Skip to main content

The Manual may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site.

Ilegal mezcal, Creyente mezcal, and more great smoky mezcals to sip all winter long

Great smoky mezcal options for fall and winter

Mezcal
Gastro Editorial/Unsplash

If you didn’t know it already, all Tequila is Mezcal, but not all Mezcal is Tequila. If you don’t understand, give us a moment to explain. You might not have realized until now that the broad term for agave-based spirits isn’t Tequila; it’s actually Mezcal. Tequila is simply a kind of Mezcal. Think of it like this: single malt Scotch is a type of whisk(e)y, and so is rye whiskey. And while we could spend days writing about Tequila, today is Mezcal’s day in the proverbial sun.

When it comes to Mezcal vs Tequila, while Tequila can only be made with Blue Weber Agave (along with other rules and regulations), Mezcal can be made with any type of agave. While there are more than 40 varieties, the most commonly used are espadín, tobalá, and tepeztate.

Similar to the production of Tequila, Mezcal begins with the agave hearts (or piñas). After harvesting, they’re roasted in a pit or stone ovens. This is why Mezcal is well-known to have a smokier, richer flavor than Tequila. The agave hearts are then pressed or crushed. The juice is fermented before being distilled.

Like Tequila, Mezcal is a protected denomination and can only be made in Mexico. While Tequila can be produced in Jalisco (where the town of Tequila is located) and a few other states, Mezcal can only be produced in Oaxaca, Guerrero, Michoacan, San Luis Potosi, Durango, Puebla, Guanajuato, Tamaulipas, and Zacatecas.

There are a few important categories of Mezcal. They are mezcal, artisanal mezcal, and ancestral mezcal. The first is produced using contemporary techniques and equipment like autoclaves and diffusers. Artisanal Mezcal is more traditional, with agave being roasted in pit ovens. Ancestral Mezcal is the most traditional, with agave being roasted in pit ovens along with fermentation in wooden tanks and other historic vessels. The Mezcal is even distilled in clay pots instead of stills.

Now that you know a little bit about Mezcal, it’s time to find some to drink. Lucky for you, we already did the hard work. Keep scrolling to see six of our favorite smoky mezcals to sip all winter.

Doña Vega Espadín
Doña Vega

Doña Vega Espadín

While Espadín is a very popular agave for mezcal production, Espadin Capon is a little less commonly used. This is the agave Doña Vega Espadín is made with. It’s hand-picked, roasted, fermented, and distilled. The result is a complex, flavorful mezcal with a ton of roasted agave, white pepper, and tropical fruit up front and a memorable smoky finish. The balance between roasted agave, fruity flavors, and smoke makes this a sublime sipper on a frigid winter night.

Del Maguey Mezcal Vida Clásico
Del Maguey

Del Maguey Mezcal Vida Clásico

When it comes to Mezcal, there are few brands more well-known than Del Maguey. While it makes myriad memorable expressions, its best for smoke fans is its Del Maguey Mezcal Vida Clásico. It all begins with Espadín agave. It’s roasted and naturally fermented before being distilled two times in woo-fired copper stills. The result is a sippable, warming Mezcal with notable flavors like roasted agave, tropical fruits, honey sweetness, cinnamon, ginger, and smoky, charred peppers. Spicy, sweet, and smoky, this is a highly memorable mezcal for the winter months.

400 Conejos
400 Conejos

400 Conejos Joven Oaxaca

If you only buy one smoky Mezcal on this list, make it 400 Conejos Joven Oaxaca. This award-winning Mezcal is known for its balance and complex flavor profile, featuring a nose of roasted agave, tropical fruits, and gentle smoke. Sipping it reveals even more vegetal, roasted agave, wood, light fruit, and robust campfire smoke. It’s a value sipper that deserves to be enjoyed neat or on the rocks.

Mezcal Vago Elote
Mezcal Vago Elote

Mezcal Vago Elote

This popular Mezcal gets its name because, while it starts as a classic Mezcal, distiller Aquilino Garcia Lopez adds roasted corn from his farm to complete the flavor profile. The result is a spirit that begins with a nose of roasted agave, tropical fruits, and light smoke and a palate of sweet honey, vegetal agave, caramelized pineapple, herbal notes, and a ton of robust, memorable smoke. The finish is a symphony of sweet corn, which ties all the other flavors together nicely.

