Skip to main content

Tips and tricks: A pro chef reveals how to cook prime rib

Chef James Tracey of Monterey, a modern American Brasserie in NYC, breaks down this showstopping dish.

Prime rib at Monterey NYC.
Table side prime rib at Monterey NYC. Monterey NYC

If you like beef, you like prime rib. There are no ifs, ands, or buts about that. Prime rib, perhaps the most classic of classic beef cuts, is a thick slice from the primal rib section of the cow and features your typical “eye” of rib (with or without the actual bone) surrounded by deliciously marbled muscle. More often than not, the prime rib is saved for special occasions, such as the holidays.

To better understand how to cook prime rib, we tapped the culinary wisdom of Chef James Tracey of Monterey, a modern American Brasserie in New York City. At Monterey, the tableside prime rib service is the menu’s star. What better expert is there to learn everything about this American classic?

Monterey dining room.
The dining room at Monterey NYC. monterey_nyc/Instagram

How to select a prime rib

Broken down, a serving of prime rib will be a thick slice from the primal rib section of the cow and features your typical “eye” of rib (with or without the actual bone) surrounded by deliciously marbled muscle.

However, prime rib, aka standing rib roast, is different than other meats like your standard steak or a rack of ribs — instead of throwing it on the grill, you bake it as a roast for a couple of hours. Sounds simple, right? In a sense, it is, but there are a few things you should know before you slap on your favorite apron and fix it up for the first time.

At Monterey, they use a series of meat purveyors for their prime rib. While Monterey always uses USDA Prime for their prime rib, you, as the home cook, can opt for USDA Choice, which will still have a good amount of marbling. However, Monterey recommends splurging a bit and going for prime quality. After all, prime rib is a special occasion dish, so why not purchase something with the best marbling and quality?

Finally, there’s the aging process. Monterey wet-ages their prime rib, something that they recommend for the best experience. When purchasing your prime rib, look for a minimum of 28 days of wet aging. While wet aging doesn’t add that meaty funk like dry aging, it’s imperative for tenderness. If the meat isn’t labeled with that information at the store, we recommend asking your butcher.

table side prime rib monterey nyc
Prime rib at Monterey being presented table side. Monterey NYC

How to cook prime rib

The key to cooking an excellent prime rib is simplicity and technique. Basically, you don’t need a secret spice rub or a plethora of herbs to make prime rib delicious — high-quality meat and proper cooking temperature will be more than enough.

“Salt and pepper 6 hours to 20 hours ahead of time and let dry uncovered in the fridge,” said Chef Tracey. “You need a heavy layer of salt on the outside, especially if the rib is thick. We start at 425 degrees [Fahrenheit] for 20 minutes, then lower to 200 degrees [Fahrenheit] until the internal temperature is 100. We keep the rib after that in the cart.”

Another tip recommended by Chef Tracey is using butcher twine: “Trim the outside to a 1/4 inch of fat all around and then tie with butcher twine. This helps the ribeye cook more evenly and looks nicer when served.”

To check the meat temperature, a great tool is using a high-quality probe thermometer. Simply stick the probe into the thickest part of the roast and keep a close eye on the temperature. Cooking the roast to 115 degrees Fahrenheit on the inside will yield a few rare slices in the middle, mostly medium-rare slices, and a few medium slices on the outside — this should accommodate most refined steak eaters. If anyone wants their slice more well-done, you can always cook the roast for a few more minutes.

Monterey prime rib slice.
Monterey prime rib slice with au jus. Hunter Lu/The Manual

How to carve prime rib

When the prime rib arrives at Monterey, it’s dinner and an event. First, the cart — impressively large, yet elegant — is opened by the server, revealing a gorgeous whole prime rib roast. Then, taking a sharp knife, they carve, slicing off a generous portion onto a plate before they ladle on the rich, in-house au jus. It’s classic, old-school American steakhouse, all in a dining room that emotes an art deco, Miami vibe. It’s a one-of-a-kind experience.

