Skip to main content

Want to buy an EV? Don’t – this is why you should lease an electric car instead

Wait to buy an EV because leasing might be the best option

ev charging in sunny weather
Blue Planet Studio / Shutterstock

One of the sad ironies of being a car lover is how much of a pain the actual act of buying a car can be. Pushy salespeople, contract terms that require a JD and a magnifying glass to comprehend, and enough miscellaneous fees to make a cell phone company blush. So, more often than not, many of us tend to lean towards buying a car rather than leasing because who would willingly volunteer to go through that kind of patience-pumping torture every three years? But, the EV movement has begun more than an energy revolution in the automotive universe, and leasing might just be the new buying.

While it used to be that purchasing a car was a net positive in the long term – eventually, the payments ended, and when they finished, the buyer actually had something tangible to show for it. But, with the relatively new landscape that the electric vehicle world has brought about, there are plenty of reasons that it makes much more sense to lease than buy a new EV.

3d rendering group of electric cars with pack of battery cells module on platform in a row
phonlamaiphoto / Adobe Stock

EV battery tech is still evolving

As we saw with the advent of plasma televisions in the early 2000s, generally speaking, technology is most expensive when it is new. And while having a fifty-inch high-definition TV made you a hero on football Sundays, spending ten grand for one was a great way to bench your bank account. But when plasma gave way to LCD, which (ironically) led to LED, and then most recently to OLED. Now, a fifty-inch high-def television can be had for around two percent of that turn-of-the-century price tag at your local Walmart.

That same flow chart of advancement can be applied to EVs and their batteries. Huge, heavy, and hampered by limited range, the early days of the EV batteries will not be missed. Slowly and steadily, we are seeing improvements to help alleviate the dreaded ‘range anxiety.’ Faster and more available charging stations combine with better batteries that can hold more charge and offer higher range. But, at best, we are in the pubescent period of EVs, and what is innovative today may well be antiquated three years from now. So rather than buying that Tesla Model 3 or Kia EV6 and risk being stuck with an outdated electric vehicle like the owner of a Zune watching the iPod nano entering the market, a lease allows you to enjoy your modern car today and be done with it before it becomes passé.

tax credit form EV

Leasing an EV can save you $7,500

While the federal tax credit can be had by those who choose to purchase an EV, the Inflation Reduction Act can make some feel like they’re facing more hoops than to jump through than LeBron James has in his career. The car must cost less than $55,000, while an SUV or truck has an $80,000 price ceiling. The vehicle must be made in North America, and its battery must meet specific sourcing requirements.

But, through a technical loophole that states a lease is a commercial sale to the dealer, which allows the EV to qualify for the much less stringent commercial vehicle tax credit. The end result is that the dealer can then apply that $7,500 to the price of the car, ultimately resulting in lower monthly payments with fewer headaches.

Tesla group photo with Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y parked in front of charger during sunset.

What will a used EV be worth ten years from now?

Aside from the change in fueling, EVs are also poised to shake up the entire used car segment. While many companies offer an average warranty of eight years and 100,000 miles for hybrid and EV vehicles, beyond that, no one knows much of anything. We see the collectibility of exceptional gas-powered cars of our past, like the BMW Z8 or Ferrari F50, the resale value of the average coupe or sedan can depend on everything from production numbers to power potential to paint color.

But anyone who has ever bought a refurbished MacBook or ThinkPad knows that the battery is something that usually needs to be addressed, even if everything else is in mint condition. In the auto world, while swapping the battery on a gas-powered car can be replaced with a 20-minute trip to Autozone, replacing one on a Tesla can cost upwards of $20,000, which adds a massive caveat of consideration when looking at that used Model S.

Audi E-tron GT
Miles Branman/The Manual / Audi

What EVs will end up being nostalgic?

Beyond just the technical and practical applications of value, no one really knows what the intangible nostalgic price tag of any electric vehicle will be because there just isn’t much evidence to draw from yet. While we have seen many Corvettes over the years come and go, it has become relatively easy to see which ones have the potential to be truly special and which do not.

But thirty years from now, will it be the Falcon-doored Model X or the Tony Stark-driven Audi E-Tron GT that middle-aged enthusiasts lust after and will fork over tons of their hard-earned cryptocurrency for? Or will aging EVs be frowned upon and looked at as decrepit relics of a technological adolescence that merely bridged a gap like 8-track players between records and MP3s?

Sure, there are collectors of everything, but for now, perhaps it is better just to lease that new EV rather than going all in on buying a car that may be out of style quicker than laser discs. Who knows, maybe the electric revolution will bring about a wave of more passive salespeople and plain-language contracts too, which would ironically make buying into leases a no-brainer.

Editors' Recommendations

Lou Ruggieri
A lifelong lover of cars, Lou contributes to Motor Trend, Hot Cars, Auto & Truck Connection, and the PowerAutoMedia Group.
The 2025 BMW M5 Touring is coming to the U.S., but don’t call it a station wagon
If you liked the M5 Sedan, you'll love the M5 Touring
Camoflaged 2025 BMW M5 Sedan and M5 Touring European models parked side by side on ice on a huge body of water.

BMW enthusiasts in the U.S. who favor the big extra helping of high-performance in the BMW M model will have good reason to celebrate this fall. BMW confirmed this week that when the seventh generation of the M5 platform completes final testing and goes into production, U.S. model shipments for the first time will include the M5 Touring model and the M5 Sedan.
Why the BMW M5 Touring coming to the U.S. matters

Americans haven't entirely abandoned sedans in the last decade, but a glance in parking lots and city streets reveals few sedans. SUVs and light trucks outnumber sedans and coupes by wide margins on U.S. roadways. The BMW 5 Series, including the M5 variant, has long enjoyed a reputation as one of, if not the best, performance sedans available, but BMW chose not to ship the M5 Touring model to our shores. Until now.

Read more
5 non-Ferrari cars you wouldn’t guess have a Ferrari engine
These cars have Ferrari engines, even if they don't have the prancing horse badge
Fiat Dino Spider

A Ferrari engine is a special thing indeed. The Prancing Horse has built its reputation around powerful motors that deliver the performance you would expect from one of the world’s most storied and exclusive sports car brands.

However, while getting certain Ferraris onto your driveway may require a close relationship with your local dealership, years of documented enthusiasm, and enough in the bank to not only buy the car but also keep it in the manner to which it is accustomed, the engines themselves aren’t the exclusive parts.

Read more
Buyer beware: The least reliable cars you can buy in 2024
Know the car reliability ratings of these bad buys
Front end angle of 2021 Ford F-150 parked on a dirt trail in front of a red barn and trees.

According to statistics, car sales grew by about 75.3 million globally in 2023, up from the estimated 67.3 million units sold in 2022. Evidently, buying a car is a big purchase, like buying a home, that many people want to achieve during their lifetime. 

Unfortunately, much like houses, cars have become increasingly more expensive in recent years. This is why people want to ensure they are buying a reliable car that isn't going to break down on them a few months to years down the line. The bottom line is drivers want reliability now more than ever. 

Read more