Skip to main content

Personalized experiences beat loyalty points for most travelers, says survey

Today's travelers no longer seek transactional loyalty

Arizona Biltmore
Emily Caldwell / The Manual

A recently published survey by Talker Research suggested a new era in personalized travel. The study polled 2,000 Americans ages 18+ who have traveled in the last 12 months, and found that nearly 68% of travelers now say they’ll stay loyal to hotels that deliver standout, personalized experiences, leaving traditional, points-based rewards behind. The survey’s findings suggest that today’s luxury travelers embrace personalization, preferring tailored experiences over an outdated points-based reward system. This study highlights the changing needs of travelers who no longer seek transactional loyalty. Instead, today’s travelers want genuine recognition.

The poll of 2,000 American travelers found that only 24% of Americans say hotel rewards are the most valuable (behind grocery store rewards, credit card points, gas rewards, and airline miles). Additionally, 82% of current hotel loyalty members cited frustrations with traditional programs, including points expiring too quickly (28%), blackout dates (24%), and difficulty earning meaningful rewards (23%). These challenges drive travelers, especially younger and affluent segments, to seek alternatives.

Recommended Videos

Other key findings from this survey suggest that affluent travelers, specifically those earning between $150,000-$200,000, are more likely to prefer personalized experiences, and those earning over $200,000 want more from their current loyalty membership. Additionally, data suggests that most travelers are willing to share their data to improve hotel experiences. The data from this survey ultimately suggests that the hotel industry needs to move away from transactions and foster genuine connections, replacing outdated point systems and loyalty tiers with real-time recognition, seamless digital experiences, and tailored offerings that make every guest feel like a VIP.

Emily Caldwell
Emily is a freelance journalist with a focus on food, travel, health, and fitness content. She loves to travel to new…
What most travelers get wrong about luggage, according to a travel expert
Choosing the right suitcase beyond how it looks on the shelf
TravelPro Luggage

Before I became an avid traveler, I never gave a whole lot of thought to luggage. To me, luggage was just something you had stuffed away in the attic for the occasional use. I soon learned that not all luggage is created equally when I began traveling every month. Selecting the right luggage can make or break your trip, offering functionality and style that sets you up for success.

With summer travel heating up, Juan Phillips, VP of Product Design & Innovation at Travelpro, says more travelers are reevaluating their gear -- and falling for many common luggage myths (I know I have). Since joining Travelpro, Juan has dedicated himself to making the company the most innovative luggage brand. His current work at Travelpro includes managing the design and development of all luggage collections and accessories. Below, Phillips debunks some of the most common luggage myths to help you choose the right suitcase beyond how it looks on the shelf.
Hardside luggage vs. softside luggage

Read more
Luxury travelers say they’re avoiding this one trend in 2025
Luxury travelers are looking to avoid "Beige-ification"
A hand opening a hotel room door with the room interior in the background

If there’s one thing affluent travelers are steering clear of in 2025, it’s sameness.

According to the newly released 2025 Luxury Travel Report from Preferred Hotels & Resorts, the biggest turnoff for today’s high-end jet-setters isn’t long flights or price hikes, it’s what the report calls “Beige-ification.” The term captures a growing dissatisfaction with the copy-and-paste culture of luxury travel, where experiences, design, and service have become nearly indistinguishable from one destination to the next.

Read more
A new travel experience just launched — for you and your dog
Get ready to go glamping with your pup
Dog camping

If you’ve ever dreamed of a luxury vacation designed just as much for your dog as for you, get ready to pack your pup’s overnight bag. Cruise Tales, the company known for its dog-centric events and canine-friendly cruising adventure, has just announced its latest experience: a land-based retreat called the Happy Tails Glamping Getaway.

Set in the scenic woodlands of High Springs, Florida, just two hours from Orlando, this five-day, Halloween-themed escape runs from October 30 to November 3 and is tailored specifically for dog lovers and their four-legged companions. Guests will stay in one of 45 luxury air-conditioned tiny cabins scattered across 90 private acres filled with moss-draped oaks and nature trails. Each cabin includes one queen-sized bed, with a limited number offering two.

Read more