Skip to main content

Coffee vs. Tea: Is One Healthier Than The Other?

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Over the last several years, there have been many debates about which is better for you: Tea or coffee?

Some influencers and health advocates advise switching to chai, green tea, or matcha to forgo the “jolt” that often comes with drinking caffeine from coffee. You can instead opt for the slower and steadier stimulation that comes from the caffeine in green tea or the more concentrated version of green tea, matcha.

What is Coffee and Tea Made Of?

Turns out, the different types of tea (black, green, and oolong) actually all come from the same plant, but differ in nutrient and caffeine content depending on when the leaves are harvested and how they are processed. To keep it simple, black tea is fermented, green tea is non-fermented, and oolong tea is semi-fermented. Matcha is a powdered and concentrated form of green tea. Coffee beans come from the seeds of the fruit of coffee trees. Coffee trees grow in tropical regions and originated in Africa.

Both beverages are lauded for their stimulating and medicinal effects. Now that we know some of their differences, let’s answer the question: Which is healthier, tea or coffee?

Nutrients in Tea vs. Coffee

Coffee contains significant amounts of B vitamins (riboflavin, niacin, folate, pantothenic acid), which help with energy metabolism and nervous system health, and thus can likewise improve how you feel throughout your day. Coffee also contains minerals like choline, magnesium, phosphorus, potassium, and manganese which help with hydration and regulating the nervous system. Coffee also contains polyphenols, which are antioxidants that are found in plant-based foods. Research shows that these nutrients can be important for disease prevention.

Black tea does not contain as many B-vitamins as coffee, although it does contain a small amount of folate, similar to coffee. Tea contains the minerals magnesium, potassium, manganese, and theobromine. The polyphenols commonly found in tea are flavonols, theaflavins, quercetin, and catechins.

Green tea is nutritionally similar to black tea, but the vitamins and minerals vary depending on when the green tea is harvested. Green tea contains lots of polyphenols, including flavonols, quercetin, and catechins. The total polyphenol content of green and black tea is similar, but depending on the degree of oxidation during processing, can vary.

There are trace amounts of omega fatty acids in both coffee and tea, but not enough to make a difference in one’s diet and overall health.

Caffeine in Tea vs. Coffee

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Most of the adverse effects related to tea and coffee come from taking in too much caffeine. Adverse effects are usually associated with taking more than 500mg of caffeine. High levels of caffeine intake have been associated with higher levels of anxiety, headaches, and migraines.

Here is how much caffeine is in the average cup of coffee:

  • 8-ounce cup black coffee: 95 mg (caffeine)
  • 1-ounce espresso: 64 mg
  • 8 ounces instant coffee: 62 mg
  • 8 ounces decaf coffee: 2 mg

Here is how much caffeine is in the average cup of tea:

  • 8-ounce cup brewed black tea: 47 mg
  • 8-ounce cup oolong tea: 38 mg
  • 8-ounce cup green tea: 28 mg

What’s the Verdict?

More research is needed before we decide which drink is actually healthier for you. But based on what we know so far, coffee is a good source of B vitamins and minerals, while tea is a good source of polyphenols. In other words, your average cup of joe provides nutritional benefits for your metabolism and nervous system. Tea has lots of antioxidants that help prevent diseases like cancer, diabetes, and heart disease, but some of these nutrients in tea haven’t been studied as well as the vitamins and minerals in coffee have. Regardless of which drink you choose, you’ll still need a balanced diet to reap the nutritional benefits of both beverages.

A word of caution: It’s easy to chug down too much caffeine with either drink. Make sure to limit your coffee to four small cups per day. If you’re a French press or pour-over devotee, keep it to two to three cups a day. With tea, it’s much harder to OD on caffeine, but if you’re drinking a strong matcha, also keep it to four cups. Whether you decide to drink coffee or tea, rest assured: Both contain more nutrients than the isolated caffeine in energy drinks, so you’re probably better off drinking a cup of joe than a Red Bull.

Editors' Recommendations

Sheena Pradhan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Sheena Pradhan is a serial entrepreneur and digital marketer. She started her career as a Registered Dietitian and…
What is Bulletproof Coffee and Is It Healthy For You?
creamy bulletproof coffee.

There are probably as many different ways to prepare or take your coffee as there are days in the average month. Black, one sugar, a splash of cream, with an espresso shot, as a latte, cold brewed, double brewed—the list goes on and on. There’s also an avid tribe of coffee drinkers who add butter. That’s right; whether for purported health reasons and diet goals or simply because they agree with the often-tossed-around phrase that “everything tastes better with butter,” some people skip the milk, cream, and sugar and make their morning cup of coffee with grass-fed butter. Known as Bulletproof coffee, this creamy coffee drink is a breakfast staple—if not an offered as breakfast in its entirety—for many people practicing intermittent fasting or who are adherents of the keto diet, paleo diet, or other low-carb diets.
If you don’t regularly follow niche diet and wellness trends, there’s a good chance you’ve never heard of Bulletproof coffee and it may sound entirely unappetizing. But, if you’re a lover of creamy coffee drinks and low-carb living, your interest may be piqued. Either way, if you’re like us and think it can be fun to learn about different diet trends and consider whether they appeal to you or may improve your own health, keep reading for all the basics about Bulletproof coffee. We’ll answer common questions including what Bulletproof coffee is, how you make Bulletproof coffee, and if Bulletproof coffee is healthy.

What Is Bulletproof Coffee?

Read more
The Amazing Health Benefits of Matcha Tea
Ground matcha tea with whisk.

Simply put, Japanese matcha is one of the healthiest beverages in the world. Rich with antioxidants, matcha is both delicious and a great source of healthy caffeine. This type of green tea also comes in a variety of grades, each with different price levels and tastes. While traditionally enjoyed hot and unsweetened, modern innovation has created other variations of the beverage ranging from cold brew matcha to creamy matcha lattes.

To properly understand this intricate drink, expert guidance is needed. Enter Amy Truong and Lani Gobaleza, owners of PARU Tea Bar in San Diego. A married couple, the pair met in a study abroad program in Japan, quickly bonding over their common love for tea. In 2017, they started PARU Tea Bar after years of studying tea making and production all over the world. Their first venture focused on cold brew pop-ups and a tea subscription box before eventually opening a physical store in 2019 in the Point Loma neighborhood of San Diego. Since both have international backgrounds -- Amy with family in Vietnam, Japan, and France, and Lani’s family being Filipino -- PARU's selection of products is diverse, offering globally inspired drinks, loose leaf teas, lattes, and cold brew. Besides these beverages, they also have lifestyle merchandise, an online subscription service (monthly or yearly), and proudly feature tea-tasting events in their private tasting room at their new La Jolla store in San Diego.

Read more
10 Unique and Best Gifts for Tea Lovers
tea cup and bags.

Tea drinkers can quickly become tea lovers, eager to brew, stir, and sip premium teas from around the world or learn to prepare the perfect cup of soothing tea. There’s so much to learn about the art of tea, and it can become a true passion. It can be difficult to come up with unique gift ideas for tea lovers.
Sure, you can always buy your favorite tea lover a luxury loose-leaf green tea or a value pack of a sleepy bedtime tea, but sometimes it’s nice to get a special tea gift that will make a lasting impression. With that in mind, we’ve done the research, reviewing, and testing for you and come up with 10 of the best gifts for tea lovers to give you the inspiration you need to be the giver of the “best gift ever” to your favorite tea lover this year.

Hapinest Herbal Tea Indoor Garden Seed Starter Growing Kit

Read more