Skip to main content

From roasted to dressed, a chef’s guide to upgrading your oysters

These tips might just blow your mind

Plate of raw oysters
Selection of raw oysters at Sagaponack Benvenuti Public Relations

Oysters, those bite-sized bursts of ocean flavor that’s sweet, briny, and complex, are often enjoyed unadorned — raw. But sometimes, these same delicious shellfish can be tasty with extra sauces or roasted with various spices and ingredients.

At the restaurant Sagaponack, managing partner Kyung il Lee and Executive Chef Phil Choy are serving up innovative takes on these beloved shellfish. While there are plenty of delicious ways to cook oysters, Chef Choy takes inspiration from Asian and Mediterranean flavors, combining those elements with an Eastern Long Island aesthetic at the restaurant. For Chef Choy, oysters can be dressed or roasted, spanning flavor combinations like Adamas Siberian caviar, buttermilk, and yogurt to gochujang butter with serrano pepper, scallion, and sesame breadcrumbs.

Trio of dressed oysters at Sagaponack
Trio of dressed oysters at Sagaponack.Cucumber with yuzu kosho and dil (left). Fresno chili , serrano, shallot (center). Adamas Siberian caviar with buttermilk and yogurt (right). Ben Hon

Dress oysters with a creamy blend of buttermilk and yogurt

Showcasing both East Coast and West Coast oysters, Sagaponack features several varieties of dressed oysters, including a refreshing option that’s topped with yuzu kosho and dill. Oysters work particularly well with bright flavors like citrus and green herbs. Caviar is another classic pairing. But, sometimes, it helps to think outside the box regarding flavors.

“Caviar and oysters are a timeless culinary combination,” explains Chef Choy. “But we wanted to elevate this pairing by infusing it with our own unique twist. Our buttermilk is a carefully crafted blend of yogurt powder and fresh lemon juice, enhanced with the addition of gelatin for a delightful textural dimension. This innovative approach allows us to introduce our guests to the exquisite fusion of caviar and oysters in a whole new light.”

Chef Choy explains that they make caviar cream with buttermilk, sour cream, yogurt powder, lemon juice, and gelatin. “We bloom the gelatin sheet in ice water for 5 minutes and squeeze dry,” explains Chef Choy. “We then combine the bloomed gelatin with a small amount of buttermilk in a pot and gently warm while mixing until the gelatin is dissolved. Remove from heat and combine with remaining ingredients over an ice bath. Cool, mixing it every few minutes. We put a spoonful of the caviar cream onto the raw oyster, add 4 grams of caviar on top with chopped chives, then serve.”

Two roasted oysters with black background
(Left) Vadouvan Curry & Brown Butter Roasted Oysters Sagavibes / Instagram

For roasted oysters, use Korean chili paste

One of Chef Choy’s favorite roasted flavor combinations takes inspiration from Korean cuisine, particularly gochujang, combining it with a shellfish favorite — butter.

“In Korean culinary tradition, braised pork belly is traditionally accompanied by raw oysters and a subtly spicy paste known as 쌈장 (ssamjang),” explains Chef Choy. “Our interpretation of the roasted oyster experience combines the bold flavors of gochujang (고추장), serrano peppers, rich butter, garlic, pepper, a delectable sesame crumble, and the freshness of scallions.”

To make the gochuchang butter, Chef Choy seeds and chops a serrano chili and combines it with microplaned garlic, rice vinegar, tempered butter, and Aleppo pepper. Then, he whisks until it’s homogeneous, adds the mixture to the oysters, squeezes some lime juice, and blasts them in the oven for roughly 5 minutes. Once the oysters are cooked, Chef Choy tops each oyster with sesame crumbs and a scallion ribbon.

Editors' Recommendations

Hunter Lu
Hunter Lu is a New York-based food and features writer, editor, and NYU graduate. His fiction has appeared in The Line…
How to grill vegetables: Your complete guide
It's easier than you think
Grilled vegetables

When contemplating all of the delicious ingredients to grill this summer, things like burgers, steaks, brats, and ribs may be the juicy, meaty images floating through your mind - and for good reason. There's something absolutely magical about charred, smokey meats straight off the coals. But that savory grilled flavor doesn't begin and end with meat. In fact, your entire meal can (and should) be made all together on the grill, proteins, sides, and all. And one of our favorite smokey sides is grilled vegetables. Grilled vegetables are truly something special and very easy to prepare if you follow a few simple guidelines.

So, when stocking up on your favorite barbecue fare this weekend, don't forget to make a stop in the produce section. Because grilled vegetables are about to become your new favorite side dish.
How to prepare vegetables for grilling

Read more
12 best breakfast recipes to start your day right
Even if you're not a purported home chef, you can whip up these delicious morning meals
Waffle breakfast sandwich with chorizo recipe

Breakfast doesn't have to be boring, even on busy mornings. In a bowl, on a plate, or in between two slices of toast, there are endless breakfast ideas and ways to enjoy the most important meal of the day. From upgraded oatmeal to weekday waffles and breakfast sandwiches with a twist, we've gathered some of the best breakfast recipes ever in one delicious list.
Waffle and chorizo breakfast sandwich

(from PureWow)

Read more
How to reheat steak the right way (and more tips and tricks)
This two-step process will make your leftover meat just as tasty as the first time
Reheating steak in an oven

Say you’ve perfectly cooked a 12-ounce steak and gotten that beautiful golden sear outside. You look forward to a night of feasting only to realize there is too much steak left on the platter after the meal. You then pack the leftover steak in a container, store it in the fridge, and hope it’s still as perfect as it was.

Steak -- whether it’s filet mignon, hanger, rib-eye, or sirloin -- is an expensive food item and it seems wasteful to just throw any leftovers. What do you do then? Reheat it the next day in the hopes it doesn't dry out and still tastes as good as the night before.

Read more