Skip to main content

Study: Which fast food restaurant gives you the worst bang for your buck?

Fast-casual restaurants: Where customers say they get the most value for their money

Whether we care to admit it or not, we all have our favorite fast-food restaurants. For all the bad rap they get, there’s really just no comparing their convenience or ability to satisfy that insane, so-bad-it’s-good, otherworldy craving for a greasy brown bagged burger and fries. Say what you will about the extra fat and calories, overly processed ingredients, and insane levels of sodium and cholesterol. At the end of the day, sometimes you’ve just got to give in and be bad.

And while we all have our favorites, from McDonald’s to Jimmy John’s, in a recent study, some fast-casual restaurants fared better than others when it came down to the best bang for your buck.

Joshua Resnick / Shutterstock

The most expensive fast-casual/fast-food restaurants in the U.S.

The study, conducted by Stifel, looked at some of the major fast-food and fast-casual restaurants and their average prices per meal across 20 cities.

  1. Panera Bread: $14.76
  2. Chipotle: $14.34
  3. Blaze Pizza: $13.72
  4. Shake Shack: $13.50
  5. Jersey Mike’s: $13.23
  6. MOD Pizza: $12.68
  7. Jimmy John’s: $11.06
  8. Panda Express: $10.32
  9. Wendy’s: $9.89
  10. Taco Bell: $9.69
Recommended Videos

This isn’t a list of every chain out there — Five Guys, for instance, was not included in the study. However, it does provide a snapshot of pricing. Unsurprisingly, Panera Bread and Chipotle topped the list of the most expensive restaurants. A given, considering very few would expect to pay the same amount for a fresh steak burrito as they would drive-thru chicken nuggets. But the lack of surprise ends there.

1,280 people were surveyed and asked, “Which restaurant(s) do you believe have become too expensive for what you get?” Unexpectedly, the overwhelming response was Shake Shack. While it’s only the fourth most expensive restaurant on the list of those studied, those polled strongly agreed that the amount and quality of food were considerably lacking for its cost.

MarketWatch reports that a Shake Shack representative, upon hearing this report, simply referred to the following statement from a recent company earnings report: “In menu innovation, we continue to lead the way with dynamic and fun products, providing our guests with elevated, premium, high-quality ingredients that they can’t find in traditional fast food, other fast-casual concepts or even casual dining. A Shack burger, fries, and beverage is on average under $14, well within and often priced below the cost of other lunch or dinner options nearby.”

Sorry, Shake Shack. Dynamic and fun are all well and good, but it seems the people want something you’re not providing.

Classic, tried-and-true staples of American cuisine, McDonald’s and Taco Bell, however, continue to impress customers despite inflation costs. The study found that despite being two of the three lowest-priced options, their satisfaction rates were unmatched by any other restaurant.

Here’s how the rest of the restaurants in the study fared (the list goes from least value for money, according to survey participants, to most):

  1. Shake Shack
  2. Blaze Pizza
  3. Mod Pizza
  4. Panera Bread
  5. Chick-fil-A
  6. Panda Express
  7. Chipotle
  8. Jersey Mike’s
  9. Jimmy John’s
  10. Wendy’s
  11. Taco Bell
  12. McDonald’s

Where does your favorite guilty pleasure restaurant fall on the list?

Lindsay Parrill
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Lindsay is a graduate of California Culinary Academy, Le Cordon Bleu, San Francisco, from where she holds a degree in…
Coffee on the carnivore diet: Do you need to give it up?
What to know about consuming coffee on a carnivore diet
Cups of long black coffee

Throughout the seven years I've followed a low-carb or ketogenic diet, I've tested the world of the carnivore diet multiple times. The carnivore diet takes a low-carb diet to the next level as a no-carb diet, which consists only of animal proteins. From weight loss benefits to enhanced mental clarity, people choose to try carnivore diets for many reasons.

The carnivore diet can be followed in several ways, from rigorous forms to more relaxed and liberal variations. When I first tried it, one of my biggest concerns was giving up my true love: coffee. As it turns out, some diet versions allow for coffee, making it much more straightforward to adhere to (if you ask me).

Read more
Cold brew vs. espresso: Which one should you order next time?
Comparing flavor, caffeine content, and acidity
Cold brew coffee

Whenever I visit a coffee shop or find myself in a coffee drive-through, my mind runs through dozens of orders. A cold brew is an excellent order for when I'm in the mood for something to sip on slowly, but a shot of espresso hits the spot when I want something fast and slightly bitter. Though I love both coffee drinks, there's a right time and a place to order a cold brew vs. an espresso. Below, let's compare cold brew vs. espresso regarding acidity, caffeine content, and taste. Next time you find yourself unsure which to order you'll go with, you'll remember these differences.
Brewing time and method

According to La Colombe Coffee Trainer Rachael Guerrieri, “Cold brew and espresso are as different as you can get. Cold brew is a coarse grind with cold or room-temperature water. During the brewing process, the coffee and water spend a ton of time together to get the perfect brew - think 8-24 hours! On the other hand, espresso is a super fine grind, made with really hot water in about 25 seconds." Guerrieri is La Colombe's East Coast trainer and has over 15 years of experience as a barista and coffee trainer.

Read more
Dirty Sue is launching premium pickle juice to help you up your cocktail game
Dirty Sue is finally launching a pickle juice
Dirty Sue

Have you ever had a Pickleback? If not, you’re really missing out on a boozy, tangy treat. In the simplest terms, a Pickleback is a shot of liquor (usually a bourbon, rye, or other whiskey) directly followed by a shot of pickle juice or brine. The tangy, salty, spicy pickle juice perfectly offsets the warmth of the alcohol.

It’s a surprisingly great combination. And while you can dump out some juice from your favorite Kosher dills or sweet gherkins, wouldn’t you buy a bottle made specifically for a Pickleback instead?
Dirty Sue Premium Pickle Juice

Read more