The key to all of this, however, is properly carving that prime rib. The last thing you want is to spend all this time roasting an expensive cut and have it hacked to death. According to Chef Tracey, all you need are “a sharp slicer, meat fork, and someone who can cut straight. The knife is called a slicer because that’s how you need to use it. If you don’t use a long slicing motion, it could look like a chainsaw cut it.”

Once the prime rib has done its time in the oven, you also must resist the urge to start slicing right away, even if your guests are growing unruly (give them some great craft beer while they wait). You need to let the roast rest for about 30 minutes so the carryover cooking can take place.

After you let the roast rest, then you can give in to the lamentations of your hungry guests and start carving. We’re partial to inch-thick cuts, but really it’s a matter of personal preference. Some people enjoy super-thin English-style cuts of prime rib.

Side dishes for prime rib

The classic accompaniments for prime rib are au jus, horseradish sauce, and Yorkshire pudding. At Monterey, they serve their prime rib with a rich bone marrow au jus, fortified with veal stock. It’s supremely silky and perfect with their buttery potato purée. To help cut through the richness, also have plenty of grated horseradish or horseradish cream sauce. You also can’t go wrong with a baked potato for the starch and asparagus or baked spinach for the vegetable.

As for wine, you’ll want a “big” Cabernet or Merlot that pairs well with the flavors of the beef. Chef Tracey prefers his prime rib with an 86 Margaux. However, it’s also important to find a wine that appeals to you — the most important critic.

Prime rib occupies a hallowed space in the minds of meat lovers. Still, you shouldn’t let that deter you from attempting it yourself. Learning how to cook prime rib can revolutionize your dinner parties, family dinners, or dinners alone.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics
Hunter Lu
Hunter Lu is a New York-based food and features writer, editor, and NYU graduate. His fiction has appeared in The Line…
How to cook lobster the right way — boiling, grilling, and roasting
Prepare lobster in one of three ways, but enjoy it all the same
Lobster on a plate

Everyone needs a little something extra to spice up everyday life -- a spa day, perhaps, or a nice meal. And while ribs in the oven or a perfectly grilled steak will definitely suffice, sometimes you might think about moving from turf to surf, and what better "surf" to have than a sweet, succulent lobster? Meaty, juicy, and slathered in butter, it's about as perfect a meal as they come -- even while in lobster roll form.

For most, a nice lobster dinner sits at the apex of gourmet meals. There's just something about the bright red body sitting on a plate that exudes class. The thing is, though, that you don't have to go out to a fancy restaurant and shell out for that kind of meal. With a little know-how, anyone can make such an incomparable dish at home.

Read more
You should know how to make these incredible sauces
Mastering these sauces will make you look like a pro in the kitchen
Bechamel sauce over lasagna

A good sauce is a core component of culinary culture. Knowing how to make a handful of them can elevate your kitchen game to unforeseen heights. Often, a good sauce is the star of the show. After all, what would Thanksgiving turkey be without gravy? Or Eggs Benedict without hollandaise?

Now, we don't expect you to pull a Bearnaise sauce out of your hat at a moment's notice. But you should be able to whip up a solid tomato-based sauce for pasta, or a good teriyaki sauce for rice and veggies or skewered proteins. We know, there are great pre-made options out there, from complex fish sauce to throw-it-on-anything Japanese barbecue sauce. Yet, you know as well as we do that when you pull it off from scratch, it's more rewarding and can even taste better.

Read more
This is how to make a Bloody Bull – a better, beefier Bloody Mary recipe
Here's a different version of a Bloody Mary
Brennan's Bloody Bull.

Born in the great city of New Orleans, the Bloody Bull is the beefier cousin of the Bloody Mary. Treated to some meaty broth, the drink is super savory and begging to accompany your brunch plans.

The original hails from Brennan's, a colorful creole restaurant that's been on the scene since 1946. There are riffs of course, with bartenders treating the drink to everything from a bit of Guinness to a host of different spice blends.

Read more