Skip to main content

The difference between pies, buckles, betties, and more

A crumble or a cobbler? It's time to learn the difference

Summertime will be here before we know it, and that means pie. It also means a lot of other delicious desserts that masquerade as pie but actually have names all of their own. So if you’ve been making the faux paux of calling a Pandowdy a Pie, or a Betty a Buckle, it’s high time to learn the ins and outs of proper pastry names. Here are a few of the most common mix-ups.

Cobbler

Slow Cooker Berry Cobbler
Chop Happy

A traditional cobbler is baked in a casserole dish instead of a pie plate. The fruit filling sits directly on the bottom, without a base dough, and then biscuit dough is dropped on top and baked in large rounds on the surface.

Recommended Videos

Crumble

Image used with permission by copyright holder

A crumble consists of fruit on the bottom of the dish, also without a base, and a streusel layer on top made solely of sugar, flour, and butter.

Pandowdy

Image used with permission by copyright holder

While this sweet treat takes the cake for the most fun to say, there is a bit of debate regarding its crust. Fruit is baked on a crustless bottom, then finished with a rolled pastry top. Traditionally, the pastry top is broken into pieces after baking to allow the juices to saturate the crust. A more modern take, however, is to layer smaller, staggered pieces of pastry on top before going into the oven, to allow the juices to seep through whilst baking. If you ask us, it sounds delicious either way.

Grunt

Cast Iron Cobbler/Facebook

Also known as a “slump,” a grunt is made just like a cobbler, but on the stovetop instead of the oven, usually in a cast iron skillet.

Pie

Peach Pie Slice
Quentin Bacon

Pie, the greedy dessert that seems to have cleverly absorbed all of these other unique and delicious treats, is baked with rolled dough on both the bottom and the top, with fruit in the center.

Crisp

apple crisp
Photo by Anna Pustynnikova

Crisp and crumble are very similar, the only difference being that oats are added to the streusel topping in a crisp.

Buckle

Barbara Olson/Flicker

A buckle is fun because it creates a bit of a surprise. For a buckle, batter is poured into a pan, and cut fruit is layered on top. It then goes into the oven. As the dessert bakes, the fruit sinks into the batter, resulting in a beautifully moist, fruity piece of heaven.

Betty

The Fun Cook/Facebook

A betty is sort of like a dessert casserole, made by layering fruit and either buttered bread slices or crumbs, in alternating layers, and then baking.

Lindsay Parrill
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Lindsay is a graduate of California Culinary Academy, Le Cordon Bleu, San Francisco, from where she holds a degree in…
Mixing up a G&T and more using citrusy Gray Whale Gin
Gray Whale Gin

Gin is such a fun spirit to work with because it can be so varied. From bold and juniper-forward to soft and floral, I do believe there's a gin out there that can appeal to anyone -- even people who think they don't like gin.

One of our favorite gins, Gray Whale Gin, has fresh citrusy flavors that are perfect for this time of year. So whether you're looking for a G&T for Gin and Tonic day, or something light and refreshing to toast the arrival of spring, you can try out these recipes.

Read more
Cortado vs. flat white: What’s the difference?
Spanish-inspired coffee vs. New Zealand-inspired coffee
Flat white

A cortado and a flat white are great espresso beverages for a morning coffee or a mid-afternoon pick-me-up. The Spanish cortado offers a balanced flavor that is not too bold but has a noticeable espresso flavor. Meanwhile, a flat white, a drink which is thought to have originated in Australia, has a creamier and milder taste than its Spanish counterpart. Although I find both espresso beverages undeniably tasty, each has notable flavor, preparation, size, and texture differences. Join me as we explore the differences between a cortado vs. flat white, which hopefully will help make deciding your next coffee shop order easier.
What is a cortado?

A cortado is one of my favorite coffees (even more so since Starbucks added it to its menu). A cortado is made using a one-to-one ratio of milk to espresso, leaving it with a balanced taste and texture. Cortados are tiny coffee drinks (at least compared to larger drinks like lattes) that are typically served in small, 4 to 5-ounce servings. The equal ratio of milk to espresso used in a cortado leaves it with a rich, smooth, and creamy taste. It's the perfect drink if you still want to taste the flavor of espresso but don't want something quite as strong as a macchiato.
What is a flat white?

Read more
Oven, smoker, and more: How to cook ham for the holidays
The best ways to cook ham in an easy step-by-step guide
Man cutting ham in the kitchen

It's nearly Easter, and that means in addition to organizing the family's egg scavenger hunt, you need to start getting the menu together for your holiday spread. Of course, no holiday menu is complete without a juicy ham at the helm of it all. Ham season is in full effect ... and yes, we said ham season.

Cooking a ham at home is the route to take, as it can be the main event for a large gathering like an Easter dinner and maybe set you up for sandwiches, soups, and casseroles for weeks to come. And don't get me started on pairing it with a lovely holiday wine and some killer side dishes to bring everything together. After multiple Christmases, Thanksgivings, and Easters at my home, I'd like to think I know a thing or two about how to do a ham some justice.

Read more