re guaranteed never to get a repeat.

Now the cons. Despite the experience being overwhelmingly positive, there are some ways to improve. First is the initial style quiz. Consultations for professional style consultants can take hours, and even after that, learning a client’s preferences and curating a personal experience involves trial and error. Now, you’re not going to get that for $60 a month, but the Menlo Club’s initial exam is a mere four questions. It is basic and surface level. You’re likely getting the same thing as most, if not all, other active members.

Lastly, you get what you get. There are no exchanges if you get something you hate and will get zero wear out of. You can swap out for a different size, but that’s it. This is a bit of a gamble and precisely why a more extensive style quiz would come in handy.

Bottom Line

A plaid shirt over a T-shirt
Image used with permission by copyright holder

At the end of the day, feelings about the Menlo Club come down to expectations. When you go into it knowing you’re paying less than for most other clothing subscription services, and as long as you’re not expecting Armani or Tom Ford products, this service is a great way to expand your wardrobe. Its specialty is certainly streetwear, and if you approach it with an open mind, you’re guaranteed to walk away with items you may never have bought on your own in the store but that now are some of your favorite garments.

If you find yourself no longer excited about getting dressed in the morning or before a date, you could do much worse than the Menlo Club.

Editors' Recommendations

Mark McKee
Contributor
Mark is a full-time freelance writer and men's coach. He spent time as a style consultant and bespoke suit salesman before…
These are the sneakers you should have in your wardrobe
Ensure you stay in style with the best sneakers on this list
Man in khakis with white sneakers

Sneakers are some of the most iconic kinds of men's shoes. From PF Flyers and Converse to Air Jordans and Vans, the right pair of sneakers can become more than the perfect completion of an outfit; they can become a personality. The versatility of sneakers is one of their biggest perks. They can be bright colors and make any outfit stand out, expressing your personality. Or they can be hybrids with dress shoes to make wearing a suit more comfortable. Needless to say, there are a handful of sneakers for men you should have in your closet

With the literal hundreds of options you have as a man loving a good pair of kicks, it can easily get overwhelming when trying to find the best men's sneakers.

Read more
What is the business casual dress code for men? The dos and don’ts you should know
Here are some tips and tricks to master business casual
A man looking at what clothing to put on

Dressing for the office used to be pretty straightforward. If you worked in an office, you wore a suit and a tie. There was no real reason to deviate, as many businesses that had offices were also client-facing workspaces. You only get one chance to make a first impression, and dressing for the occasion is the way to do that.

In the late 1970s and early '80s, Silicon Valley became a place that prioritized results over everything else. While many businesses lived on processes, some of them antiquated, the tech field started to focus on processes in their product and letting their employees be comfortable in their wardrobes. Thus, the idea of business casual was born, and the suit became a whole other elevated level of office wear.

Read more
Khaki isn’t boring – and we can prove it
The pants you think are out of style are still as cool as they've always been
Man wearing khaki pants

Men have been wearing khaki pants for nearly two centuries, and even though men's fashion tends to change, these staples have endured. About 180 years ago, a British soldier in Punjab got sick of sweating in his heavy wool jacket and trousers, so he traded them in for local lightweight cotton. The looser cut and dyed fabric were dubbed khakis, and we've been wearing them ever since.

Nowadays, they can feel a little like old-fashioned style, which makes sense given they're coming up on the bicentennial mark. Many men are beginning to feel like they need to retire their khaki pants and opt for something different, but we're here to tell you that couldn't be further from the truth. Not only are they still useful, but these pants are as cool today and as much a part of men's style as they were in 1846.

Read more