Skip to main content

J.D. Power survey shows the airlines people like the most (and least)

If you're curious to see how other people rank the best airlines, J.D. Power did the survey for you

A view of a Delta airplane out of an airport window.
Hanson Lu/Unsplash / Unsplash

Do you fly with the same carrier every time? Do you ping back and forth between two different ones, depending on things like the ticket price or ones that don’t have hidden fees? Was there one airline you had a horrible experience with and have never booked with again? J.D. Power did a survey about all of that and more, and we have the results for the best airlines to fly with. Have a peek if you’re curious to see where your pick landed.

What it took to be a fan favorite

How do you make it to be one of the top airlines to fly with? It surveyed people from March 2022 to March 2023, so the data is pretty recent. And it only asked about main North American airlines, so you might not see all of your low-budget or other airlines in the rankings.

What the airline needed to be good at

  • The state of the plane itself
  • Baggage fees
  • Ease of boarding
  • Those fun fees and other costs
  • The flight attendants
  • The in-flight experience
  • The reservation process

J.D. Power made sure it asked about all the pertinent things we care about when picking our top airlines. We think they asked the right questions.

But it dug deeper and broke it up by seat class, separating things by ranking basic, premium, and first-class areas. If you have a preferred way to fly, go straight to that ranking.

The winners

Basic economy

  • Southwest Airlines
  • Delta Air Lines
  • JetBlue

Premium economy

  • Delta Air Lines
  • JetBlue
  • Alaska Airlines

First class

  • JetBlue
  • Delta Air Lines
  • United Airlines

Well, well, well, aren’t JetBlue and Delta leading the way? No matter what class you like to (or can afford to) fly, JetBlue and Delta are your safe bets to give you the most appealing experience across all categories.

A flight attendant checking on the inside of a cabin on an airplane.
Omar Prestwich / Unplash

The ones that need some work

Everyone wants to know the ones that ranked the lowest in each category. While these may not be the worst airlines to fly on, for this survey, they ranked last among the North American airlines.

Basic economy

  • Frontier Airlines
  • Spirit Airlines
  • American Airlines

Premium economy

  • United Airlines
  • Air Canada
  • American Airlines

First class

  • American Airlines
  • Air Canada
  • Alaska Airlines

Unfortunately for American Airlines, it ranked in the bottom three in each class category, so it seems it is struggling a little bit across the board. Air Canada isn’t too far behind, being in the bottom three in two out of three classes. 

In the past few years, we’ve struggled with flight cancellations, delays, rising fees, hidden fees, understaffed flights, and not being able to find a flight for the day or time we want. Customers are almost scared to book any flight in fear of how things will change from when they purchased the ticket to when they show up at the airport. We’re happy to see these airlines trying their best to meet the basics every customer looks for when flying.

Editors' Recommendations

Dannielle Beardsley
Dannielle has written for various websites, online magazines, and blogs. She loves everything celebrity and her favorite…
Here’s how to live in your car comfortably for a few weeks (or longer) like a pro
Living in your car isn't much different than extended car camping. Here's how to gear up for it like a pro.
Relaxing in the back of a car on a mattress

The van-life movement has evolved beyond short-term escape into a way of life in the most minimal and sustainable sense. Should you decide to spend days or weeks traversing the country on four wheels sounds appealing, then this one is for you. We’ve put together a starter kit of essential tips and gear — most of which is similar to any extended car camping trip.

Here’s everything you’ll need to stay safe, sane, and happy when living in your car (or truck or van) for a few weeks or even longer. Whether you're trying to fully embrace van life or just planning an extended road trip to get out of your house, here's the low-down on how to live in your car.
Learn how to get a good night’s rest

Read more
Travelers are going to hate American Airlines’ newest policy change
American Airlines baggage policy just changed, and it might make you want to change your airline carrier
An American Airlines airplane in an airport.

Nothing upsets us more when flying than getting hit with fee after fee after fee. One specific downer is that darn baggage fee. We wear layers to save space in our suitcase and will try any tips we see on TikTok to pack way more than we need into one bag. Packing cubes are everyone's friend. Well, you might need more help because the American Airlines baggage policy changed, and it's not for the better.

For passengers flying American's basic economy fare, American Airlines no longer offers one checked bag on flights to and from Europe, Asia, the Middle East, and Oceania — and the rates are pretty steep. (Note: the basic economy policies for both domestic flights and for those going to Canada and Latin America have not changed.)
The price of our over-packing problem
Your ticket (be it economy or first class), where you are flying to, and where you are flying from all factor into the cost. We know — that's annoying and confusing. Here's the deal for transatlantic and transpacific flights:
Carry-ons are still free
Each passenger still gets one carry-on and one personal item for free with their basic economy ticket. As always, check with your airline about what counts, the weight and size requirements, and all that fun stuff. But otherwise, those two are business as usual. 
First and second checked bag fees
That first checked bag is where the fees start to stack up. First bags start at $0 if you grab a first-class ticket and go up to $75 for economy seats. But if you're looking to check a second bag? That will cost you $100.
Third and fourth checked bag
At this point, you might not even want to know. You'll spend $200 per bag checked in. It might be cheaper to ship your stuff ahead of you.

Read more
Good news for JetBlue loyalists — the airline is adding a bunch of new routes to the Caribbean
Time to get out of here for some island time on JetBlue
Si'u Point Trail, Ta'u Island, National Park of American Samoa.

Attention travelers: JetBlue just announced plans to continue its expansion of flights—both in and outside of the U.S.—and some of those destinations just happen to be in the Caribbean. We already know that most Americans don't take enough vacation time (and you shouldn't let that be you). If island time is calling for you, now is your chance to visit those beautiful white beaches and crystal blue water for under $200 on one of these JetBlue flights. So, what are you waiting for? Your feet could be in the sand come this November!

What are the new routes?
The airliner is adding destinations from New York, Boston, Orlando, and Los Angeles to begin with. "Launching later this year, JetBlue will now offer nonstop flights to two new destinations from New York’s John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK): Robert Llewellyn Bradshaw International Airport (SKB) in St. Kitts and Nevis and Philip S. W. Goldson International Airport (BZE) in Belize City, Belize," the company said in a press release.

Read more