Skip to main content

You’re drinking rum all wrong — why you need to treat it more like wine

Chances are good that you're not giving rum drinks the resect they deserve

Even if you take rum seriously, as you should, you’re probably doing it wrong. The spirit has long been served in shot form or buried in candy-sweet drinks. Enough is enough, as good rum deserves better.

You see, good rum is a lot like good wine. It can be complex, sip-worthy stuff, wildly reflective of the region it was produced in. It’s easy to write rum off as a tropical drink and little more, but it’s simply not true. The flavor spectrum of the spirit is vast, thanks to variations in production from country to country. A rum may be distilled from a certain type of sugarcane, using one type of still and aged a certain way in the West Indies while one from the Dominican Republic might be made a completely different way.

A set of Plantation rums from around the world.

The rules for making rum are longstanding and vary from country to country. That’s a big plus for the taster, as you can really get a sense of terroir bouncing from one rum-production country to the next in warm regions like the Caribbean.

Explore regionality

I was lucky enough to get my hands on some remarkable one-off rums from Plantation. There were six in all, part of the brand’s Birds of Paradise release in 2020 (the bottles are gorgeous). Each rum was made in a different country and aged at a different length. The oldest vintage in the bunch was 2003.

The level of character and distinctiveness in each offering was impressive. I’ve spent years tasting through wines from all over the planet and this tasting was done in the same general spirit. I could not believe the amount of variation. The Jamaican rum from 2003,  made from molasses in a double retort Vendome pot still and aged 16 years in bourbon casks, showed marzipan, prunes, green banana, tropical fruit, and black pepper. The one from Peru, a 2006 and my favorite of the bunch, was made in a combination of column and pot stills and showed dark chocolate, citrus, and some fruity esters. It was unbelievably smooth and graceful. It went on like this, rewriting my already broad and respectful definition of fine rum.

Now, you don’t need a special collection of rums like this to enjoy the breadth and quality of the spirit (although some bottles from the collection do show up online now and again and are worth hunting for). Simply peruse a more eclectic liquor store with a solid rum section and incorporate a few different nations and styles. Try a few different ages from prominent places like Barbados, Jamaica, Cuba, Guatemala, Martinique, and more.

Taste properly

Treat it like wine

That means put together an actual tasting, comparing and contrasting multiple brands from various countries. Use a large glass so you can really get your nose in there and rinse it in between tastes. Conduct a tasting with a friend and compare notes on what you’re detecting in each sip. Explore the context so you know more about what you’re enjoying, such as what different stills tend to do to rum, how aging affects both the color and flavor of the stuff, how climate can play a factor, and the differences between utilizing sugarcane or molasses from the get-go.

Take notes and trust your palate

You may not taste everything you see listed in the tasting notes, but the more you explore the category, the better prepared your palate will be. Rums can be similar, but when tasted side by side, can really flaunt their independence. And remember to stay hydrated and take frequent water breaks. You can treat rum like wine, just note that it has a much higher ABV so exercise some caution. Consider adding a little water to the highest proof options in your tasting and take your time; it’s not a race.

A set of Plantation rums on a table.

Pair it up

Yes, you can pair with rum. Lighter rums do great with dishes like ceviche, jerk chicken, even mac and cheese. Darker rums do great with cheeses, grilled meats like steak, and pulled pork. Unsurprisingly, a lot of great pairings honor the dishes that are popular in that specific rum-producing country. Mix up a complementary snack spread that includes things like dried fruit (mango, pineapple, etc.), salted nuts, pretzels, candied ginger, and even some mild sweets (think angel food cake or snickerdoodles).

There are a few names to look out for. Renegade Rum from Grenada is a fantastic light rum selection, showing colossal caramelized plantain notes. Also check out Diplomatico, Zacapa, Flor de Cana, and Appleton Estate, just to name a few. Many of these labels feature various aged rums as well as tweaks in styles that reflect where it’s made.

Editors' Recommendations

Mark Stock
Mark Stock is a writer from Portland, Oregon. He fell into wine during the Recession and has been fixated on the stuff since…
These 2 whiskies go with everything you’re going to serve at Thanksgiving dinner
Add these two whiskeys to your Thanksgiving menu for a happier holiday
Dragon Glassware Diamond Whiskey Glass

Thanksgiving is a day for being with those we love, feasting on delicious food until we can feast no more, and reflecting on the things we are most thankful for. And if whiskey doesn't top your list, we probably shouldn't be friends. While wine and other specialty cocktails (pumpkin martini, anyone?) may be the Thanksgiving drinks that shine at your family's table, there's always a place for whiskey. Surprisingly, this beautiful brown liquor pairs perfectly with many traditional Thanksgiving foods with its complex, well-rounded flavors. So in your holiday preparations, be sure to pick up a few bottles of these perfect whiskeys for Thanksgiving dinner.

It's difficult to narrow our selections down to two, but we understand that a full whiskey bar at Thanksgiving may not be the new tradition you want to start this year... though, it sounds like a perfectly reasonable (and spectacular) custom to us.

Read more
Compound butter: It’s the thing you’re missing in your life — and your meals
Compound butter is magical flavor bomb will make all of your dishes shine
how to make compound butter img 3543

If you're looking for an easy, instant upgrade to just about any dish, compound butter is the way to go. When you're looking for ways to add flavor to a dish, you can't go wrong with infusing butter, already the world's most perfect food, with fresh herbs and savory flavors like garlic and shallots. If you're wondering how to make an over-the-top magnificent bird this Thanksgiving, the answer is compound butter. A steakhouse-quality steak for date night at home? Compound butter. Roasted vegetables with a complex, buttery sauce straight from your fridge? You get it.

So how do you make this magical ingredient? And how can you be sure you always have it in a moment of need? Read on to find out how to make compound butter, learn different recipe ideas you can try, and discover why you need to make a big batch of this buttery beauty ASAP.
What is compound butter?

Read more
Why you should be eating more acorn squash this fall
Acorn squash: Get to know this nutty little squash that's perfect for savory autumn dishes
Acorn squash cut.

There's no shortage of squash recipes this time of year, and for good reason. Not only are squash healthy, beautiful, and versatile ingredients that can be prepared any number of ways, but they also fill us with all the warm and fuzzy fall feelings. And who are we to deny ourselves that?

One of our favorite squashes this time of year is the acorn squash. Known for its beautiful buttery, mild sweetness and ability to take on flavors divinely, this cute little fruit is on the smaller side of fall squashes, and, as suggested by its name, resembles an acorn. Let's crack this guy open and see what we should be doing with this favorite fall ingredient.

Read more