Skip to main content

Why Parmesan isn’t the cheese you should put on your pasta

It may be time to rethink your finishing cheese for your pasta dishes

Mauro Pezzotta/Shutterstock

We know that we say this about a lot of dishes, but truly — is there anything better than a big, rich, steaming bowl of cheesy pasta? Give us your bucatini, your ravioli, your fettuccini Alfredo. We’ll take it all. Just always, always, top it with a generous grating of cheese. But which cheese? Of course, in this country, we’ve gotten very used to that finishing cheese being salty, nutty, delicious Parmesan. And while that’s certainly a very adequate choice — is it the best choice? We say no. If you ask us, Pecorino Romano is the superior alternative.

What’s the difference between Parmesan cheese and Pecorino Romano?

The two cheeses undoubtedly have their similarities. Both are hard, aged, salty Italian cheeses. The main difference between the two is that Parmesan is a cow’s milk cheese, and Pecorino is a sheep’s. And while both cheeses are aged, the differences in aging time are significant. Parmesan can be aged anywhere between one and three years, while the more youthful Pecorino is generally only aged a few months.

Parmesan cheese
Rawpixel.com/Adobe Stock

What are the best uses for Parmesan cheese?

Parmesan is deservedly popular for its delightful salty nuttiness and mellow ability to blend with any number of dishes. It’s beautiful in the dishes after which it is named, such as chicken or eggplant parmesan. Parmesan is also a wonderful filler for meatballs and it adds richness to soups and sauces. But overall, Parmesan does far better in a supporting role than that of the main star.

Pecorino Romano
Image used with permission by copyright holder

What are the best uses for Pecorino Romano?

Pecorino, however, gets the winning trophy from us. While it’s clearly the less appreciated cheese here, you just can’t argue its obvious superiority. Its gorgeous creaminess adds a texture component that one doesn’t get from Parmesan. It also hits with a signature tang, making it beautiful on its own, or adding depth to simple dishes, such as lighter pastas or gratins. That tangy creaminess is just impossible to compete with.

Recommended Videos

It’s also worth noting that Pecorino is a delight to enjoy by itself with a glass of wine. You could enjoy Parmesan this way, but it doesn’t work as well as a table cheese as Pecorino does.

Pasta on white plate with cheese on top
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Can you use the two interchangeably?

You can. But that doesn’t mean you should. Generally, a recipe will take these differences into account before printing, so if you want to enjoy a dish the way it’s meant to be enjoyed, it’s best to stick with what’s called for, such as Locatelli cheese (Pecorino Romano).

Another thing to consider, apart from the flavor and texture differences we’ve already mentioned, is that Pecorino tends to taste quite a bit saltier than Parmesan. So if you do end up swapping one for the other, keep salt content in mind and adjust your seasonings accordingly, tasting your dish as you go.

Lindsay Parrill
Lindsay is a graduate of California Culinary Academy, Le Cordon Bleu, San Francisco, from where she holds a degree in…
What is a black tie coffee? Why it might become your new favorite drink
A blend of sweet and spicy
Iced coffee with cream

Part of what makes the world of coffee so fascinating is that there's always something new to learn. If you think you've heard of every type of coffee imaginable, perhaps you'll need to rethink that statement. The black tie coffee offers something unique that other coffee beverages simply do not: the perfect balance between tea and coffee. If you're a tea and coffee lover like me, this drink could become your new favorite. Here's what you need to know about the "black tie coffee" and how to make it.
How to make black tie coffee

Ordering a black tie coffee at your local cafe isn't relatively as easy as ordering an iced latte. While you might find this specialty beverage more easily abroad, it's hard to come by on coffee shop menus throughout the U.S. Luckily; this drink is simple enough to prepare enough on your own at home, even for beginner Baristas. Here's how to make a black tie coffee.
Ingredients

Read more
Cortado vs. macchiato: Which espresso drink should you order?
The Spanish cortado or the Italian macchiato
Cortado

Both the cortado and macchiato are varieties of coffee orders that I'll order at least a few times per month. The cortado has gained a lot of popularity recently since it was added to the Starbucks menu in January. However, the cortado and the macchiato are not new to the coffee scene worldwide.

The cortado emerged from Spain in the early 20th century, whereas the macchiato was born in Italy in the 1980s. Though they share many similarities, these "espresso with milk" orders differ in taste and preparation. Here's how I decide which coffee to order and what differentiates the cortado vs. macchiato.
Cortado vs. macchiato: What are the differences?

Read more
A novice cheesemaker’s guide on how to make cheese at home
Ever wanted to make your own cheese? Let this story be your faithful guide
Wooden table with a delicious variety of cheeses. Cheeses included in the composition are Manchego cheese, goat cheese, emmental cheese, Roquefort cheese, Parmesan cheese and Cheddar cheese. Predominant colors are yellow and brown

The art of cheesemaking is a time-honored tradition that is far less complicated than one might think. Knowing how to make your own at home can unlock a world of unpasteurized possibilities if you are a cheese connoisseur like I am. For the beginner cheesemaker, I found starting with a soft cheese like Chevre or mozzarella is best, which requires fewer steps and minimal aging. Once you have mastered the basics, the combinations are endless.

Want to impress next time you're pairing up wine (or beer) and cheese? I've found there's no better way than with some tasty dairy you made yourself with your own bare hands. You can create the cheese of your wildest dreams, from the sheep to cow's milk to added herbs and even dairy-free versions. To help you embark on your cheesemaking journey, here are the fundamentals you need to know on how to make cheese to begin making the freshest, most delicious cheese right at home.
The basics of cheesemaking

Read more