Skip to main content

The difference between pies, buckles, betties, and more

A crumble or a cobbler? It's time to learn the difference

Summertime will be here before we know it, and that means pie. It also means a lot of other delicious desserts that masquerade as pie but actually have names all of their own. So if you’ve been making the faux paux of calling a Pandowdy a Pie, or a Betty a Buckle, it’s high time to learn the ins and outs of proper pastry names. Here are a few of the most common mix-ups.

Cobbler

Slow Cooker Berry Cobbler
Chop Happy

A traditional cobbler is baked in a casserole dish instead of a pie plate. The fruit filling sits directly on the bottom, without a base dough, and then biscuit dough is dropped on top and baked in large rounds on the surface.

Crumble

Image used with permission by copyright holder

A crumble consists of fruit on the bottom of the dish, also without a base, and a streusel layer on top made solely of sugar, flour, and butter.

Pandowdy

Image used with permission by copyright holder

While this sweet treat takes the cake for the most fun to say, there is a bit of debate regarding its crust. Fruit is baked on a crustless bottom, then finished with a rolled pastry top. Traditionally, the pastry top is broken into pieces after baking to allow the juices to saturate the crust. A more modern take, however, is to layer smaller, staggered pieces of pastry on top before going into the oven, to allow the juices to seep through whilst baking. If you ask us, it sounds delicious either way.

Grunt

Cast Iron Cobbler/Facebook

Also known as a “slump,” a grunt is made just like a cobbler, but on the stovetop instead of the oven, usually in a cast iron skillet.

Pie

Peach Pie Slice
Quentin Bacon

Pie, the greedy dessert that seems to have cleverly absorbed all of these other unique and delicious treats, is baked with rolled dough on both the bottom and the top, with fruit in the center.

Crisp

apple crisp
Photo by Anna Pustynnikova

Crisp and crumble are very similar, the only difference being that oats are added to the streusel topping in a crisp.

Buckle

Barbara Olson/Flicker

A buckle is fun because it creates a bit of a surprise. For a buckle, batter is poured into a pan, and cut fruit is layered on top. It then goes into the oven. As the dessert bakes, the fruit sinks into the batter, resulting in a beautifully moist, fruity piece of heaven.

Betty

The Fun Cook/Facebook

A betty is sort of like a dessert casserole, made by layering fruit and either buttered bread slices or crumbs, in alternating layers, and then baking.

Editors' Recommendations

Lindsay Parrill
Lindsay is a graduate of California Culinary Academy, Le Cordon Bleu, San Francisco, from where she holds a degree in…
The traditional Greek food you need to try when you visit Greece
Dishes you must try while in Greece
Yamas in Walla Walla.

Traditional Greek food is one of the great Mediterranean cuisines. Working with ingredients ranging from pita bread and lamb to incredible olive oil and unique cheeses, the Grecian table is a delectable one. Like Chinese food culture or Italian cuisine, Greek food is an entire world that is very much worth exploring, fork in hand.

Most eaters have dined at a Greek Restaurant (Yamas in Walla Walla wine country is one of our favorites) or made a Greek dish like dolmas from the supermarket. That's great, but don't stop there. In fact, doing so would be a discredit to one of the torch-bearers of fine food.

Read more
Why these methods of cooking are best when you want to retain nutrients
Learn all about healthy cooking methods
Man with apron in industrial kitchen

 

Cooking with a variety of methods can not only save you time in the kitchen but also maximize the nutrient content of your food. The way you cook and prepare food has a significant impact on its nutritional value.

Read more
This is how Bobby Flay makes store-bought barbecue sauce taste amazing
Make your sauce taste homemade with this easy trick
Person grilling

Love him or hate him, Bobby Flay is admittedly one of the more talented and famous chefs of our time. Between his countless television shows and cookbooks, the popular chef has amassed quite a dedicated fan following, looking to him for culinary inspiration in just about any dish. This time of year, the grilling expert is well-loved and sought after for his delicious barbecue tips, tricks, and recipes, and we've stumbled across one that we can't wait to try this summer.

In a YouTube video posted by The Food Network, Flay admits that while making homemade barbecue sauce is certainly a great option, not everyone has the time or desire to do so. He then goes on to explain that by simply adding a few key ingredients to a high-quality store-bought sauce, everyone's favorite summertime condiment can be elevated to whole new levels of finger-licking deliciousness.
The secret ingredients

Read more