Skip to main content

Basil Hayden’s Rye Whiskey Review

Rye is all the rage, there’s no doubt about that. With rye whiskeys winning top awards for the past few years, more and more companies seem to be coming out with rye whiskeys to enter into the market. It shouldn’t really be a surprise, though, as Basil Hayden’s Bourbon already has a high rye mash bill and the spicy character that comes from rye is one of the key associations most people have when you mention Basil Hayden’s in conversation.

Basil Hayden’s Rye whiskey is four-year-old rye that’s been moved from its aging barrels into new charred quarter casks and left for seven more years. Some of this product is then blended with straight rye whiskey to achieve what will sit in the bottle before you.

Basil Hayden Rye Whiskey
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Appearance: Basil Hayden’s Rye Whiskey is golden-orange in color.

Nose: Mellow is the best word to describe this whiskey, through and through. There are hints of wood on the nose and these are complemented nicely by baking spices and just a little bit of sweet corn.

Palate: The upfront spice that you might expect in other straight rye whiskeys is somewhat muted here. You get hints of the spice, but the majority of the palate is composed of deep brown sugar notes mixing with dried fruit and a little bit of baking spice. Throughout, you will be hard-pressed to find a burn—this is one smooth rye whiskey.

Finish: A medium-length finish that pulls smoky caramel flavors through to the end, clearly a byproduct of being put into new charred oak casks.

Final Thoughts: If you have somehow not had a rye in the past two or three years and are unsure of spicier whiskeys, then Basil Hayden’s Rye is a perfect place to start. I won’t call it an introductory rye, because there is more going on than you might find in other spirits that might fall into a similar category, but it is a good place to gauge how your palate accepts or will adjust to spicier whiskeys. Also, it’s great in cocktails, which is always a bonus.

Basil Hayden’s Rye Whiskey is 40% ABV and retails for $45. You can also check out our review of Vinn Rice Whiskey and Booker’s Bourbon.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics
Sam Slaughter
Sam Slaughter was the Food and Drink Editor for The Manual. Born and raised in New Jersey, he’s called the South home for…
Rabbit Hole London Dry Gin Review: Great for Whiskey Lovers
rabbit hole london dry gin cocktail

We’re no strangers to barrel-aged gins here at The Manual. Whether it is the peated Big Gin or, more recently, Starbucks’ adventure into the gin barrel-aged coffee market, we like it when two of our favorite spirits are brought together.

This time, that combination of whiskey and gin comes to us in the form of Rabbit Hole's London Dry Gin, which is aged in char #3 Kentucky Rye barrels. Rabbit Hole, which is based in Louisville, imports the gin from London before aging it in their own Kentucky rye barrels for a short period of time.

Read more
Pittsburgh’s Wigle Whiskey Releases New Spirits
Wigle Whiskey Rudolph

Wigle Whiskey, a craft distillery located in Pittsburgh, has a bunch of new whiskeys and other spirits that are out just in time for the holidays.

First up is one of the most exciting, Deep Cut Bottled in Bond Rye. This organic rye whiskey was made from a mash bill of 65% rye, 18% wheat, and 17% barley, bottled at 100 proof as required by law, and aged for five years in new charred oak barrels. Then there is Rudolph Whiskey, a straight wheat whiskey that was aged in Christmas Ale barrels from Great Lakes Brewing Co., giving it a bit of spice.

Read more
Wolves Whiskey Releases Newest Expression Called Winter Run
wolves whiskey

Last year, the first release from new brand Wolves Whiskey sold out quite rapidly, something which founders James Bond (co-founder of Undefeated) and Jon Buscemi (founder of Buscemi) hope to repeat. This year's release is called Winter Run, and like last year's it's a blend of various whiskeys, mostly distilled by master distiller Marko Karakasevic of Charbray Distillery. This year's release is a blend of the following: whiskey distilled from stout beer aged in French oak for eight years, whiskey distilled from pilsner beer aged in new American oak for five years, rye whiskey (not distilled by Karakasevic), and a single malt whiskey aged for nine years in used French oak.

Yes, this is basically another celebrity-fronted whiskey, although not of the caliber of, say, The Rock's new tequila venture. It's questionable how much these fashion mavens actually had to do with selecting the liquid that you will find in the bottle, although according to Buscemi they were very involved. “We took some cues from First Run while incorporating a really earthy single malt," he said in a prepared statement. "I like single malts all year round but enjoy them most in the colder months. It took a lot of work to get this right, but the result is special and I’m happy we were able to crank out a few more bottles this time in production.”

Read more