Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Food & Drink

This limited rye whiskey is back, and it’s a Manhattan in a bottle

Fans of classic cocktails will love this whiskey

By
Whiskey in a glass on a table
Timothy James / Unsplash

If you’ve never tried Maryland rye whiskey, you’re a few centuries late to the party. The whiskey style has been around since the colonial days when Scottish and Irish immigrants decided to distill the spirit when they realized rye was a much easier crop to grow in the mid-Atlantic than barley. Its history in America is even older than that of bourbon. Like all rye whiskey, Maryland rye has seen a resurgence in the last few years thanks to brands like Sagamore Spirit.

The brand, which was founded in 2013, has a slew of award-winning expressions, and we suggest you get to know all they have to offer. But we’re most excited about one of the Baltimore-based distillery’s newest releases: Sagamore Manhattan Finish Rye Whiskey.

Recommended Videos

First released in limited quantities back in 2020, the distillery recently announced that this highly sought-after expression is back for a second time.

Sagamore Manhattan Finish Rye Whiskey

Sagamore Spirit Manhattan Finish
Sagamore Spirit

If you haven’t guessed it already, fans of the classic Manhattan cocktail (made with rye whiskey, sweet vermouth, and bitters) are going to love everything about this unique expression. The 2024 release of Sagamore Manhattan Finish Rye Whiskey is a potent, sippable 103-proof. It begins as a 4-year-old straight rye whiskey. It’s then finished in vermouth, bitters, and cherry brandy barrels for at least twenty full months. The result is a complex, rich, sweet rye whiskey that takes on all the memorable characteristics of a traditional Manhattan cocktail.

What does it taste like?

Whiskey with a black background
Mathew Schwartz / Unsplash

Did we mention this rye whiskey tastes exactly like a Manhattan cocktail? Because it really does. Sipping it neat reveals notes of dried cherries, vanilla beans, honey, and gentle spices. The folks at Sagamore Spirit suggest drinkers take it one step further and use this whiskey to make a Manhattan. What could be better than a base of Sagamore Manhattan Finish Rye Whiskey, along with bitters, vermouth, and the brand’s whiskey cherries?

“The original idea for Manhattan Finish back in 2020 challenged us to fully deconstruct the flavors of a Manhattan to create a full-proof whiskey that leaves you with a parting kiss of the cocktail,” Ryan Norwood, VP of Operations at Sagamore Spirit said in a press release. “Manhattans have become even more popular since then, so we knew it was time to bring back this delicious, limited-edition rye expression.”

Related: 
Blue Run’s latest release flips bourbon tradition with a gin barrel twist

How much does it cost?

Whiskey bottles
Adam Wilson / Unsplash

This expression is the newest release in Sagamore Spirit’s Reserve Series. It was created to pay tribute to the legacy of Maryland Rye whiskey. The brand previously released a port-finished rye whiskey. Sagamore Manhattan Finish Rye Whiskey is available for a suggested retail price of $79.99 at the Baltimore-based distillery and select retailers nationwide. If you’re a classic cocktail fan, you’re going to want a bottle of this limited-edition release.

Buy Now

Christopher Osburn
Christopher Osburn
Writer
Christopher Osburn is a food and drinks writer located in the Finger Lakes Region of New York. He's been writing professional
Topics

Editors’ Recommendations

Woodford Reserve is releasing its first American single malt whiskey
Woodford Reserve is finally getting in on the American single malt whiskey game
Woodford Reserve

The American single malt whiskey category isn’t very old, but there are already countless brands making expressions. One of the newest is much more well-known for its award-winning bourbons. That’s right, Woodford Reserve is set to launch its first foray into the world of American single malt whiskey.
Woodford Reserve 12-Year-Old American Single Malt

This new American single malt whisky is the iconic distillery’s newest release in its Distillery Series. To make this whiskey, Master Distiller Elizabeth McCall started with a mash bill of 100% malted barley. It was triple pot distilled before being matured for a minimum of twelve years in used whiskey barrels.

Read more
The angel’s share explained: The whiskey term every fan should know
What is "angel's share"?
Whiskey barrels

The whiskey world is loaded with unique, unusual, and sometimes confusing terms. We’re talking about phrases like “bunghole,” “sour mash,” “wash,” and the mysterious “angel’s share.” And while we could get into all of these terms (and more), today is the day to take a deeper dive into the latter.

I’ve been writing about alcohol for almost twenty years. The first time I visited a distillery (likely in Kentucky or Tennessee, although I can’t remember), one of the first things that was explained to me when visiting the barrelhouse was the idea of the angel’s share.

Read more
Why reposado tequila is the right choice for beginners
Beginners will love the versatility of reposado tequila
Tequila glass

If you didn't know it, tequila is much more than just that crystal-clear, sometimes harsh alcohol that you used to drink as a shot with lime and salt during your college days. It's a nuanced, complex spirit with various levels and types, each perfect for different uses and palate types.

I've written about alcohol for nearly two decades, and in that time, I've learned (and tasted) a lot about tequila. The major tip I always tell tequila newbies is to keep the blanco for cocktails and save the long-aged expressions for when their palates are a little more refined. If you're a beginner looking to start your tequila journey, there's no better choice than reposado.

Read more