Skip to main content

How to Make Lobster Rolls the Easy (and Cheap) Way

Lobster rolls are all the rage, and for damn good reason (it’s because they’re delicious). Pardon the pun, but there’s also a catch — they’re crazy expensive. If you’re not familiar with lobster rolls — or you’re imagining a sort of dumpling-style treat, a muffin-like thing with lobster meat baked right in, or something else entirely — then read on, as we’re about to break down what this treat is and how you can easily make them at home without breaking the bank.

In order to figure out the best recipe for homemade lobster rolls, we consulted a noted professional chef whose lobster rolls recently won the Editor’s Choice Award at the 2018 Tasting Table’s Lobster Rumble held in Brooklyn, New York. Chef Christopher Kim helms New York City’s Saltbrick Tavern, a restaurant dedicated to “reimagining tavern classics,” elevating dishes often taken for granted to a level of true gastronomy. If there is anyone to talk to about a sandwich that started off as a seafood street meal and is now having its culinary moment.

Homemade Lobster Roll Recipe

A lobster roll with a toasted bun, Bibb lettuce, and seasoned and dressed lobster meat.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Ingredients:

  • Approx. 1 pound cooked lobster, cut into chunks (and cooled if cooked fresh)
  • 4 hot dog buns (or fancy rolls, if you prefer), Toasted
  • 4 lemon wedges
  • 4 tablespoons mayo
  • 4 tablespoons melted butter
  • 4 celery stalks, finely chopped
  • Salt and pepper to taste

Method:

  1. Mix mayo and celery.
  2. Portion out 0.25-pound lobster meat into each roll.
  3. Spread on mayo and celery mix.
  4. Drizzle butter over the top.
  5. Squeeze some lemon on there.
  6. Salt and pepper to taste.

See? Super simple. In the end, it won’t cost you $20 bucks per lobster roll, either. Bon appétit, friends.

What is a Lobster Roll?

So, what is a lobster roll? Basically, it’s a lobster hot dog. Seriously. It’s lobster meat served in a hot dog-style bun, and that’s it. When they originated in New England, lobster rolls were essentially fast food, often served at roadside stands or counter-style restaurants and usually consisting of meat, butter, and bread. Despite the more or less humble origins of the lobster roll, many establishments will charge you well over $20 for a single lobster roll today. Any way you cut it, that’s a lot of cash for one sandwich, but it’s also an affront to the roots of this unique New England eat. The solution? Why, the homemade lobster roll, of course.

A lobster popover from Saltbrick Tavern.
Saltbrick Tavern/Facebook

First, Chef Christopher Kim cleared the airwaves, explaining that a lobster roll, simply put, “is cooked lobster meat dressed in butter or mayo and served on a warm hot dog style bun.” See? Just like I said. His winning lobster rolls use a “cold and hot contrast” with “chilled lobster [on] crispy warm bread.”

The bread is a freshly made, warm, cheddar and black pepper popover roll. He and his assistants dress up their freshly-cooked-then-chilled lobster meat with fresh tarragon, chives, and celery salt, and then slather on a blend of 80% seaweed butter and 20% mayo to finish off the award-winning recipe.

Sounds amazing, right? A group of professional food writers thought so too. But guess what? You don’t need to use home-cooked lobster, seaweed butter, or fancy herbs and spices to make a lobster roll you and your guests will love. In fact, you can make awesome lobster rolls at home using the six ingredients above, and two of those are just the bread and the meat!

Want to learn to cook lobster a different (or three different) ways? We’ve got you covered.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics
Steven John
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Steven John is a writer and journalist living just outside New York City, by way of 12 years in Los Angeles, by way of…
Chef-inspired recipe: How to make Mexican carne asada for a winning meat entree
Become an expert cook and make this at home
Carne asada

Carne asada, a smoky and savory Mexican-style steak, is one of the most popular items in Mexican cuisine. Spanish for “grilled meat,” carne asada is incredibly prevalent in America, and it can be quite tricky trying to find a Mexican menu that doesn't feature this iconic beef dish. But carne asada isn't only a restaurant treat — it can be recreated fantastically at home. All you need is quality meat, the right techniques, and a hot grill.

Origins of carne asada
The historic origins of carne asada can be traced to the Spanish colonization of Mexico. Cattle are not native to Mexico. Cows were brought to Mexico in 1521 by the Spanish to serve as labor and dairy animals. Initially, beef was not widely eaten, as the meat from these early working animals were tough and expensive because of their value as farm animals.

Read more
Listen to the experts: Here’s how to make the perfect Paloma drink
Want to make the best version of a classic Paloma cocktail? Here's how
Paloma cocktail

Step aside margarita, the Paloma is the real drink of Mexico. The zesty cocktail is delicious any month of the year, but it's especially mouthwatering on a hot day. In a situation such as this, we like to pick the wise brains of cocktail gurus like Alicia Perry and Garret Dostal. Perry used to make incredible drinks at Polite Provisions and last we heard, works as a drinks guru at Consortium Holdings. Garrett Dostal is a cocktail consultant and brand ambassador for Hiatus Tequila.

"In terms of the Paloma cocktail, I am really looking for a cocktail that is juicy, acidic, and thirst quenching," Perry said. She adds that there are three major components at play -- the tequila for the Paloma, citrus, and soda. "In the process of creating my perfect Paloma I found that specific Blanco Tequilas were either too dominant, or were not able to stand up to the ingredients of the cocktail," she stated. "Fortaleza Blanco allowed for subtle notes of citrus, agave, and vanilla to be well represented in the cocktail."

Read more
How to make limoncello: Everything you need to know about this Italian delicacy
This brightly flavored Italian citrus liqueur is deliciously refreshing for any occasion
Limoncello shots and lemons

Limoncello is the bright, vibrant yellow liqueur that has become synonymous with sunshine on the Italian Riviera. Crafted from an aged blend of lemons and liquor, this sweet, slightly tart citrus cocktail is considered to be an Italian delicacy that is traditionally served chilled as a "digestive" after dinner or dessert.

Originating in the Campania region of southwestern Italy, limoncello was a common homemade liqueur that has been a part of family traditions and dinner rituals dating as far back as the turn of the 20th century.

Read more