Skip to main content

How to Make Lobster Rolls the Easy (and Cheap) Way

Lobster rolls are all the rage, and for damn good reason (it’s because they’re delicious). Pardon the pun, but there’s also a catch — they’re crazy expensive. If you’re not familiar with lobster rolls — or you’re imagining a sort of dumpling-style treat, a muffin-like thing with lobster meat baked right in, or something else entirely — then read on, as we’re about to break down what this treat is and how you can easily make them at home without breaking the bank.

In order to figure out the best recipe for homemade lobster rolls, we consulted a noted professional chef whose lobster rolls recently won the Editor’s Choice Award at the 2018 Tasting Table’s Lobster Rumble held in Brooklyn, New York. Chef Christopher Kim helms New York City’s Saltbrick Tavern, a restaurant dedicated to “reimagining tavern classics,” elevating dishes often taken for granted to a level of true gastronomy. If there is anyone to talk to about a sandwich that started off as a seafood street meal and is now having its culinary moment.

Homemade Lobster Roll Recipe

A lobster roll with a toasted bun, Bibb lettuce, and seasoned and dressed lobster meat.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Ingredients:

  • Approx. 1 pound cooked lobster, cut into chunks (and cooled if cooked fresh)
  • 4 hot dog buns (or fancy rolls, if you prefer), Toasted
  • 4 lemon wedges
  • 4 tablespoons mayo
  • 4 tablespoons melted butter
  • 4 celery stalks, finely chopped
  • Salt and pepper to taste

Method:

  1. Mix mayo and celery.
  2. Portion out 0.25-pound lobster meat into each roll.
  3. Spread on mayo and celery mix.
  4. Drizzle butter over the top.
  5. Squeeze some lemon on there.
  6. Salt and pepper to taste.

See? Super simple. In the end, it won’t cost you $20 bucks per lobster roll, either. Bon appétit, friends.

What is a Lobster Roll?

So, what is a lobster roll? Basically, it’s a lobster hot dog. Seriously. It’s lobster meat served in a hot dog-style bun, and that’s it. When they originated in New England, lobster rolls were essentially fast food, often served at roadside stands or counter-style restaurants and usually consisting of meat, butter, and bread. Despite the more or less humble origins of the lobster roll, many establishments will charge you well over $20 for a single lobster roll today. Any way you cut it, that’s a lot of cash for one sandwich, but it’s also an affront to the roots of this unique New England eat. The solution? Why, the homemade lobster roll, of course.

A lobster popover from Saltbrick Tavern.
Saltbrick Tavern/Facebook

First, Chef Christopher Kim cleared the airwaves, explaining that a lobster roll, simply put, “is cooked lobster meat dressed in butter or mayo and served on a warm hot dog style bun.” See? Just like I said. His winning lobster rolls use a “cold and hot contrast” with “chilled lobster [on] crispy warm bread.”

The bread is a freshly made, warm, cheddar and black pepper popover roll. He and his assistants dress up their freshly-cooked-then-chilled lobster meat with fresh tarragon, chives, and celery salt, and then slather on a blend of 80% seaweed butter and 20% mayo to finish off the award-winning recipe.

Sounds amazing, right? A group of professional food writers thought so too. But guess what? You don’t need to use home-cooked lobster, seaweed butter, or fancy herbs and spices to make a lobster roll you and your guests will love. In fact, you can make awesome lobster rolls at home using the six ingredients above, and two of those are just the bread and the meat!

Want to learn to cook lobster a different (or three different) ways? We’ve got you covered.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics
Steven John
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Steven John is a writer and journalist living just outside New York City, by way of 12 years in Los Angeles, by way of…
How to cook rice perfectly every time, no matter how you choose to make it
These methods mean no more mushy meals or rice stuck to the bottom of the pot
Cooked white rice

Rice is a staple portion of or a whole meal. Practically anywhere in the world, that region's cuisine features rice to some extent. Not only does it go with everything from steak to chicken, but it can also be used in sweet dishes, too (rice pudding, anyone? How about sweet sticky rice with fresh mango?).

Rice is also a perfect dry ingredient to keep on hand when you need a quick meal that will fill you up and leave you satiated, but that also won't break the bank. But it isn't always easy to make. Sometimes it gets mushy, others it sticks to the bottom of the pot. Cooking rice doesn't have to be tricky, though. To help, we’ve put together a guide on how to cook rice perfectly every time, so you can enjoy those tasty grains without the headaches.

Read more
How to cook lobster the right way — boiling, grilling, and roasting
Prepare lobster in one of three ways, but enjoy it all the same
Lobster on a plate

Everyone needs a little something extra to spice up everyday life -- a spa day, perhaps, or a nice meal. And while ribs in the oven or a perfectly grilled steak will definitely suffice, sometimes you might think about moving from turf to surf, and what better "surf" to have than a sweet, succulent lobster? Meaty, juicy, and slathered in butter, it's about as perfect a meal as they come -- even while in lobster roll form.

For most, a nice lobster dinner sits at the apex of gourmet meals. There's just something about the bright red body sitting on a plate that exudes class. The thing is, though, that you don't have to go out to a fancy restaurant and shell out for that kind of meal. With a little know-how, anyone can make such an incomparable dish at home.

Read more
You should know how to make these incredible sauces
Mastering these sauces will make you look like a pro in the kitchen
Bechamel sauce over lasagna

A good sauce is a core component of culinary culture. Knowing how to make a handful of them can elevate your kitchen game to unforeseen heights. Often, a good sauce is the star of the show. After all, what would Thanksgiving turkey be without gravy? Or Eggs Benedict without hollandaise?

Now, we don't expect you to pull a Bearnaise sauce out of your hat at a moment's notice. But you should be able to whip up a solid tomato-based sauce for pasta, or a good teriyaki sauce for rice and veggies or skewered proteins. We know, there are great pre-made options out there, from complex fish sauce to throw-it-on-anything Japanese barbecue sauce. Yet, you know as well as we do that when you pull it off from scratch, it's more rewarding and can even taste better.

Read more