Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Food & Drink

This is how much you should actually be cooking for Thanksgiving dinner

Thanksgiving dinner: We all love leftovers. But sometimes you can have too much of a good thing.

By

Look, don’t come for us. We all love Thanksgiving leftovers. The argument could even be made that the leftovers are even better than the big meal itself. Perhaps it’s because the flavors have had more time to marinate in the refrigerator, becoming even more delicious and complex than the day before. Or maybe there’s just less pressure when everyone has gone home and we can finally put on our sweatpants and carb-load in front of the TV without boring Uncle Ned talking about bitcoin. Either way, it seems everyone has a favorite Thanksgiving leftover preparation — be it another full plate, doused in a heavy pool of microwaved gravy, or a multi-layered, multi-textured sandwich, bursting at the seams with everything from stuffing to cranberry sauce. But there is such a thing as too many leftovers. Some years, it seems no matter how many plastic containers we send home with family, no matter how many delicious sandwiches we make in the days to come, in the end, we just made too much food.

Thankfully, Williams-Sonoma has created a convenient guide to help prevent an abundance of gluttony this year. Their helpful chart indicates the average amount people tend to eat of each popular Thanksgiving dish, and how much to make (or buy) of each item.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Most every traditional Thanksgiving dinner tends to consist of many, if not all of the following dishes: hors d’oeurves, turkey, gravy, salad, rolls, mashed potatoes, cranberry sauce, stuffing, and of course, dessert and wine. Of these dishes, it certainly surprised us to discover the average amount consumed by each person. What do you think?

  • Hors d’oeuvres: 4-6 bites
  • Turkey: 1 1/2 pounds bone-in turkey
  • Gravy: 1/2 cup
  • Salad: 1 1/2 cups
  • Rolls: 1-2 each
  • Mashed potatoes: 1/2 pound
  • Cranberry sauce: 1/3 cup
  • Stuffing: 3/4 cup
  • Dessert: 2 small pieces pie or cake
  • Wine: 1/2 – 1 bottle
Recommended Videos

Of course, no one knows your family’s eating habits better than you do. If we’re being totally honest, the thought of a mere half cup of gravy per person seems more than a little bit absurd, but maybe that’s just us. Either way, perhaps this helpful guide will make your Thanksgiving dinner plans and preparations a little easier this year. Because if there’s one thing you don’t want to stress about when it comes time to clean up the mess, it’s making room for the abundance of extra food in the fridge.

But if you ask us, maybe just make a little more gravy than the chart calls for.

Lindsay Parrill
Lindsay Parrill
Contributor
Lindsay is a graduate of California Culinary Academy, Le Cordon Bleu, San Francisco, from where she holds a degree in…

Editors’ Recommendations

Stop cooking pork like it’s 1995 — the rules have changed
Why pink pork is safe (and actually way more delicious)
Pork chops on cutting board

If you grew up in a household where pork chops were slim enough to double as bookmarks and so overcooked that they squeaked against your teeth, you’re not alone. For decades, American home cooks treated pork the way they treated chicken during a salmonella scare: as something to be scorched into submission in the name of safety. This wasn’t just your mom being overly cautious — it was advice straight from the USDA. In the ’80s and ’90s, the official pork cooking temperature was a hard-and-fast 160°F, and by the time meat reached that point, it was about as juicy as a kitchen sponge.
The culprit behind this era of gray, sawdust-dry pork? A tiny parasitic worm called Trichinella spiralis — better known as the cause of trichinosis. Back then, it was a real concern, and overcooking was the only weapon home cooks had against it. But here’s the thing: farming practices have changed, the risk is almost nonexistent, and the USDA has lowered the recommended safe temperature to 145°F. Which means if you’re still cooking pork like it’s 1995, you’re missing out on the juicy, tender, actually delicious version of it.
Clinging to outdated pork-cooking rules is like still microwaving your coffee in a foam cup — technically possible, but why would you? The science has changed, the product has changed, and the official guidelines have changed. It’s time our cooking habits caught up.

Why pork got such a bad reputation

Read more
How to make Tequila Corralejo’s Cocoa Old Fashioned
Cocoa Old Fashioned.

Hispanic Heritage Month is coming up and that calls for some deep dives into fascinating cultures. A great way to do so is by way of food, whether that's a dish from traditional Mexican cuisine or a cocktail that honors a specific place. It's a great way to experience the flavors of the world and broaden your palate.

A tequila brand reached out with a cocktail we could not resist. It's a Mexican riff on a classic drink, treated to an agave spirit, chocolate, and peppers. It's a great way to showcase the dynamic nature of tequila.

Read more
How to mix a mini mezcal Cosmo straight out of the ’90s
A 90s cocktail icon given the agave spirits treatment
Mezcal Union Cosmopolitan.

Labor Day Weekend may be over but the calendar still says summer for another few weeks. Make the most of it with a refreshing drink, whether that's a non-alcoholic beer after a long hike or trying your hand at a frozen cocktail recipe at home. Whatever you're in the mood for, we've likely got it here at The Manual.

Mini cocktails are enjoying the moment, the product of folks wanting to moderate a bit (or just have more smaller drinks). We're seeing them in bars across the land, from Los Angeles to New York City. And we just got a great recipe from an agave spirits brand we like. Best, the drink plays the nostalgia game and throws some love at the 90s.

Read more