Creyente Mezcal Joven
Creyente

Creyente Mezcal Joven

This joven Mezcal is made from Espadin agave grown in two separate areas and combined to make a nuanced, complex flavor. The first is Tlacolula, which is known for its rich terroir. The second is Yautepec, which is known for its high-elevation, mountainous geography. The result is a rich, sweet, mellow mezcal with a ton of citrus peel, cracked black pepper, tropical fruit, and rich smoky flavors. It’s the kind of sweet, smoky Mezcal you’ll enjoy sipping neat on a cold winter night.

Ilegal Joven
Ilegal

Ilegal Joven

With a name like Ilegal, you might assume there’s something nefarious or criminal about this mezcal brand. But, as mischievous as it seems, it’s simply a great mezcal. Especially its smoky, memorable Joven expression. This award-winning Mezcal is known for its mineral, herbal, fruity, smoky flavor profile that makes it a great choice for mixing into your favorite cocktail or sipping neat or on the rocks. It’s truly a versatile spirit and one that belongs on your home bar cart or liquor cabinet throughout the winter months (and beyond).

Editors' Recommendations

Christopher Osburn
Christopher Osburn is a food and drinks writer located in the Finger Lakes Region of New York. He's been writing professional
These are bartenders’ favorite value single malt Scotch whiskies (all under $100)
Bartenders tell us the best value single malt scotch whiskies
Scotch

If you don’t know much about single malt Scotch whisky (only the US and Ireland use the ‘e’ in whiskey), you might have some preconceived notions about its price. Like with any whisk(e)y, there are many uncomfortably expensive bottles of single malt whisky. There are also countless flavorful, reasonably-priced bottles. That’s what we’re most interested in today.

When we talk about value, we specifically talk about complex, rich, sippable single malt whiskies priced under $100. And these under $100 (and often much less) gems aren’t from lesser-known brands. They’re award-winning expressions from some of the most respected distilleries in Scotland.

Read more
The best vodka and vodka mixers for no hangover
The best hangover cure is to never get one in the first place
Cold cocktail with lime, lemon, tonic, vodka and ice on vintage background

Hangover side effects are unpleasant in every sense of the word, leaving us feeling unproductive and even sick the night after drinking. Most of us know drinking too much will lead to a hangover, but did you know the type of alcohol you drink and the mixer used can also contribute to the severity of your hangover? Carefully selecting the type of liquor you consume and opting for specific mixers can help you feel your best after drinking. Here's why vodka might be the smartest choice for no hangover symptoms.

Why vodka is the best liquor choice to avoid hangovers
While a hangover is nearly impossible to avoid if you drink too much, even moderate or casual drinking can lead to hangovers, too. No matter what your alcohol drink preferences are, it might be worth considering a switch to high-quality vodka if you're looking to minimize hangover effects. All types of alcohol contain ethanol. However, the differing fermentation and distilling processes of every alcohol can leave every kind of liquor with different chemicals remaining. The substances created as a byproduct of the fermentation process are known as congeners.
What do congeners do to the body?
Unfortunately, however, some types of alcohol are left with more congeners than others, resulting in worsened next-day hangover symptoms. Like ethanol, your body must also work to break down the congeners in the drinks you consume. If you've ever noticed tequila seems to lead to a worse hangover, it might be because tequila is a type of alcohol that is higher in congeners. Our bodies are left trying to break down two substances at once, which makes each process less efficient. In turn, this is why consuming alcoholic drinks that are high in congeners can lead to a worsened hangover.
Which types of alcohol are lowest in congeners?
A comprehensive study performed in 2013 explored the amount of congeners in many types of alcohol, including all liquors. The results of this study found that vodka was the option that had the least congeners per serving. But this doesn't mean that vodka can't give you a hangover; instead, it just means that it is less likely. Furthermore, the more times it is distilled in the production process, the more congeners will be removed. For this reason, choosing a high-quality vodka brand can help you reduce your chances of a hangover even more.

Read more
The best sommelier-approved wine picks for date night
Need some wine recommendations for date night? We've got you
Hands toasting with red wine

Wine has captivated the senses for what seems like an eternity. And while a solid Sauvignon Blanc is great for everyday sipping, special occasions call for special pours.

We’ve assembled a list of great wines worthy of your special somebody, whether you’re on a date or celebrating your 10th anniversary. The options come courtesy of seasoned pros representing restaurants all over the nation.

Read more