Skip to main content

A professional chef reveals the secrets of wood-fire cooking

Chef Ed Cotton of Jack & Charlie No. 118 teaches The Manual the art of the wood oven.

halibut tail on table.
Wood-fired Halibut Tail for Two, filleted table-side and served with charred Chinese broccoli and braised pig’s feet and little neck clam ragout. Jack & Charlie’s No. 118

For Chef Ed Cotton of Jack & Charlie No. 118, there’s nothing like the creative cooking process of a raging wood fire oven.

“When coming up with dishes, I just really look at them with a different pair of glasses and see if I can see something different that I can do to it by using the wood-burning oven,” said Cotton. “What can I do to help elevate it? Is it worth it? Will people notice it? Is the end result of the dish much more noticeable if I chose not to use the wood oven? These are a bunch of things that I think of and put into deep consideration.”

Incredibly diverse, the wood oven is used by chefs for foods ranging from wood-fired pizza to Japanese binchotan grilling. But it’s a complicated process, and anyone interested in the art of the wood oven will be remiss not to experience the carefully crafted menu at Jack & Cotton No. 118. From delicate seafood to pork, here, the art of wood fire cooking is elevated cuisine.

clams casino with lemon.
Wood-fried Clams Casino. jackandcharlies118/Instagram

Cooking with wood is a choreographed dance

Much of the menu at Jack & Charlie No. 118 is centered around an 800-degree Fahrenheit wood-burning pizza oven. And for that process to succeed, Cotton believes the best wood for his oven is a curated combination of oak, maple, cherry, ash, and beech.

“They all work in different ways,” said Cotton. “Some burn faster, and some burn slower, but the best part about using them all is that they all work well with one another and help impart a tremendous amount of flavor into the food that is cooking in the oven. The end results give that signature flavor to our food that really gets people talking about how great everything tasted. The wood helps with it all.”

But wood is only the beginning. With so many different dishes and ingredients, all of varying sizes and styles, ensuring a dinner service runs smoothly is a carefully choreographed dance. Food is constantly moving and spinning around in the oven, some being covered or pulled, either moved closer to the mouth of the oven for char or further away to slow down cooking. It takes skill and experience to manage this dance.

“You really can’t take your eye off what’s inside when you’re dealing with an 800-degree inferno,” said Cotton. “Things can definitely get away from you, but this is why it is very important to watch the items that you are cooking like a hawk. You need to have a strong person on this station. Not only does the cook have to understand how to physically cook the items inside, but they need to fully understand how to control the heat, whether it be by adding a few pieces of wood to the fire or not adding more wood to the fire.”

prime rib on white plate.
Slow roasted prime rib at Jack & Charlie No. 118. chef_edcotton/Instagram

The art of wood-fire cooking

While not every item on Jack & Charlie’s menu is cooked in the wood-fired oven, many of the most interesting items are. An intensely savory Wood-fired Clams Casino, served with crusty bread, is one of the best versions anywhere. The hearty Snake River Farms Pork Chop A’ La Diablo is rich and smoky, the marbled pork balanced by the acidity of peppadew peppers. Even the unique Bone-In Duck Meatloaf, which is cooked in a conventional oven, is blasted in the high heat of the wood oven before it reaches the diner.

Naturally, the capacity and style of the wood-burning oven lends itself to this variety of ingredients — anything can be cooked in the oven. One particular strength is large, show-stopping foods. The Wood-fired Halibut Tail for Two is a new dish that represents this. Filleted table-side and served with charred Chinese broccoli and braised pig’s feet, and little neck clam ragout, this item is part of the Sunday Summer Supper Series.

But the wood-fired oven can also be used in conjunction with other cooking methods, creating dishes that feature various techniques. For Cotton, one of his favorites is the Jack’s Cut Prime Rib, served only on Fridays and Saturdays. A weeklong process from start to finish, the prime rib is deboned in-house, brined for three to four days in corned beef brine, and rubbed with Dijon mustard and pastrami spice. While the prime rib is first slow-roasted at 250 degrees Fahrenheit in a convection oven, the butchered ribs are placed in the wood oven overnight (when the fire is mostly gone), picking up a smoky flavor. However, the prime rib here is cooked twice.

