Skip to main content

291 Single Barrel Colorado Rye Whiskey Review

Located in Colorado Springs, Distillery 291 was born when New York City fashion photographer Michael Myers realized he needed to get out of dodge. That was 2011. Since opening, Distillery 291 has produced five kinds of whiskey (a bourbon, unaged rye, an American whiskey mellowed with Aspen charcoal, and an unaged corn whiskey), as well as a citrus clove whisky liqueur.


What separates this rye whiskey from other rye whiskies on the market is the finish. Where some whiskies (like Maker’s 46, for example) may finish with French oak, a common type of wood used in liquor-making, Distillery 291 finishes their Colorado Rye Whiskey with aspen staves — which, coming from Colorado seems appropriate.

Distillery 291 Colorado Rye Whiskey
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Appearance: Distillery 291 Colorado Rye Whiskey shines bright like a new penny.

Nose: The rye spice characteristics come through first and foremost, and these are rounded out by notes of cooked fruit and fruit cake. A hint of pine can also be found mixed in there.

Palate: A beery, sweet malty flavor is one of the most prevalent you will get upon first sip. It is bright and almost effervescent, leading you into baking spices and caramel that remind you that you’re working with a rye whiskey aged in new barrels. There is a certain heat on the back end, due to both the age of the whiskey (less than two years) and the high proof (101.7).

Finish: As we get near the holiday season, the finish on this whiskey seems appropriate, as it tastes very Christmas-y. You’ll get nutmeg and cinnamon mixing with a cedar woodiness. The flavors linger on the palate for a while.

Final thoughts: For a young whiskey, this is more enjoyable than many I’ve had. I’m curious to see what these whiskies would taste like once they’ve got a few more years in barrels. The real hang-up for most will be the price — at around $70 per bottle, it might be hard for some to justify splurging on a whiskey that is so young. However, we think if you appreciate well-made whiskey (and you have the money to spend), it’s worth giving it a try. It’s a whiskey that is good for putting in a flask and going camping in order to brave those cold mountain nights, or for using in a rye whiskey cocktail, as the flavor and proof will stand up to other ingredients.

Distillery 291 Colorado Rye Whiskey is 50.8 percent ABV and retails for around $70.

Feature image courtesy of Distillery 291/Facebook.

Editors' Recommendations

Sam Slaughter
Sam Slaughter was the Food and Drink Editor for The Manual. Born and raised in New Jersey, he’s called the South home for…
Tincup Releases New Rye Whiskey
Tin Cup Whiskey

As rye whiskey continues to grow in popularity, established whiskey brands and distilleries continue to add it to their portfolios. And many of them continue to source whiskey from the experts at MGP, the Indiana distillery that is responsible for so much of the rye whiskey out there sold under various brand names like Bulleit, Dickel, and Redemption. The latest to release a rye whiskey is Colorado's Tincup, adding it to its lineup of original (a blend of bourbon and single malt) and 10-year-old American whiskey.

The rye is distilled in Indiana from a mash bill of 95% rye and 5% malted barley, aged for three years, and cut with Colorado Rocky Mountain water to proof it down to 90. The whiskey reads as young but flavorful, with balsa wood notes on the nose and a sweet palate full of notes of freshly cut grass, soft spice, and vanilla flavors. In fact, it does not immediately comes across as your typical 95/5 rye, because of the toned-down nature of the baking spice and fruit notes that are often predominant with that mash bill. Overall, this is a good mixing rye that would work well in a variety of cocktails.

Read more
Rabbit Hole London Dry Gin Review: Great for Whiskey Lovers
rabbit hole london dry gin cocktail

We’re no strangers to barrel-aged gins here at The Manual. Whether it is the peated Big Gin or, more recently, Starbucks’ adventure into the gin barrel-aged coffee market, we like it when two of our favorite spirits are brought together.

This time, that combination of whiskey and gin comes to us in the form of Rabbit Hole's London Dry Gin, which is aged in char #3 Kentucky Rye barrels. Rabbit Hole, which is based in Louisville, imports the gin from London before aging it in their own Kentucky rye barrels for a short period of time.

Read more
Pittsburgh’s Wigle Whiskey Releases New Spirits
Wigle Whiskey Rudolph

Wigle Whiskey, a craft distillery located in Pittsburgh, has a bunch of new whiskeys and other spirits that are out just in time for the holidays.

First up is one of the most exciting, Deep Cut Bottled in Bond Rye. This organic rye whiskey was made from a mash bill of 65% rye, 18% wheat, and 17% barley, bottled at 100 proof as required by law, and aged for five years in new charred oak barrels. Then there is Rudolph Whiskey, a straight wheat whiskey that was aged in Christmas Ale barrels from Great Lakes Brewing Co., giving it a bit of spice.

Read more