Skip to main content

Shaken vs. stirred: The ultimate cocktail showdown

Stirred or shaken depends on your desired result and what you're mixing

Dirty martini
Johann Trasch / Unsplash

Ever since Sean Connery strolled onto the screen as James Bond in 1964’s Goldfinger and asked for his martini “Shaken, not stirred,” people have been debating the right way to make a vodka martini. It’s a subject that inspires bartenders to roll their eyes and plenty of drinkers to worry about whether they are ordering their martini correctly.

The truth is that most experts would strongly agree that a martini should be stirred, not shaken. Shaking a martini will give you a watery, cloudy, and frankly rather sad drink, while stirring it should result in a crystal clear, elegantly proportioned drink. But other cocktail recipes will specify that they should be shaken, not stirred — especially if they contain fruit juice. That’s because you need to pick the right method for the cocktail you’re making. Shaken vs. stirred depends on what you’re trying to mix.

Recommended Videos

Is it better to shake or stir?

Martini with three olives
Stanislav Ivanitskiy / Unsplash

There’s no easy answer to this question. There are cocktails where shaking is more appropriate and drinks where mixing is the better technique. Below, we’re going to take a look at when you should use each technique.

When to shake

In addition to the alcoholic elements, any cocktail that also uses dairy products, eggs, or fresh juice should be shaken. Shaking adds air bubbles to the drink, which adds a bit of creamy froth. It is also a better way to combine fresh fruit juices with other ingredients. Finally, can you imagine attempting to stir cream into a drink or an egg white? Good luck with that.

When to stir

While shaking is the best option for more complex, ingredient-filled cocktails, stirring is the better choice for simple cocktails. Stir your drink when it is much heavier in the booze department. When a drink is mostly (or all) alcohol, you wouldn’t want to shake it. Stirring with ice will keep the drink clear, limit the dilution, and help chill it. Shaking it will make it cloudy and watery.

When both are wrong

It might seem like you should choose one or the other when it comes to cocktailing. But when it comes to certain highball drinks, the better option is to simply build it. If you’re making a whiskey highball, you’ll want to add the whiskey and then top it with soda water. The same goes for sparkling wine-based drinks like the French 75.

Why do bartenders shake or stir drinks?

Strawberry Frida mixed cocktail with UNA Vodka at bar
UNA

You might be wondering why bartenders bother to shake or stir drinks at all. If it’s just to make the drinks cold, then why not keep the spirits in the fridge or freezer and serve them that way? The answer is because shaking and stirring doesn’t only chill a drink, but it also dilutes it. That might sound unappealing — who wants a watery cocktail? — but it’s really important to keep a drink balanced.

To see why this is, try taking the ingredients of your favorite cocktail and mixing them together without ice or water. The result will almost certainly taste harsh and unbalanced, with far too much boozy heft. You need at least a little bit of water in there to help the flavors mix together properly and to give you a better drinking experience.

The key is the amount of water to add. Shaking tends to add more dilution than stirring, and the exact amount of dilution depends on lots of factors including the size, shape, and amount of ice you’re using as well as how long you stir or shake for. But cocktails will typically have around 20% to 30% of their total volume made up of water.

Why does James Bond have his martinis shaken, not stirred?

Martini
Ambitious Studio* - Rick Barrett / Unsplash

While the first-time audiences heard 007 ordering a drink “shaken” was in Goldfinger, the first reference was in Ian Fleming’s 1956 James Bond novel Diamonds Are Forever. There’s not a lot of information as to why James Bond preferred his martinis shaken vs. stirred. Many believe that it just sounds cooler than “stirred, not shaken.”

However, it’s not like Fleming was clueless when it came to the world of martinis. He was the creator of Bond’s originally preferred martini variation in the books, known as the Vesper martini. This delicious take on the classic uses both vodka and gin for the best of both worlds, offering the thick and creamy mouthfeel of chilled vodka as well as the deep flavors of gin. It also incorporates Lillet in place of dry vermouth, making it more bitter and herbal and less fruity. It’s a great drink, and it’s traditionally shaken — just as Bond orders it.

In the case of the Vesper martini, it arguably makes a little more sense to shake than to stir, as due to the generous pour of Lillet, the drink is going to be somewhat cloudy anyway. The crystal clear ,artini is only achievable through stirring when a small amount of vermouth is used. And some bartenders argue that vodka benefits more than gin from shaking, as its texture changes when it gets very cold.

