Skip to main content

The Manual may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site.

Review: Cometeer instant coffee might be better than fresh-ground

Instant coffee isn't always great, but brands like Cometeer are taking it to new levels of gourmet quality

For years, instant coffee was terrible. It was meant to caffeinate and do little more. It was easy to make, but it tasted a bit like wet dirt. Times have changed — dramatically — and Cometeer Coffee is proof.

It’s a wild understatement to say that the brand is shaking up the instant coffee realm. Cometeer has basically rewritten the rules, utilizing a flash-freezing procedure that produces a cafe-caliber cup, all while staying true to single-origin terroir and minimizing its environmental impact.

The holiday collection from Cometeer Coffee.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Real quality

Cometeer’s coffees across the board are incredibly smooth, balanced, and delicious. Our favorites include Coltrane, a collaboration with Red Bay Coffee, with dark chocolate, caramelized sugar, and dark fruit. The Big Trouble is equally compelling, a medium roast teeming with toffee notes and a nutty profile. The light roasts are great too, despite being a little softer on the palate. The Nano Genji, floral and fruity, is full of personality, making for a great afternoon cup.

Cometeer is working with some great roasters responsible for some great beans. They work with the likes of Counter Culture, George Howell, and Onyx Coffee Lab, just to name a few. The great flavor makes sense not just because of the roaster clientele but also because of how the stuff is made. Apparently, Cometeer brews a strong-as-jet-fuel batch (10 times stronger than regular coffee) before flash-freezing the pods at negative 321 degrees Fahrenheit. When the pods show up at your door, they come still frozen and packed with dry ice. The fog that sometimes comes from a freshly-opened delivery only adds to the futuristic nature of the product.

Are there downfalls? Not really. It’s a subscription service, so getting additional info on the coffees themselves is a little tricky upfront, but what comes in the delivery is helpful. It’s not cheap, but then again, think about how much you shell out for a cup from your favorite barista.

Fun to make

A pile of Cometeer Coffee pods.
Facebook/Cometeer Coffee

The process is fun. The box comes with a visual guide on how to produce your cup, which takes little more than some hot water. You run the capsule under warm water until the pod jostles free, then dump it into your mug. You add your hot water from the kettle and milk or cream, if that’s your thing, and you’re done. The pod melts down quickly and evenly, creating a genuinely enjoyable sipper.

In a blind taste test, you’d be hard-pressed to identify this as instant coffee. The nuance of flavors, roundness in character, and variation from roast to roast is remarkable. More impressive, it comes from essentially a concentrated capsule of coffee that just needs some hydration to come to life. We did a double-take after tasting the first round and continue to be impressed by Cometeer’s offerings.

Bonus points must be awarded for the smart design. As reported, single-use coffee pods aren’t as bad for the planet as many thought. Better, Cometeer utilizes a capsule that you can recycle, meaning the only real waste is the metal seal, and the only real energy suck is the process of warming the water (and, of course, whatever is happening in the coffee farms). There are no grounds in these capsules, and therefore, no additional waste. The spent grounds Cometeer produces are even sent to a local composting facility, per the brand’s website.

There are decaf options, and the pods work in Keurig machines. They’re also TSA-friendly, meaning you can fly with them. All in all, it’s a giant step forward not just in terms of instant coffee (it’s hands-down the best instant coffee we’ve tried), but also for gourmet coffee in general. We’re excited to see who Cometeer teams up with next.

Editors' Recommendations

Mark Stock
Mark Stock is a writer from Portland, Oregon. He fell into wine during the Recession and has been fixated on the stuff since…
Video: This ‘new’ way to make poached eggs might be the best (and simplest) ever
Learn how to poach your eggs to perfection
Poached egg with green asparagus and caviar.

Since their appearance in the 13th-century medieval French cookbook, Le Viandier, poached eggs have served as an aristocratic dish. According to the lifestyle platform, the term "poached" originates from the French word "poché," meaning small pouch or pocket. This sophisticated method of cooking is essentially steaming the egg to elicit a subtle, almost perfect delicacy — cooked, almost crispy white surrounded by a lush, runny yolk. Be it breakfast, lunch, or dinner, poached eggs serve as the perfect main dish or an addition to many, many meals.

Achieving this culinary delight, however, takes practice and a skilled hand. Fortunately for us, many of these masters are available online. Today, The Manual takes you through Epicurious’ "incredible new way to poach eggs that never fails." Via Chef Adrienne Cheatham, we will show you how to poach an egg at brunch-level quality in less than 5 minutes.

Read more
Aeropress, VSSL, Frazy, and more: How to make great coffee while camping
Don't feed or caffeinate the bears, though, please
A woman sitting and drinking a warm beverage by a green tent.

Savvy world travelers know the single most important thing to pack is their passport. Without it, nothing else matters. For most campers, that one most important thing — the crown jewel of every camp load out — is coffee. Some would rather forget their underwear, their best backpacking tent, or their significant other at home than head out into the wild java-less.

There are plenty of ways to brew the perfect cup at home and almost as many for doing so in the wild. Most campers have pretty strong opinions on their preferred method — the right way, if you will — to make the best cup o’ joe. We’re not here to tell you which is best, but we can help steer the ship. Here is our favorite go-to gear for making great coffee while camping (or traveling or anywhere on the go, really).

Read more
This marshmallow recipe is so simple (and homemade marshmallows are so much better than store-bought)
This is the marshmallow recipe you need
Hot chocolate served in vintage mugs with marshmallows

Hot chocolate season is upon us, and that means marshmallows. Soft and pillowy, bouncy and sweet, tender, chewy marshmallows. Maybe it's just us, but even with the summertime s'more craze, winter seems to be the true marshmallow season. There's just something delightfully wintery about a marshmallow's pure white sweetness, perfectly complimenting so many warm and cozy treats.

And sure, you can always buy a bag of one of the store-bought varieties. They're cheap and convenient, and these days come in a wide variety of flavors, colors, and shapes. But homemade marshmallows are precisely one million times better than any bagged version you can pick up at the store. And chances are, they're a whole lot easier to make than you think.

Read more