Skip to main content

The fall martini: How to put a seasonal twist on a classic

Fall is a time for a whiskey-based martini

Manhattan
Heleno Viero / iStock

If you were to make a list of iconic, classic cocktails, the martini would make the cut. While there are many stories about its genesis, it’s believed by many that famed writer and bartender Jerry Thomas created the martini in the mid to late 1800s at the Occidental Hotel in San Francisco. Whether this is its true origin story, it’s still a timeless classic drink that remains popular today.

If you’re not a big drinker, you might assume that the martini is made with vodka. In fact, if you use vodka as the base for the drink, it must be referred to as a vodka martini. The original martini consists simply of London dry gin, vermouth, and perhaps a lemon twist or olive garnish. It’s simple, elegant, and the perfect way to drink gin.

Recommended Videos

And while nobody is going to argue about its popularity, is it the best option for fall imbibing? Sure, it’s boozy and warming, but is there a way to change it up enough to make it a fall seasonal drink? And no, we aren’t talking about adding pumpkin spice flavor to it to make it a fall martini.

Changing up the martini for fall

Fall martini
ArtMarie / iStock

Obviously, the classic martini is made with gin, but we prefer to enjoy gin-based drinks during the warmer months. We’re all about whiskey when autumn rolls around. That’s why we’re going to enjoy a riff on the classic drink made with whiskey instead.

Similar to a Manhattan, our fall martini is going to have a base of rye whiskey (or bourbon) instead of the usual herbal and botanical gin or neutral vodka found in a martini. But while a Manhattan is made with rye whiskey, sweet vermouth, and Angostura bitters, we’re keeping with the martini tradition and using whiskey, dry vermouth, simple syrup, and Peychaud’s bitters. Keep scrolling to see how to make this warming, autumn cocktail.

What you need to make the fall martini

  • 2 ounces of rye whiskey (or bourbon if you prefer more corn sweetness to peppery spice)
  • 1 ounce of dry vermouth
  • 1/2 ounce of simple syrup
  • 2-3 dashes of Peychaud’s bitters

The fall martini recipe steps

1. In an ice-filled mixing glass, add rye whiskey, dry vermouth, simple syrup, and Peychaud’s bitters.
2. Stir gently to combine and chill all of the ingredients.
3. Strain into a chilled martini glass.
4. Garnish with a cocktail cherry.

Bottom line

Whiskey bottles
Adam Wilson / Unsplash

If you’re not about pumpkin spice and you’d prefer your cocktail boozy and loaded with whiskey as opposed to coffee, this is the fall drink for you. It’s simple and easy to make and guaranteed to warm you from the inside out. If you already enjoy the Old Fashioned, Manhattan, and other whiskey-based classic cocktails, you’ll love this whiskey-fied take on the traditional martini.

Christopher Osburn
Christopher Osburn is a food and drinks writer located in the Finger Lakes Region of New York. He's been writing professional
Sip gently into the season with bright, fresh, long drinks for spring
Badger Bevs

The spirit plus mixer formula has its pluses, for sure. It's easy to make, for one, and is lower in alcohol than a combination of spirit plus liqueur. And there are some great classics in this formula -- I'll never tire of a Gin & Tonic, and plenty of people swear by a Screwdriver or a Vodka and Coke.

However, sometimes you're looking for an option that's a little more elevated.

Read more
An expert explains how to make the perfect Milk Punch
Milk Punch

The Milk Punch is one of those classic drinks which is beloved by its fans, but has a reputation of being a bit of a hassle to make at home. When working with diary you have to be careful not to split it, so some versions of the drink use milk that is clarified using heat and filtration. The classic version of the cocktail combines brandy or bourbon, rum, sugar, and vanilla alongside the milk for a creamy, boozy, comforting drink that's a little like an eggnog without the egg.

A bartending expert from BLVD Steakhouse, Kyle Davidson, has come up with his own take on the Milk Punch, which uses clarified milk for a light, clearer cocktail that incorporates flavors from the classic Arnold Palmer drink as well. Named for the golfing legend, the Arnold Palmer combines iced tea and lemonade, and sometimes has a shot of vodka, cognac, or bourbon added as well.

Read more
Give your gimlet a herbal twist with this vodka cocktail
Ghost Hill Organic Vodka

The Gimlet is one of those cocktails that is so simple and such a classic that it's easily overlooked. Whilst I lean toward a Gin Gimlet (and I have strong feelings like it should be made with fresh lime juice and sugar syrup rather than a pre-made lime cordial), you can also experiment with different spirits such as the also popular Vodka Gimlet.

The simple recipe is ripe for experimentation though, and especially when you are working with vodka, you have a lot of leeway to incorporate other ingredients to add more interest and unique personality to your drink. This recipe from Ghost Hill Organic Vodka showcases the smooth and clean notes of the spirit while also allowing space for the other ingredients to shine -- not only lime juice and simple syrup, but also the addition of sage leaves for a more herbal note.

Read more