Most would still say that even a Vesper martini would be better stirred than shaken, but there’s more justification for Bond’s preferences if he’s drinking a Vesper than a classic gin martini.

What is the difference between shaken and stirred?

Vodka martini
Brent Hofacker / Adobe Stock

As we mentioned earlier, there are major differences between shaking and stirring. But, if you take a moment to think about it, the differences are quite obvious. Shaking a drink involves adding all the ingredients to a shaker with or without ice before straining it into your glass. Stirring, on the other hand, involves adding all of your ingredients to an ice-filled glass. You simply stir gently to combine everything. The finished product is much different.

Can you taste the difference between shaken and stirred martini?

Dirty martini
Eric Hood / Adobe Stock

Shaking a martini will add bubbles and cloudiness to your drink. While you won’t be able to taste the hazy appearance, you might notice the added air in the drink. You’ll also notice that the drink tastes much more watery than most drinkers would prefer. If you enjoy the flavor of gin (or vodka) and vermouth, you won’t want to shake your martini.

Why is an Old Fashioned stirred and not shaken?

Old Fashioned
Pylyp Sukhenko / Unsplash

Since the classic Old Fashioned is made with whiskey, sugar, water, and bitters, it should never be prepared in a shaker. This is because, even though it contains a handful of non-alcoholic ingredients, it’s primarily whiskey. Stirring combines all the ingredients without diluting the flavors by adding air or watering it down.

Bottom line

Gin cocktail
Toni Cuenca / Pexels

There’s a time and place for both stirring and mixing your cocktails. The key is understanding when each technique is correct based on the included ingredients and not listening to a fictional secret agent who doesn’t know anything about the art of bartending.

Christopher Osburn
Christopher Osburn is a food and drinks writer located in the Finger Lakes Region of New York. He's been writing professional
Country singer Dierks Bentley is releasing a new, limited-release bourbon
Launched to coincide with his new album, Dierks Bentley is releasing a new whiskey
Whiskey glass

Dierks Bentley is a country music star. He also launched his own whiskey brand, ROW 94, in September 2024 in collaboration with the historic Green River Distilling Co. in Owensboro, Kentucky. Recently, the brand announced the release of a new, limited-release bourbon.
ROW 94 Broken Branches

Named for his new album, it was made in partnership with Lofted Custom Spirits at the Green River Distilling Co. It begins with a mash bill of 70% Kentucky-grown corn, 21% rye, and 9% malted and row barley. It's matured for at least five years in new, level 4 charred American oak barrels using "Branch Aging" with fire-toasted oak staves seasoned for up to twenty-four months.

Read more
Michter’s releases two legacy whiskeys packed with flavor and heritage
Micher's is releasing two historic, timeless whiskeys
Michter's

If you're already a fan of Michter's iconic whiskeys like Michter's US-1 Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey, Michter's US-1 Toasted Barrel Finish Bourbon, or the iconic Michter's 10-Year Kentucky Straight Bourbon, you'll be excited to learn about the popular brand's two new releases set to hit store shelves this month.
Shenk's Homestead Kentucky Sour Mash Whiskey and Bomberger's Declaration Kentucky Straight Bourbon

This month, the distillery will release two whiskeys in its Michter's Legacy Series: Shenk's Homestead Kentucky Sour Mash Whiskey and Bomberger's Declaration Kentucky Straight Bourbon.

Read more
World Whiskey Society is launching a bourbon that’s finished in a rare, Japanese cask
World Whiskey Society's newest bourbon was dubbed "Samurai Edition"
Whiskey in a glass

Fans of exceptional, unique whiskey know all about the World Whiskey Society's prowess. Founded in 2020, this brand strives to bring rare, ultra-premium expressions to whiskey drinkers' home bars and liquor cabinets. Its newest whiskey combines America's "native spirit" with the aging techniques popularized in Japan.
Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Finished In Japanese Mizunara Shochu Barrels

To say this whiskey is unique is an understatement. This 108-proof Kentucky straight bourbon dubbed the "Samurai Edition" begins with a mash bill of 75% corn, 13% rye, and 12% malted barley. Originating at the renowned Bardstown Bourbon Company, it's first matured in charred white American oak barrels before being finished in rare Japanese Mizunara oak casks previously used to age Shochu.

Read more