Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Food & Drink
  3. Features

An expert sets the record straight on bourbon’s biggest myths

It's time to learn the real deal about the worst bourbon myths

Whiskey in a glass
Haris Calkic / iStock

Bourbon might be America’s “native” spirit and one of the most common whiskey varieties you’ll find on the shelf at your local liquor retailer, but what do you really know about this popular spirit? I’ve been writing about alcohol for nearly 20 years. In that time, I’ve learned a lot of information about the various spirits, wines, and beers we drink on a regular basis. But few spirits have as many myths surrounding them as bourbon.

If you listen to your uninformed whiskey purist uncle, he might tell you a tale about what bourbon is, where it can be made, and why Jack Daniel’s absolutely is a bourbon. But is he actually right? Probably not (although we’ll get into the Jack Daniel’s debate a little later). Keep scrolling as I make an attempt at debunking bourbon myths that you may have heard and don’t know if you should believe them. To help me out, I turned to Paul Hletko, Founder of FEW Spirits.

Recommended Videos

The bourbon geography myth

Whiskey barrels
Josh Collesano / Unsplash

You know that in order to be considered a bourbon, the whiskey must fit a few specific rules. Among them are the fact that its mash bill must be made up of at least 51% corn. That is a fact. This is where things get tricky.

That same uncle we mentioned earlier might whisper in your ear that Kentucky is the only state that can make bourbon. And while 95% of it is made in the Blue Grass State, the idea that it can only be made there is one of the many myths about bourbon and a big fat myth at that. To be considered a bourbon, it must be made in the U.S. (including D.C. and Puerto Rico).

 “In fact, some of the best bourbon on the planet comes from outside Kentucky, from Evanston Illinois, to Virginia, Indiana, Pennsylvania and more,” Hletko said. 

This means that it can be (and is) distilled from Tampa to Tacoma and everywhere in between. Some of the best, most awarded bourbons come from places like Texas, Wyoming, and New York.

Other myths about bourbon

Barrel proof whiskey
Nathan Dumlao / Unsplash

Another big myth is the legend that Elijah Craig invented bourbon whiskey. Sure, it’s a fun tale. As the story goes: The former Baptist preacher created bourbon in 1789 when he decided to age his corn whiskey in charred barrels. The problem with this Genesis story is the fact that there were already other distillers in Kentucky alone making what we now know as bourbon.

Another myth is that the flavor comes from the barrel exclusively. “While the barrel can certainly have a large impact on the flavor, the flavor of the spirit itself comes from the fermentation process,” Hletko explained. 

Another myth is that big age statements are better. Bourbon is exclusively aged in new barrels, and so the barrel influence can be too strong if the whiskey is too old.

“The key is to find your own personal balance and understand that many bourbon professionals think the sweet spot is between six and eight years, although preferences certainly vary, and you may like older or younger,” he said. 

Regardless of what the ingredients say, Jack Daniel’s isn’t a bourbon. Even though its ingredients fit the criteria for bourbon, it’s considered a Tennessee whiskey because of the charcoal mellowing process it undergoes, called the Lincoln County Process.

Last but not least, there’s a myth that bourbon is too sweet or lacks complexity, or is a “beginners”whiskey. 

“While bourbon does certainly have sweet notes like vanilla and caramel, bourbon can be spicy with notes of black and white pepper, and bourbon can be fruity with cherry notes, and bourbon can have a wide variety of flavors, and can be quite complex,” Hletko said. 

Bourbon misconceptions

Bourbon barrels
Katherine Conrad / Unsplash

“There are so many misconceptions because a large fraction of the world’s bourbon does come from Kentucky, but the fact remains that some of the best bourbon on the planet comes from outside,” Hletko told us. “Sure, Kentucky makes a lot of bourbon, but the best bourbon in the world comes from all over, including Evanston, Illinois.”

