Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Food & Drink

This secret to a perfectly browned steak is almost impossible to believe

This counterintuitive method will give you a beautifully browned steak every time

Lindsay Parrill
By
Porter house steak
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Every once in a while, a new piece of information goes against everything we’ve been taught, and it’s pretty mind-blowing. It turns out, cursive is useless, Pluto isn’t a planet, and we do carry around a calculator with us all the time (sorry, 1990s-era teachers). From time to time, these new truths also hit the food world, and when they do, it’s pretty exciting.

For as long as we can remember, the key to a good sear on steak has been fat and fast, high heat. Anything else would create a grayish, lackluster piece of meat that was hardly appetizing. But there’s a new trick in town about cooking steak — water. While cooking a steak in water sounds counterintuitive when it comes to proper searing, if done correctly, this technique can create a beautifully browned, perfectly seared, deliciously juicy piece of meat. So, how is this possibly the best way to cook steak, you ask?

Recommended Videos

Different types of browning in food

The science behind this new cooking method is pretty interesting. In cooking, there are two types of browning — caramelization and Maillard. Caramelization happens when sugars in certain foods are heated past 300 degrees Fahrenheit. When these sugars break down, we get browned, flavorful, sometimes jammy and sweet foods like caramelized onions. Maillard browning occurs when sugars and amino acids break down and reform in proteins like beef, pork, or chicken.

Related

Why water works

Water has traditionally been the enemy of good browning because water turns to steam, which prevents pan heat from getting hot enough to create a proper sear, and that’s where colorless meat comes from. If you cook your meat thoroughly this way, it will end up sear-less and gray, which is just gross, any way you slice it.

However, suppose you add a bit of water to the pan first and simmer your meat just until that water evaporates. What will happen is that the sugars and amino acids will release from your protein, staying behind once the water has evaporated. Essentially, the water pulls the flavor and color out of the meat, leaving it for you to turn into something delicious.

To prevent poaching or steaming your protein, only add a few splashes of water. This is where it’s easy to go wrong. Remember, you’re not trying to cook your meat fully. You’re only giving it enough time to give up some of its extra flavor. Only a few splashes are necessary, no matter what you’re cooking.

This method also works perfectly for vegetables, and even mushrooms, which are hard to sear properly. With a bit of water applied in just the right way, almost everything you make can have a beautifully browned caramelization packed full of flavor. We tried this recipe for sauteed mushrooms with shallot and thyme using this method, and they were the best we’ve ever had!

Sauteed mushrooms and shallots with thyme
America's Test Kitchen / a

Sauteed mushrooms with shallot and thyme

(From America’s Test Kitchen)

Ingredients:

  • 1 1/4 pounds mushrooms, halved
  • 1/4 cup water
  • 1/2 teaspoon vegetable oil
  • 1 tablespoon unsalted butter
  • 1 shallot, minced
  • 1 tablespoon fresh thyme, minced
  • 1/4 teaspoon table salt
  • 1/4 teaspoon pepper
  • 1/4 cup dry Marsala
  • 1/2 cup chicken broth

Method:

  1. Cook mushrooms and water in a 12-inch nonstick skillet over high heat, stirring occasionally, until skillet is almost dry and mushrooms begin to sizzle, 4 to 8 minutes.
  2. Reduce heat to medium-high. Add oil and toss until mushrooms are evenly coated. Continue to cook, stirring occasionally, until mushrooms are well browned, 4 to 8 minutes longer. Reduce heat to medium.
  3. Push mushrooms to the side of the skillet. Add butter to the center.
  4. When the butter has melted, add shallot, thyme, salt, and pepper to the center and cook, stirring constantly, until aromatic, about 30 seconds.
  5. Add Marsala and stir the mixture into the mushrooms. Cook, stirring occasionally, until liquid has evaporated, 2 to 3 minutes.
  6. Add broth and cook, stirring occasionally, until glaze is reduced by half, 2 to 3 minutes.
  7. Season with salt and pepper to taste, and serve.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics
Lindsay Parrill
Lindsay Parrill
Contributor
Lindsay is a graduate of California Culinary Academy, Le Cordon Bleu, San Francisco, from where she holds a degree in…
What is a barrique? Exploring wine’s most popular barrel size
Learn about these wooden vessels made famous by vintners in Bordeaux
Wine barrel barrique

Walk into any winery on planet Earth and you’re sure to run into a barrel or two. Most commonly, these barrels are barriques, the wooden vessels made famous by vintners in Bordeaux and known for their ability to gently bring a wine from fermented juice to something well integrated and special.
Think of the barrique as the most common size of wooden barrel out there. It holds 225 liters, or about 59 gallons, making it immensely heavy when full (over 500 pounds). Yet, thanks to barrel racks and forklifts, it can be stacked elegantly in cellar spaces and climbed upon by intrepid cellar hands carrying out their day-to-day winemaking tasks.

The barrique basics

Read more
Here’s how to crawfish boil the right way (and everything else there is to know about crawfish)
Crawfish is a Southern staple and in season right now. Here's how to properly prepare this seafood
A southern Crawfish plate

Crawfish, crayfish, crawdads, freshwater lobsters, mountain lobsters, yabbies, or mudbugs -- whatever you call them, one thing remains the same: They're delicious. That is; when they're prepared correctly. If you live above the Mason-Dixon line, you may not have heard of any of these cousins to the lobster, and that's totally normal. Crawfish are everywhere, but the vast majority of the world's eating crayfish come from Louisiana (around 95%).

The end of March to early June is prime crayfish season (when they grow to be the largest). That's why crawfish boils are common around the middle of spring to early summer. Despite being at their largest around this time, they're still pretty small. A jumbo crayfish will provide about as much meat as an average-sized shrimp. So, after you learn how to eat crawfish, you're going to need to eat a lot -- we suggest around 3 to 5 pounds per person. This seems like a ton, but you have to remember that these little buggers are mostly shell. And the secret of a good crawfish boil is to not overcook them, or the meat becomes tough.

Read more
Pro tips from Chef Eduardo Garcia for cooking outdoors like a true mountain man
Here's how to really cook like a mountain man
Chef Eduardo Garcia.

When we think of mountain men, we tend to think of rugged and self-sufficient folks who live off of the land. And while that's mostly accurate, it's also 2024, and the definition has evolved. Today's mountain man is personified by chef Eduardo Garcia, who combines culinary expertise and the right cooking tools with an adventurous attitude and focus on the environment.

Garcia has put in some shifts. He's done everything from cooking on yachts to delivering motivational speeches. He's also the host of Big Sky Kitchen, now two seasons deep. The show focuses on outdoor cooking and the many joys of preparing and eating food in the context of nature.

Read more