Skip to main content

The Manual may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site.

Product Review: These Fall-Ready Boots Cost Hundreds Less Than Red Wings

Pfister boots
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Pfister boots
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Fall is coming at long, long last.

Recommended Videos

As if 2020 hadn’t jerked us around enough already, this summer has seen scorching temperatures around the globe, with unprecedented heat waves from Japan to Phoenix, AZ and even a potential hottest temperature seen anywhere on Earth in well over 100 years as Death Valley hit 130 degrees Fahrenheit on Sunday, August 16.

Autumn means respite from the heat, mosquitoes dying off by the millions, cherished seasonal beers returning to stores and taps, and of course the chance to finally put on jeans, a button-down, sweater, or handsome light jacket, and to step back into a damn fine pair of boots. Because is there really any type of footwear half as excellent as a great boot? Supportive, comfortable, protective, and great looking to boot (sorry), when you find a pair that fits just right and suits your style, you’ll start your outfit and your day off right, literally from the ground up.

Ah, but what boot to buy? You can’t go wrong with a Heritage Collection boot from Red Wing Shoes, to be sure. Or an OG 1000 Mile Boot from Wolverine. But those fine boots will set you back nearly $300 and nearly $400, respectively. If only someone made a comparable boot for (much) less money!

Well, guess what? Did you guess that someone did? You’re right.

This fall, the primary pair of boots you’ll find strapped to my feet are from Milwaukee Boot Co., a new kid on the block in some respects, an old hand in others. Milwaukee Boot Co. has only been open for business since last year, having opened a retail shop right in downtown Milwaukee (surprise, surprise, right?) in 2019, and even now in the late summer of 2020, the brand’s website is still partially under construction. But behind this new brand comes three generations of shoemaking experience, not to mention more than 165 years of leather working heritage boasted by the city of Milwaukee itself, once arguably the world capital of leather manufacturing.

From boots to saddles to aprons to bags, Milwaukee tanneries and leather workers have been crafting high quality goods for generations, so why not go ahead and name your boot brand after the spot? And in fact, these guys took things a step further, too, naming each brand of boot they offer after a landmark, neighborhood, or native son of the town, including the Pfister, the pair on my feet right now and that I’ll be focused on for the rest of this review.

Pfister Boots
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Material

The Milwaukee Boot Co.’s Pfister boots are made from rugged full-grain leather, and as a quick primer on leather grades, “Genuine leather” essentially means cheap and flimsy, “top grain” is short-hand for OK but not great, while “full grain” leather is the spare no expenses, ages well over time, resists water and attracts attention variety you want. Nay, you demand. Yet rugged as these boots are, they were comfortable the very first time I pulled them on and laced them up, something that involves handsome brass hardware.

And after many a step taken, they are only getting more comfortable as they break in. The footbeds are made using a padded leather that is slowly taking on the shape of my feet, while the outsole is a tough Goodyear (yeah the tire guys) rubber with a moderately aggressive treads pattern, something I appreciate as so many boots have smooth soles that offer so little traction.

Fit and Style

The Pfister boot definitely skews a bit closer to work boot than to stylish boot, but its rugged, simple design is plenty handsome nonetheless. Besides, when there’s work to be done, you want a boot that’s ready, not that’s shiny. My pair, which is in the Gaucho color that has a rough finish (other option is a more reddish “Scotch” that’s smoother)  fits my size 12 feet perfectly and look best under a pair of jeans, sometimes with a slight cuff. Currently, the company only offers boots in medium width, and in half sizes from 8 to 13. (Well, no 12.5, actually.) The tall collar offers decent ankle support, while the unlined upper resists water and will spare you most of the pain from a stubbing or a dropped hammer.

Value

Milwaukee Boot Co. boots are priced well in range for most gents who care about fine footwear but also want to keep things reasonable. And compare their price point — which is currently between $149 and $179 depending on the pair you choose — to the Wolverine 1000 Mile boot, which sells for close to $400, and you’ll consider these a deal. And having worn a pair of Wolverines for several years, I can tell you that my Pfister rival those absolutely excellent boots in most regards, with the price being a major selling point.

If you’re looking for a great pair of boots for 2020’s fall season, then Milwaukee is a good place to look. Because you’ll still be enjoying these boots in the winter and spring of 2021. And fall 2021. And fall 2024. And so on.

Steven John
Steven John is a writer and journalist living just outside New York City, by way of 12 years in Los Angeles, by way of…
I ran 50 miles on roads and trails—how the Craft Nordlite Ultra 2 performed
Is the Craft Nordlite Ultra 2 the only running shoe you need?
Craft Nordlite Ultra 2

When it comes to shoes, runners have almost too many choices. There are daily trainers, speed shoes, trail shoes, plated racers, and more. High-end models start around $150, so building up a “quiver” of footwear requires $300, $450, or more. That can make the simple, refreshing act of running an expensive hobby.

However, some manufacturers produce road-to-trail shoes that can handle both roads and trails, as well as everything in between. One such model is the Craft Nordlite Ultra 2, which features a supercritical midsole and a lugged outsole. I tested it on the roads and trails of Virginia’s Shenandoah Valley to answer the question: Is this the only running shoe you need? Read on for my take.

Read more
From Malibu to Porto Cervo, Armani x Kith goes full coastal luxe
Kith, Armani debut a summer-ready collection
man wearing kith x armani tee shirt

When Kith and Giorgio Armani released their first collection together for Fall/Winter 2024, there was no doubt that both brands had nailed the concept of a luxury partnership. Now the two brands are joining forces once more to bring this same luxury feel to the summertime with the second installment of their collaboration. Meant to bridge the luxury of Italy and the modern sophistication of New York, this new collection is ready for wherever the summer may take you. Whether you’re hitting the Italian coast or the streets of New York, this collection embodies the summer of your dreams and an aspirational lifestyle. Besides featuring a series of stylish silhouettes and styles, this collection is also made to be sensible to withstand the summer in Europe or the United States. 

Giorgio Armani and Kith go global with new collection

Read more
Tiffany & Co. revives legendary Atlas watch collection
Tiffany & Co. has officially relaunched its iconic Atlas® watches
the Atlas watches feature graphic Roman numerals and streamlined silhouettes

To the surprise of absolutely no one, Tiffany & Co. has resuscitated its storied Atlas collection, reimagining the legendary Roman numeral motif for today's discerning watch collectors. Released originally in the 1990s and inspired by the iconic Atlas clock at Tiffany's Fifth Avenue flagship, these timepieces bring together timeless elegance and contemporary sophistication.

Precision craftsmanship, unmistakable style

Read more