Skip to main content

Don’t make these common mistakes when grilling fish

What not to do when grilling fish

Grilled salmon
amenic181 / Adobe Stock

Sweet, sweet summer is on its way. That means lazy days, fired-up grills, and al fresco dining. It also opens the door for plenty of mistakes to be made when cooking and entertaining.

Recommended Videos

When it comes to grilling fish, there are many things that people do wrong. Frankly, the makeup of fish is not quite like other grill-ables such as chicken, pork, or steak. That said, they behave a bit differently on the grill, whether it’s charcoal or gas. So we reached out to an expert in the field to point them out, setting you up for better salmon, halibut, and grouper dinners this grilling season.

Rima Kleiner is a registered dietician and blogger at Dish on Fish. She’s a member of the Academy of Nutrition and sings the many health praises of seafood, not to mention to dynamic range of flavors and styles. Here are the top five mistakes she says people make when grilling fish.

Not prepping your fish for the grill

Fresh fillets of fish about to be cooked.
Marco Verch / Shutterstock

“Whether you choose to marinate or not, preparing your seafood with a rub or marinade before grilling will deliver big in the taste department,” Kleiner says. “Even something as simple as a salt rub or basic marinade of olive oil, lemon, herbs and salt (which is my fallback when grilling fish!) will help to lock in taste.”

Don’t shy away from something a little more complex either, like a marinade involving some powerful citrus-like yuzu. And make that fish all the better with a good side when the time comes, like mango salsa or grilled asparagus with lemon.

Not cleaning the grill prior to cooking

Brush cleaning grill grates
RDNE Stock project/Pexels / Pexels

“Cooking seafood—or any food—on a grill that hasn’t been cleaned likely means your food will pick up the burnt taste of the food cooked on the grates before,” Kleiner says. “For the best tasting grilled seafood, gently scrape the grates before or after heating (though cleaning after heating may help dislodge stubborn burnt pieces).”

Think of it in terms of relativity, which is a great way to look at most things involving food. Just as improperly stored food items in your fridge and affect the flavors of other leftover items in there, what was previously on your grill and impart unwanted flavors to what you’re presently cooking. Start clean; that’s the way to go.

Not oiling or preheating the grill properly

Man grilling over large flame
Nicholas Peloso / Unsplash

“Just like oven cooking, you’ll get the most evenly, best-tasting food when the grill has been preheated,” Kleiner says. “Let the grill heat up for about ten minutes, then oil with a high-smoke point oil (avocado oil works well) to help prevent the food from sticking.”

Starting to early can dry seafood out or result in a fish that’s partially cooked in one area and fully cooking in another. Also, keep in mind where the major heat spots are on your grill and lay your proteins out accordingly.

Not grilling skin-side down

Salmon fillet with coarse ground pepper, grilled over a cedar plank.
Getty Images

This one is pretty easy to remember, as there isn’t much wiggle room. “If your seafood has skin on it, grill with the skin side down,” Kleiner says. “And let it cook until almost done before flipping to prevent sticking.” Being a little more patient here will allow for a nice, clean release when it’s time, not to mention a crispy and delicious skin layer.

Not cooking for the right amount of time

A man grills in a campsite with a truck behind him.
Jay Miller / Unsplash / Unsplash

While adequate cooking time depends on the species, a good rule of thumb to keep in mind when cooking fish is to grill ten minutes for every inch of thickness,” Kleiner says. “If your fish is about one inch thick at the thickest part, cook for about ten minutes (and don’t flip until at least halfway through the cooking time). If your fish is one-and-a-half inches at its thickest, grill for about 15 minutes and so on.”

With the above in mind, fish grilling season will certainly be a more enjoyable and flavorful affair. Also keep in mind the seasonality of seafood and chat up your local fishmonger or seafood specialist. If you happen to live near the sea, all the better. If not, there are still great ways to get fresh seafood online.

Grilling whole fish is always fun and can be a show-stopped when hosting a meal. We suggest smaller salmon species, sea bass, trout, or red snapper. But play around and see what’s available locally in your neck of the woods.

Hungry? Us too. Check out our guides on pairing seafood and wine and how to clean a fish. Your grilling game is about to improve a notch or two.

Mark Stock
Mark Stock is a writer from Portland, Oregon. He fell into wine during the Recession and has been fixated on the stuff since…
Topics
Do you cut with or against the grain? Here’s the truth when slicing steak
Why you should always cut steak against the grain (and how to do it right)
Steak on cutting board

Have you ever seen someone grill a flank steak and they nailed the marinade, timed the cooking just right, and even let it rest like the patient adult we all strive to be when it's time to dig in? I have, and I thought it was a masterclass on how to get a juicy steak out of a fairly lean cut, but that brings me to where things went wrong.

When they sliced it, they cut it the long way, with the grain, and served it up. Everyone chewed. And chewed. And chewed some more. A perfectly cooked steak had the texture of a gym towel. That was the day I learned the hard truth; how you slice your steak matters. Big time. So, what does it mean to cut with or against the grain, and what does that look like if you'rer trying to achieve the most tender steak possible? Let's get into it.
What does 'cutting against the grain' mean?

Read more
5 mistakes to avoid when learning how to grill top sirloin
A person is cooking a sirloin steak in a pan with herbs and spices. The steak is brown and he is well-cooked

Grilling top sirloin sounds simple enough, until you end up with a piece of meat that's tough, dry, or way past medium rare. This lean cut has tons of flavor, but it also comes with a learning curve if you want to get it just right. Essentially, I'm saying, there are a lot of ways that things can go wrong, from seasoning slip-ups to temperature troubles; small mistakes can make a huge difference. I’ve definitely overcooked a few steaks in my time, but once I learned what not to do, everything changed.

So, whether you’re a grill newbie or just looking to improve your steak game, avoiding these common mistakes can take your top sirloin from decent to pretty impressive. So, how do you grill top sirloin? Now's the perfect time to lay the foundation so you don't ruin a perfectly good steak when you throw it on the grill.

Read more
7 must-know tips for the best burger seasoning for grilling
Noteworthy tips to bring the most flavor out of burgers
Burgers on a grill

I didn’t always know what I was doing on the grill. There was one summer when I learned how to make a hamburger, I figured a quick sprinkle of salt and pepper made me a burger expert. In reality ... it didn’t. The patties looked great, but they lacked flavor and soul. That’s when I started experimenting with spices, testing ratios, and learning what makes beef sing. Fast-forward to today, and I’ve landed on the best burger seasoning for grilling, and I’m laying it all out right here. If you want brag-worthy burgers, this list will get you there.
1. Seasoning matters more than you think

Ground beef is a blank canvas. It’s mild, even a little bland, to be honest. Seasoning transforms it because it adds depth, creates crust, enhances fat, and keeps you wanting to take your next bite. Skip this part, and even the fanciest beef falls flat. Gordon Ramsay is an industry vet who does an excellent job of showcasing how the work toward a great burger starts with getting your beef patties ready by seasoning them ahead of time.
2. You can mix it in or sprinkle it on, but I'd go with sprinkling

Read more