Skip to main content

The Manual may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site.

Review: Is Caraway cookware worth all the hype?

It turns out, these pots and pans are pretty perfect — find out what we learned

If you spend any time at all on cooking blogs, recipe sites, or watching YouTube chefs, you’re probably at least familiar with Caraway cookware and bakeware. The Caraway brand has become well known in the culinary community for its claim to healthier cooking through pots and pans that don’t contain any harmful chemicals or contaminants.

Its nonstick surfaces release food with ease, leaving you with a healthier meal and a pan that’s a breeze to clean. Not only that, but the aesthetic of the cookware is absolutely stunning, available in a wide range of gorgeous hues and a sleek, modern style. It couldn’t possibly be as great a brand as it’s hyped up to be, right? Well, we decided to see for ourselves.

My family is hard on cookware. Like, really hard. My husband is a chef, and while I left the professional cooking biz behind ages ago, I do still know my way around the flames and blades of a home kitchen. Enter two kids who eat about 17 times a day, and my kitchen is a busy place. So I was curious, to say the least, when it came to Caraway’s claims of healthier, easier cooking. Here’s what I learned.

Caraway cookware in shipping boxes
Lindsay Parrill/The Manual

Why is Caraway cookware healthier?

Unlike other nonstick cookware, Caraway doesn’t use any harmful chemicals or synthetics, like polytetrafluoroethylene (what Teflon is made from). As more and more research has shown, these synthetics can leach out toxic chemicals into the food they’re cooking. Furthermore, research has shown that these chemicals, not-so-fondly nicknamed “forever chemicals,” can stay in the human body for decades.

Caraway realized how absolutely disgusting this problem was and decided to invent a product that was just as conveniently nonstick, but made from mineral-based coatings that contain zero harmful toxins. Incredibly, Caraway pots and pans also release 60% less CO2 when produced compared to traditional nonstick coatings.

Caraway cookware and bakeware on a kitchen table
Lindsay Parrill/The Manual

How well do they cook?

I was shocked at how well these pans retain heat. They come to temperature quickly and evenly, giving an even browning to everything I’ve cooked in them so far — including salmon, shrimp, chicken thighs, numerous vegetables, mushrooms, and even a few late-night pancakes.

I have a gas range, but Caraway products are also compatible with electric and induction stovetops.

These pans are also much lighter in weight than many on the market, making for easy maneuvering around a stovetop when you have several things cooking at once.

Cooking fish on a Caraway pan
Lindsay Parrill/The Manual

Are they really nonstick?

Yes. So much so, in fact, that when I lifted this pan from the oven and tilted it slightly in the process, the whole meal nearly slid right off the pan and onto the floor.

As you can see from the photo, I baked a skin-on salmon filet, as well as zucchini and green beans on the medium baking sheet. On all the ingredients total, I used less than a tablespoon of olive oil, and yet, the stick was completely nonexistent.

Lindsay Parrill/The Manual

Are they dishwasher-safe pots and pans?

No, but it’s not as big a deal as you think. Dishwashers use harsh soaps and detergents that aren’t good for the nonstick properties of these pots and pans and can reduce their lifespan. But the truth is, there’s really no need to put them in the dishwasher anyway because…

Are they easy to clean?

Caraway pots and pans are ridiculously simple to clean. No overnight soaking, no sweaty scrubbing, and no secretly throwing pans away because you just can’t take the gunk. That’s all over with these pots and pans. A sudsy run under warm water and a gentle wipe down, and these products are shiny and new again.

A special handy Cleaning Eraser came with a special Cleaning Eraser, but I haven’t had to use it.

How long will they last?

Because these are so easy to clean, and there’s no need for hard scrubbing or soaking, they’ll last much longer than many other brands. When properly used, cleaned, and stored, these pots and pans will last for years. And because my family does so much cooking, in the short amount of time we’ve had them, we’ve used them several times. Still, they look absolutely brand new.

Caraway cookware and bakeware in a box
Lindsay Parrill/The Manual

Will they work in any kitchen?

Cleverly and beautifully designed, these products can match almost any kitchen aesthetic. They’re traditional, yet simultaneously sleek and modern. The wide range of colors will match any kitchen, and color schemes include the following:

  • Cream
  • Navy
  • Gray
  • Sage (pictured)
  • Perracotta
  • Marigold
  • Black
  • White
  • Rose quartz
  • Silt green
  • Emerald
  • Stone
  • Midnight

As far as cabinet space, , creating storage caddies and lid pouches that fit into most standard-sized cabinets.

 Caraway pot lids in a storage lid pouch

The truth is, for the sake of credibility, we’d love to say we found even the slightest flaw with these incredible pots and pans. But as it turns out, there isn’t one.

