Skip to main content

Create the perfect winter cocktail using these bartender-approved ingredients

A top bartender on winter cocktails

Old Fashioned cocktail
Pylyp Sukhenko / Unsplash

Winter is a surprisingly good time for cocktails, and not just because of the many gatherings we have this time of year. Yes, there’s an abundance of citrus, but there are other ingredients too that can properly winterize your favorite cocktail recipes.

While we love a great hot cocktail, there are other ways to melt the snow with a soothing beverage.

Recommended Videos

David Rowe is the lead bartender at the Four Seasons Embarcadero in San Francisco. He loves embracing seasonality and is always coming up with great ways to have his drinks reflect the time of year. He offered some great suggestions for making quality winter cocktails, including a recipe to try at home. And if you’re continuing with Dry January into February or just looking for a good non-alcoholic option, you’re in luck.

Buddah’s Hand and other citrus

Buddha's Hand citrus.
Flickr/Luigi Guarino / Flickr

Rowe is quick to admit he doesn’t go for ingredients that are too exotic, as the extra work of getting ahold of them can be too much. He does call on Buddha’s Hand this time of year. The citrus shrub produces evocative fruit that looks very much like a cartoonish hand. “The preparation requires the hand to be peeled, which is easily done with a ceramic peeler,” he says. “After the peel is removed, you soak the peels up to a month in the liquor of your choosing. I prefer either vodka or gin. If you choose, you can add sugar and water to make a lemon cello type of liquor.”

How does one put it to use? Spritzers of Collins’ type cocktails are great. “Or, a great Buddah’s Hand Martini,” Rowe adds.

Winter Spices

Variety of Indian masala chai spices - star anise, cloves and cinnamon on a plate.
VD Photography / Unsplash

“My current choice for winter is taking the bountiful orange and pairing it with the friendly holiday spices of cinnamon, clove, nutmeg, allspice, anise, and clove,” the bartender says. “It’s a familiar mixture for that cozy baked aroma.”

What’s his go-to orange? Valencia, which is ideal for juicing. “I’ll take the juice, let’s say a quart, and dissolve a quart of cane sugar into it. Add your mixture to a large saucepan with the spices and reduce it by at least half. After it cools, it will have the consistency of a rich simple syrup,” he says.”

Just like that—at least after if cools—you have an orange spiced simple syrup that can be used in a number of way to impart what Rowe calls “warmth” and a “comfortable element to your cocktails.” The spice mix reminds him of fresh-baked banana bread or the holidays and cider spices.

“Using this syrup in an Old Fashioned transforms the cocktail to a winter wonderland with little effort,” he says. “Replace the agave with the orange syrup in a Margarita and the spices jump forward and pair with tequila’s earthiness.”

Room temperature cocktails

White Negroni
NA

“For novice drinkers I think many of the room temperature cocktails come across as too strong, because the liquor is not diluted in any form,” Rowe says. “With that said, room temperature cocktails can offer a warm comfort during these chilly winter nights.”

He suggests spirits well-steeped in flavors. “Roots, spices, botanicals are all well-curated in many Amaros and liquors,” he says. “One such liquor on every bar’s back shelf is Benedictine. Used judiciously, it adds a complement of botanicals and sweetness.”

And one can always go the way of the apple, expressed greatly in Calvados. “To rinse a brandy snifter with Benedictine and add a shot of Calvados, then you have a very easy and seasonal room temperature cocktail that is very sip-able and complex,” he says.

“A cocktail we make at Orafo is called the White Lotus which easily transitions to a room temperature cocktail. Incorporating a white Negroni idea, it uses Tanquray Suville, amaro Nonino, and Calvados, with a wash of Benedictine. A bit more complex than the for mentioned version but packs the same warm and comforting apple and orange combination so familiar to the season.

Winter NA Cream Soda

Two refreshing glasses of Scotch and Soda.
NA

“My favorite surprise is how incredible the baking spices come forward when it’s used for a simple NA Italian Cream Soda,” admits Rowe. He notes that if you pour the club soda slowly enough, a pillowy white crown will rise to the top of the glass. That’s some presentation.

Ingredients:

  • 1 ounce orange spiced simple
  • 1/2 ounce cream
  • Club soda
  • Ice

Method:

  1. Combine simple syrup with cream and shake with 1 cup of ice.
  2. Pour whole mixture into a Highball glass and slowly add club soda.

Rowe likes to apply the syrup to any number of non-alcoholic mocktails. For example, in the winter, he will treat an ounce of the orange syrup to two ounces of pomegranate juice, an ounce of lemon juice, an an ounce of egg white. He dry shakes, chills, and strains into a coupe for a tangy mocktail with warm holiday spices. Don’t forget to garnish with crumbled dehydrated lemon!

Mark Stock
Mark Stock is a writer from Portland, Oregon. He fell into wine during the Recession and has been fixated on the stuff since…
Bucked Up Whiskey is releasing the perfect expression for fans of churros
Bucked Up Whiskey is releasing the cinnamon and sugar-filled whiskey of your deep-friend dreams
Whiskey in a glass by a fire

Bucked Up Whiskey is a whiskey brand that got its name because it's a brand committed to supporting organizations like the Wild Horse Sanctuary in Shingletown, California, which supports the protection and preservation of horses. It's known for its Bucked Up Bourbon, Bucked Up White Whiskey, and Bucked Up Bourbon Gold.

All of which are adorned with a cowboy in the process of being knocked off bucking bronco. Its latest whiskey release doesn't really have much to do with horses, but it should appeal to anyone who enjoys deep-fried, cinnamon-covered treats.
Bucked Up Churro Flavored Whiskey

Read more
This season’s most unexpected cocktail ingredient is tea
Hibiscus tea in a cup.

Of all the cocktail trends for 2025 that were on my radar, here's one I didn't see coming: making tea the star ingredient.

Earl Grey tea in particular is having a moment in cocktail bars, where its floral, citrusy flavors are being incorporated into cocktails along with ingredients like lemon juice and gin. We've got some recipes below, and you can even have some fun serving these drinks in tea cups for something a bit special at your next party.

Read more
Ready-to-serve cocktail fans will be excited for this new collaboration from The House of Suntory
The House of Suntory is launching The Harmony Collection of ready-to-serve cocktails
The House of Suntory

Suntory is the biggest name in the world of Japanese whisky. And while you can't go wrong with any of its epic whiskies, including Toki, Hibiki, Yamazaki, and Hakushu, sometimes wouldn't you rather have a premium ready-to-serve cocktail? Well, you're in luck. The House of Suntory recently announced the launch of a new collection of ready-to-serve cocktails.
The Harmony Collection

On The Rocks Premium Cocktails and The House of Suntory are releasing The Harmony Collection. This limited-edition partnership launches with two ready-to-serve cocktails created by Hidetsugu Ueno, the world-famous bartender and owner of Tokyo's Bar High Five.

Read more