Skip to main content

Why nutrition experts say you (probably) don’t need that gluten-free diet

Do you believe these gluten-free diet myths?

Just when you thought the experts had spoken and the people agreed that the Mediterranean diet was best, social media whet people’s appetites for more. This year alone, there’s been the “all-carnivore diet” and “All-McDonald’s diet,” which are precisely what they sound like and have received two thumbs down from the nutrition community.  

However, another diet trend won’t go away: Gluten free.

Gluten is a term used to describe proteins found in wheat, rye, barley, and triticale (a wheat-rye cross). There are a ton of foods with gluten, like bread. Gluten helps keep their shape and serves as a glue to hold everything together. 

A gluten-free diet is necessary for some people, such as those with gluten sensitivities or celiac disease. However, do people without these conditions need to stock up on gluten-free foods? Should they go entirely gluten-free?

The short answer is no.

“There are no benefits to being gluten-free if you don’t need to be,” said Anna Mapson, a registered nutritionist and founder of Goodness Me Nutrition.

Nutrition experts broke down the pros, cons, and misconceptions of living gluten-free (without celiac or a sensitivity).

baked bread sliced on a white table
Mariana Kurnyk/Pexels

The basics of a gluten-free diet

Before you eliminate an ingredient, it’s best to get the facts.

What foods have gluten?

Gluten-free diets can be challenging because it’s in so many foods, including ones you wouldn’t expect. Kimberly Gomer, RDN, a private practicing registered dietitian in Miami, says you’ll find gluten in:

  • Beer
  • Bread
  • Cakes
  • Pies
  • Bulgur wheat
  • Cereal
  • Cookies
  • Crackers
  • Communion wafers
  • French fries
  • Crotons
  • Sauces
  • Chips
  • Soups

Are there benefits to going gluten-free? 

Generally, no. 

“While a gluten-free diet is essential for people with celiac disease or gluten sensitivity, there is no evidence to suggest that a gluten-free diet is beneficial for the general population,” said Nick Zanetti, a nutritional therapist. 

However, some people may have issues with gluten, even if they don’t have celiac disease or a sensitivity.

“There is a percentage of the population that responds to the main protein in gluten called gliadin by producing a protein in the intestine called zonulin,” Zanetti said, pointing to a 2006 study on the subject. “This is a problem as zonulin can raise the level of intestinal permeability and inflammation.”

Are there drawbacks to going gluten-free?

Many, actually. 

“There are several potential drawbacks to a gluten-free diet, including nutrient deficiencies, increased cost, and social restrictions,” Zanetti said.

Mapson adds that buying gluten-free foods like special bread products can be costly. She also adds that gluten is essential to digestive health in many fiber-rich products like whole grains.

“If you’re gluten-free, you should eat a lot of vegetables, fruits, nuts and seeds, pulses, wholegrains such as oats (if tolerated), brown rice, and gluten-free quinoa,” Mapson said.

several pizzas on a wood table
Narda Yescas/Pexels

Myths about gluten-free diets, debunked

The gluten-free craze isn’t new, and nutrition experts say it’s long past time to nix these myths about the gluten-free diet. Experts discussed nutrition and weight loss myths.

Gluten is inherently bad for you

That is not true, but the idea that gluten is bad for you is too common.

“In reality, gluten is a protein found in wheat, barley, and rye, and it is only harmful to those with celiac disease or gluten sensitivity,” Zanetti said. “But any food containing gliadin — one of the main proteins of gluten — has the potential of trigger intestinal permeability and an increase in inflammation.”

The keyword: Potential.

Gluten-free foods are healthier

Seeing “gluten-free” on a label is not a catch-all sign the food is “healthy.”

Processed, high-sugar foods like cookies and cakes might be gluten-free, but that doesn’t mean consuming only them will lead you to health and wellness.

“The main drawback I have seen in my clients is that they add gluten-free processed foods to their diets, assuming it is healthier,” Gomer said. “The majority of gluten-free products like bread, cereal, cookies, and cakes are even more processed and loaded with more sugar, salt, and processed flours as compared to their gluten-laden counterparts.”

