Skip to main content

This NYC restaurant is upgrading burgers with a new type of American cheese

We tried the Double-Smash Cheeseburger at Hoexter's to learn all about this cheese

Hoexter's Smashburger.
The Double-Smash Cheese Burger at Hoexter's. Hoexter's

For many burger purists, there’s only one suitable cheese for the classic American burger — creamy and salty American cheese. But for others, American cheese is overprocessed and lacks the depth of flavor compared to cheddar or Swiss. The good news is that there’s something called “New School” American cheese, which combines the great melt of processed American cheese with higher-quality ingredients.

An excellent way to try out New School American cheese is the Double-Smash Cheeseburger at Hoexter’s. An American brasserie in Manhattan’s Upper East Side, Hoexter’s is making a classic double patty smash burger that showcases this product. We interviewed them and tried the burger to learn more.

Recommended Videos

What is New School American Cheese?

New School American cheese on a black background
eatnewschool / Instagram / New School American Cheese

First, what exactly is New School American cheese? Regular American cheese, while tasty, is also filled with an assortment of processed ingredients, such as coloring and modified food starch. For certain people, this can be off-putting.

New School American cheese, created by Chef Eric Greenspan and entrepreneur Alan Leavitt, aims to capture the melty texture of classic American cheese with better ingredients. According to the ingredient list on the New School American cheese website, the product includes aged cheddar cheese (pasteurized cultured milk, salt, enzymes), water, cream, sodium citrate, butter (cream), salt, paprika, and turmeric.

“I am absolutely in love with this product,” said Alexandra Shapiro, owner of Hoexter’s. “I love the flavor, I love the way it melts, I love the tang. I love the better ingredients. It reminds me of the American cheese my grandmother would buy when I was little.”

What does it taste like?

Hoexter's smashburger closeup
Double-Smash Cheeseburger at Hoexter’s Hoexter's

We were able to try the Double-Smash Cheeseburger at Hoexter’s and found it to be an excellent rendition of an upgraded classic. The burger is straightforward — meat, cheese, special sauce, and pickles. The 80/20 patties are thin and made with a combination of sirloin, brisket, and short rib, all sourced from Allen Brothers, a premier meat purveyor. The result is a tasty burger that satisfies any burger craving.

Particularly, the choice of two thin patties is not only for aesthetic reasons. “There is something special about two thin patties,” Shapiro explained. “It gives you more surface area for char on each patty and more room for cheese.” The burger also features a special sauce. Tasting it, we found the special sauce to be quite mustard-forward, which in our opinion is a good balance to the richness of the beef and cheese.

Perhaps most importantly, each patty is also topped with a slice of New School American cheese. One bite, and we can conclude that this is an excellent cheese for burgers. It has the melty texture of classic American cheese but with the funk of a good quality cheddar.

Hunter Lu
Hunter Lu is a New York-based food and features writer, editor, and NYU graduate. His fiction has appeared in The Line…
Topics
Gorgonzola vs. blue cheese: Similar, yet different flavor profiles
You may love them both, but do you know how they differ?
Blue cheese

 

 

Read more
You can now get MEATER’s new Pro XL meat thermometer, and it’s well worth the investment
MEATER actually makes using a meat thermometer a fun experience
Meater meat thermometer

If you spend a lot of time (as we do) grilling, roasting, pan-frying, and poaching, you understand the need for a truly great meat thermometer. It's one of those tools that people try to avoid using, opting instead for little tricks like comparing the feel of the meat to the palm of your hand to test its doneness. We've all tried these little "hacks," and we've probably all ended up under or (worse) over-cooking a piece of meat because of them.
It's time to shake the stigma around using meat thermometers. They're the only surefire way to guarantee your meat ends up cooked to the exact temperature you're craving. If you've been holding off on buying this essential part of any kitchen tool collection, now is the time to strike.

MEATER, one of the biggest names in smart meat thermometers, has just launched a brand-new, top-of-the-line collection headed by their latest product, the MEATER Pro XL.
The MEATER Pro XL has four separate probes with one centralized digital charging hub, providing users with the versatility to cook multiple dishes simultaneously and utilize different cooking methods. This way, you can enjoy a perfectly cooked medium-rare steak, and Uncle George can still get his medium-well, all using the same thermometer unit. The new unit also boasts strong wireless connectivity with unlimited range, a USB-charging system, precision-calibrated probes, smart-temp multi-sensors, an easy-to-use app, and a sleek, ultra-slim design you'll be proud to show off at your next cookout.
MEATER's clever wireless design is the first of its kind, allowing any chef to thoroughly enjoy using a meat thermometer and getting incredibly delicious results, every time.

Read more
What’s in a $50 burger?
The Fifty Dollar Burger breakdown
The $50 burger at Brasada Ranch.

When you put a $50 burger on the menu, it better deliver. Sure, things are more expensive than ever, but that's still a pretty penny to pay for some meat and a bun. Well, Brasada Ranch in central Oregon has debuted the luxe dish and it's worth every dollar.

The resort's top restaurant, Wild Rye, debuted the Fifty Dollar Burger earlier this summer. Chef Karl Holl is responsible, along with other outstanding additions to the menu, from juniper-braised lamb shank with wild rye risotto, summer squash, turnips, and huckleberries to grilled maitake mushrooms with braised greens, polenta, and hot sauce butter.

Read more