“When the prime rib is finished cooking, I let it rest for 30 minutes or so, then remove the butcher’s twine and then coat it again in Dijon mustard all over and cover it with pastrami spice,” said Cotton. “Right before service, I transfer it to the wood oven and char every square inch of the rib until a deep caramelized crust appears. The prime rib is held in an extremely low-temperature oven for service and carved to order.”

This combination of cooking techniques and heat management is central to understanding the surprisingly subtle art of the wood oven, according to Cotton.

“One of the most common misconceptions about wood-fired ovens is you are cooking just from the heat of the fire,” said Cotton. “It’s not just from the heat of the oven, but it’s the actual oven that is doing the work. The design of the oven, along with the stones, has a lot to do with how it holds and retains the heat. Another one is that people are blaming wood ovens for ruining our environment. Burning firewood does release carbon into the atmosphere, but it is way greener than burning fossil fuels.”

Editors' Recommendations

Hunter Lu
Hunter Lu is a New York-based food and features writer, editor, and NYU graduate. His fiction has appeared in The Line…
Our 6 favorite bourbon brands and bottles in 2024
Buy these bourbon bottles in 2024
Bourbon glass

Bourbon is referred to as America’s “native spirit.” If you didn’t know it already, particular rules regulate what a bourbon is. While we won’t get into them all right now, the most important (in our opinion) is that to be considered a bourbon whiskey, the spirit must be made in the US (but not just Kentucky, regardless of what bourbon purists might have you believe) and it also must have a mash bill of at least 51% corn (although many have a much higher percentage of corn).

This corn-based spirit is known for its sweet, complex flavor profile featuring notes of vanilla, caramel, oak, cinnamon, and gentle spices. While 95% of all bourbon is made in Kentucky, it’s also made all over the United States, with a ton of the spirit coming out of places like Washington State, Texas, and even New York.

Read more
It’s been scientifically proven that pasta makes you happier
It's not your imagination. Pasta actually does make you happier.
Raw spaghetti

Is there anything more beautifully comforting, as intensely satisfying, or as incredibly delicious as a big bowl of your favorite pasta dish? From classic spaghetti and meatballs to creamy fettuccine Alfredo to a late-night pasta carbonara, every plate of pasta just feels like a giant hug. Pasta can be as simple as can be, delectable with only a little browned butter and Pecorino Romano, or intricate and sophisticated, accented with fresh seafood and earthy truffles. It's the perfect pantry staple from which to create a million dishes from a thousand global cuisines, and we can't get enough. According to Share The Pasta, the average American consumes approximately 20 pounds of pasta annually, making it the sixth-highest food per capita in the country. As a nation, we consume almost 6 billion pounds of pasta every year. It's also one of the most universally loved and appreciated foods in existence. I fail to recall a time when I've ever heard someone say, "Pasta? Nah. Not my thing."

Everyone loves pasta because pasta is perfection. And now, at long last, science has confirmed what most of us have known since childhood. That this life-giving ingredient actually makes our brains happier.

Read more
The 5 biggest lies you’ve been told about salmon
Don't believe these myths about salmon
Raw salmon filet

According to a report from IntraFish, salmon is the second most consumed seafood in the United States, falling behind only shrimp on an extensive list of commonly enjoyed kinds of seafood. It makes sense. Attend any wedding or catered event, and salmon is sure to be on the menu. The seafood counter at your local grocer is likely to have more of this beautifully orange-hued fish than any other variety on display, and there are more Pinterest recipes for salmon dishes than anyone knows quite what to do with.
The little black dress of the seafood world, salmon can be dressed up or down and is appropriate for any meal of the day, and everyone has their favorite version. It's also one of the most diverse, healthy, crowd-pleasing foods that's actually easy to prepare. Cooking salmon is at least a once-a-week occurrence in my house and one of the few healthy things my kids will eat without complaint.
Because of its sparkling popularity, though, salmon - inevitably - is bound to be the victim of some rumors.

You shouldn't eat salmon skin
This common misconception took a strong hold back in the early '90s when people were absolutely terrified of consuming anything containing fat. As we should all know now, though, there's a big difference between good fats and bad fats. Salmon skin is indeed fatty, but it falls into the good fats category, along with deliciously healthy ingredients like avocados, nuts, and olive oil. These good fats contain omega-3 fatty acids that are wonderful for everything from helping to prevent cardiovascular disease to clearing up breakouts. So crisp up that delicious skin with a little salt and olive oil, and enjoy!

Read more