If you’re going gluten-free, continue to read the whole nutrition label as you meal plan and shop.

“It is important when attempting to transition to a gluten-free diet that whole, unprocessed foods are replacing the gluten-containing ones, Gomer said.

Gomer suggests adding more whole grains to your diet, including gluten-free oats, corn, and brown rice.

You will definitely lose weight on a gluten-free diet

If only it were that easy.

“They may believe that just removing gluten will magically help them lose weight,” Gomer said. “I have seen many clients actually gain weight when removing gluten.”

Gomer noted that there are many lifestyle factors involved. 

“This means choosing other healthy foods like fruits, vegetables, lean protein, and lots of water,” Gomer said. “Consistent exercise also leads to better health outcomes with a well-balanced diet with gluten-containing foods.” 

Bottom line?

“We always strive for optimal health and energy – both physically and mentally,” Gomer said. “We need to be careful not to have one scapegoat – gluten.”

Gluten-free diets are popular but often misunderstood. Though necessary for certain people, namely those with celiac, most experts say the cons outweigh the pros for everyone else. Gluten-free diets may lack nutrients, such as fiber, a component of good digestive health. “Gluten-free” doesn’t mean healthy, and cutting it from your diet won’t necessarily help you lose weight. Other lifestyle factors, such as a holistic approach to your diet and exercise, play into weight.

What’s more, you’re not the number on the scale. Aim to eat nutritious foods that make you feel good — whatever that means to you. Speaking to a primary care physician or dietician about your food choices can be helpful if you are concerned.

Editors' Recommendations

BethAnn Mayer
Beth Ann's work has appeared on healthline.com and parents.com. In her spare time, you can find her running (either marathons…
The pros and cons of counting calories for weight loss: What you need to know
Weighing up the pros and cons of calorie counting
measuring tape wrapped around a silver fork on orange background

Nicholas Clement first introduced calories in Paris between 1819 and 1824. By 1918, books on calorie counting for weight loss were published. Some people lose weight by counting every calorie, while others successfully use other methods, like ditching sugar, following a ketogenic diet, or starting a new workout routine. We’ve listed the pros and cons of calorie counting — one of the oldest and most widely-discussed approaches to weight loss. 

What are calories?
Your food and drinks provide you with units of energy called calories. You can read the calorie counts on nutrition labels to determine how many calories are in a particular food item. You take in calories from your food and drink and burn calories for energy.

Read more
Does collagen count as protein? What you need to know about counting your protein macros
collagen powder

Collagen peptides have gained a lot of popularity in the health, beauty, and fitness industries over the past decade, offering many health benefits, from improved skin appearance to stronger muscles. Powdered collagen supplements, which come in a large container similar to protein powder, are the most popular. You might also see collagen in capsule supplement form. Collagen supplements are made of small pieces of animal collagen and contain mostly protein. Despite this, your daily collagen supplement should not count towards your protein macro goals. Here's why.

Does collagen count towards protein goals?
Hitting your daily target protein macro is an essential component of any healthy diet. Given that protein is the building block of your hair, skin, bones, muscles, and skin, your body relies heavily on the amino acids found in protein. Not to mention, protein helps give us energy and keep us full between meals. But collagen powder is not quite the same as a protein powder supplement.

Read more
Can’t do pull ups? You need this simple addition to your workout routine
a man doing pull ups

There's no doubt that a pull-up is one of the most challenging exercises to master. Not only does a pull-up require a strong upper body, but it also requires grip strength and core stability. Even for people who regularly do killer back exercises at the gym, a pull-up is a different type of motion than that of many strength training exercises -- making it difficult even for those with a strong back. However, with time, patience, and dedication, anyone can master the pull-up.

There are many approaches to pull-up training, such as using an assisted pull-up machine or performing negative reps. Ultimately, a combination of techniques and exercises can help your body gradually get used to pull-ups and improve over time. Using a pull-up band is a great way for beginners of any skill level to start practicing a pull-up motion. Here's how.

Read more