Editors' Recommendations

Lindsay Parrill
Lindsay is a graduate of California Culinary Academy, Le Cordon Bleu, San Francisco, from where she holds a degree in…
How to soften butter: 4 easy ways (no microwave necessary)
No microwave? No problem! Soften butter quickly and easily with these tips
sliced butter

Let me guess — you’ve forgotten to take the butter out of the refrigerator. Don’t worry, it happens to the best of us. Softening butter is a crucial step in many recipes, and if you’ve forgotten to take it out of the fridge soon enough, your batter or dough will be full of gross lumps and chunks. The most common solution to this is to go straight to the microwave. That said, what if you don’t have one or prefer not to use it? 

Fortunately, there are several ways to soften butter quickly without one. With just a few common household items, it can be done in a blink of an eye.

Read more
HelloFresh alternatives: Have you considered these great options?
Meal delivery kits are wonderful — why not branch out and try something new?
Man cuts fresh salmon while looking at a tablet

Everyone loves a good meal delivery service. They're wonderful for those long, exhausting days when you're too frazzled for a chaotic grocery store run or a never-ending search through your cookbook collection, trying to decide what to make for dinner. And while there are a number of meal kit delivery services widely available these days, HelloFresh still seems to be leading in the popularity contest. But what about the others? How do they compare?
Meal kit delivery services deliver pre-portioned ingredients and instructions to make different recipes each week. Subscribers can usually select one of several -- like vegetarian or classic meals -- and the number of servings and meals they want per week. Each week, prior to the delivery day, you choose the meals you want to prepare, and the ingredients will arrive in a refrigerated box on your designated day. In this way, meal kits eliminate the need to find recipes and shop for ingredients, and they cut down on meal prep time and food waste.
HelloFresh is certainly among the most recognized names in the home meal kit delivery market. They are known for their high-quality ingredients and a wide variety of wholesome, palate-intriguing recipes. But, is there a good HelloFresh alternative or HelloFresh competitor? Or is HelloFresh the best meal kit? Are there cheaper meal kits than HelloFresh? Are there healthier meal kits? After thoroughly researching nearly two dozen of the most popular meal kit delivery subscriptions, we found the best HelloFresh alternatives and have reviewed them below.

The gold standard: HelloFresh
To compare anything, you have to have a baseline. All of the meal kits we chose as veritable HelloFresh competitors that have similar policies in terms of flexibility with choosing meals and skipping an order, changing or canceling your plan, as well as what you get in each box (ingredients and the detailed recipes). Therefore, we will mostly note the primary differences.
HelloFresh is undeniably a reputable meal kit delivery subscription service with tasty meals. Here are the fast facts:
Meal plan sizes: Customers can choose to get two or four servings of each recipe in the plan they prefer, and enough ingredients for anywhere from two to six recipes each week.
Meal plans offered: HelloFresh offers quite a few meal plans -- more than many alternative meal kit delivery subscription services. The HelloFresh meal plans include the following:

Read more
Which came first: Pasta Alfredo or Al Pacino? The Manual investigates
Who was first on the scene? Al-Pac or pasta-Al?
Al Pacino in The Godfather.

There may just be only two truly glorious, holy, and pure things left on this godforsaken earth, and we know and love them well. They both provide comfort and joy in our darkest hours. They both bring smiles to our faces and warmth to our souls. They are, respectfully, pasta Alfredo and Al Pacino.
Now, apart from the obvious similarities mentioned above, these two Italian gems have more in common than might initially meet the eye. Did you know, for example, that Pacino's full first name is not, in fact, short for Alexander or Albert? Our favorite movie star's first name is, yes, you guessed it, Alfredo. And it got us thinking -- which came first? The gun or the cannoli - no, wait, that's another article. The pasta dish or the Italian heartthrob?
It turns out that the two are not that far apart in age, either. According to Guisti d'Italia, everyone's favorite creamy pasta dish was created in Rome in 1914 by chef Alfredo di Lelio and served at his restaurant, Alfredo’s. And while revenge may be best when served cold, di Lelio served his pasta creation piping hot, swimming in butter and Parmigiano-Reggiano. The dish's popularity caught fire and soon became a staple in American cuisine.

Just 26 years later, another delicious Alfredo was born in New York City on April 25, 1940. And 32 years after that, Pacino was starring in a film that made Hollywood's head spin, along with the rest of the world's. Obviously, The Godfather quickly rose to the status it still holds to this day of being one of the greatest films of all time, but it did something even more important. The film helped the country finally shift from the stereotypically harmful and racist views of Italian-Americans the country had at the time.
So whichever Alfredo you prefer, enjoy them for their steamy deliciousness. Their ability to satisfy any kind of hunger. And their perfectly rich Italian shape and flavor. Because there's truly nothing heartbreaking about either of these 'Fredos.

Read more