Advice for novice bourbon drinkers

Glass of whiskey with ice cubes served on wooden planks
Jag_cz / Shutterstock

If you’re new to bourbon, try as many brands and expressions as possible. We’ll always tell you to start with classic Kentucky brands like Buffalo Trace, Woodford Reserve, Maker’s Mark, Wild Turkey, and more. But don’t limit yourself to bourbons only from Kentucky. Branch out and try expressions from the likes of Frey Ranch (in Nevada), Wyoming Whiskey (in Wyoming), Garrison Brothers (in Texas), and Woodinville Whiskey (in Washington state), among others.

Buy a reasonably priced bottle for sipping neat, on the rocks, and with a splash or two of water. Also, buy a few bottles exclusively for mixing. While you’ll want to elevate your palate by sipping whiskeys, you should also learn to mix classic bourbon drinks like the Old Fashioned, Manhattan, Gold Rush, Boulevardier, and more.

The best advice for “beginner” bourbon drinkers is “drink it how you like it” and don’t listen to others try and tell you the “best” way to drink it. 

“There is only one ‘best way’ to drink bourbon, and that is how you like it. So, experiment with it in cocktails, with cola, neat, rocks, and see how you like it, and you may even find that you like different bourbons in different ways, so don’t be afraid to try it,” he explained. “Bourbon is supposed to be fun, so enjoy it. And if you are new to spirits and sampling neat, I always recommend sipping the smallest sip you can to let your mouth get used to the high alcohol content, and then taking a ‘tasting’ sip, still small, after the smallest sip.”

Bottom line

Pouring whiskey in a glass
lenakorzh / iStock

We hope that after reading this story, you’ll be more likely to look facts up as opposed to simply believing someone who may or may not be informed. At the very least, you now know that bourbon can be made anywhere in the U.S. and definitely not just in Kentucky. Don’t let your uninformed uncle’s opinion muddy the whiskey waters.

Christopher Osburn is a food and drinks writer located in the Finger Lakes Region of New York. He’s been writing professional Read Full Bio
The best smoky single malt Scotch whiskies to sip this holiday season
Scotch Glass

Many of us look forward to the Holiday season. It’s a time to reconnect with old friends, spend time with family, and enjoy over-the-top, gut-busting meals and rich, indulgent desserts. It’s also a great time of year to crack open that bottle of single malt Scotch whisky you’ve been holding onto all year. Few things go better with holiday revelry than a well-made whisky.

Sure, a case can be made for a nice single malt aged in sherry-seasoned barrels or even a unique rum cask-aged whisky, but I believe the best choice for holiday sipping is a complex, smoky single malt. And if we’re talking about peat-smoked whiskies, we’re talking about the Inner Hebrides island of Islay.

Read more
Skip the fruit basket & sweets: These gourmet meat and cheese gifts are worth giving
Boarderie

If there’s one thing I love giving (and receiving) during the holiday season, it’s food. Yet, when I think about the holiday season, all I think about is how there’s way too much sugar and treats around. Candies, fruit, chocolates, cookies, gingerbread houses… sure, these are all fun and delicious.

But I’ve got more of a savory set of taste buds—and I know there are others out there like me, too. A great assortment of meats, cheeses, and delicious extras can make a great gift for someone like me who really doesn’t want another cookie tin this holiday season. From pre-arranged charcuterie boards to meat delivery boxes to jerky and meat stick stocking stuffers, use these gourmet meat and cheese gifts for inspiration to do something different this holiday season.

Read more
A Francophile’s Guide to the Best French Restaurants in NYC
a francophiles guide to the best french restaurants in nyc 09 lesixth alexstaniloff 051226 043

Despite my Puritan roots, I am an ardent Francophile. My flinty forebears contented themselves with beige and brown vittles, boiled and unseasoned. Among the Elect, dining offered all the aesthetic nuance of a horse at his trough. A fondness for delicacies was, in their god-fearing eyes, but a gateway to graver sins of the flesh.

The French knew better. Dishes elevated to art, languorous lunches followed by coffee and cigarettes, entire afternoons devoted to a bottle of Comtes de Champagne and a paramour. These were essential ingredients of a well-lived life. The Good Lord, insisted the Gaul, fashioned tongues to savor fine wine and delicate sweetmeats, among other purposes.

Read more