Skip to main content

We Asked a Pro for His Tips on How to Make Sourdough Bread at Home

Baking bread is a daunting task if you’ve never done it before. But the only way to learn to make fluffy, crusty loaves is to practice and experience a little trial and error. This is especially the case with sourdough, which requires a starter, aka a fermented dough that contains wild yeast and bacteria. This is what’s used in place of active dry yeast to make sourdough bread rise, and it also gives the loaf its signature tangy flavor.

While you can follow a recipe for baking a sourdough loaf, it’s likely that your very first attempt isn’t going to be very successful. It takes time, patience, and practice, but some tips from the pros also don’t hurt. So we chatted with Jonathan Davis, the senior vice president of La Brea Bakery, to get some pointers on creating a starter, what type of flour to use, and how long to proof a sourdough loaf. Use these tips in conjunction with a solid sourdough bread recipe, and you’ll become a seasoned baker in no time.

Related Videos
La Brea Bakery Jonathan Davis Sourdough Bread
La Brea Bakery

The Manual: How should a novice baker go about sourcing or creating a starter?

Jonathan Davis: While some recipes are more complicated than others, the process of creating your own sourdough starter from scratch is somewhat simple. It’s always a good idea to use reference books, but if you’re a novice baker and uncomfortable with creating one from scratch, starters can always be purchased on the internet. If you’re looking to create a basic sourdough starter, most recipes will call for water, flour, and time. After combining the water and flour, bakers must wait several days (if not longer) to fully cultivate and feed their starter. At La Brea Bakery, we’ve always used Nancy Silverton’s original sourdough starter — made from water, flour, and organic grapes — that she cultivated more than 30 years ago.

TM: What type of flour would you suggest using to bake a sourdough loaf?

JD: High protein bread flour is usually recommended when baking a sourdough loaf. But today, because we have access to so many different grains, using a high protein bread flour isn’t required. With so many different available grains on the market, bakers can create different sourdough blends based on their own characteristics and personal preferences, which is something we’ve started experimenting with at La Brea Bakery during the last several years.

La Brea Bakery Sourdough Bread
La Brea Bakery

TM: Should you knead the dough during the first fermentation? How long should the dough be left to rise?

JD: Kneading during fermentation is totally dependent on the formulation being used. Some knead throughout the process to initiate the dough, but it’s a personal preference. When it comes to determining how long the dough should be left to rise, it’s important to examine the quantity. The bigger the quantity, the longer it will take to rise, ranging anywhere from six to 24 hours. The key to fermentation is to always examine the volume first. One trick to telling whether the dough is ready to be shaped is to poke it with your finger. If the indentation stays, the bread is ready to be shaped.

TM: After the first fermentation and shaping the dough, should it be proofed? For how long?

JD: The duration of proofing depends on the fermentation process with a wide range of options — six to 24 hours — depending on the desired outcome. La Brea Bakery is known for our sourdough loaf, but over the years, we’ve amassed several variations including our Sourdough Batard, Petite Country White Sourdough Round, Country White Sourdough Loaf, and La Brea Bakery Reserve Demi Sourdough Baguette. All of the breads that we make at our bakery take a total of six hours of proofing.

Editors' Recommendations

Bubbly? Full-bodied and red? Zesty and white? Your favorite wine types, explained
All the primary types of wine (and everything you need to know about them)
Glasses of different kinds of wine

Trying to understand everything about wine all at once is an impossible endeavor. Wine is a beautifully complicated, ever-changing quiddity, and even the most decorated and prestigious wine experts in the world often find themselves confounded by its constant little surprises.
That isn't to say that, if you care to, you shouldn't become educated on the subject of wine. It's a hobby and a passion that's tremendously fun to pursue, and there's much to learn on the matter.
If you find yourself in the beginning stages of your wine education, just as in everything, you'll want to start with the basics. It's possible that up until now, you haven't put much thought into the several different kinds of wine there are, except for, say, red and white. But while there are obviously exceptions within every hard and fast rule, for the most part, wine can be broken down into roughly nine categories. Here we'll take a minute to break those categories down, explain what they mean, which wines fall into them, and, our favorite - how to drink those wines.

Sparkling wine

Read more
This NYC restaurant’s $518, 19-course tasting menu of Chinese cuisine is amazing
Chef Guo in New York is a once-in-a-lifetime experience and a feast for the senses and the palate
Chef Guo food.

Butterfly Falls in Love with the Flower.

Step inside the restaurant Chef Guo, and the first thing you'll be greeted with is a majestic model of a ginko tree, the national tree of China, complete with brightly colored golden leaves. The tree cascades over the dining room, a space filled with Chinese calligraphy on the walls and regal Indonesian Zi Tan rosewood chairs. Soft and pleasant Chinese instrumental music plays in the background, an oasis in an otherwise hectic Midtown Manhattan.

Read more
How to reheat tamales: Learn the secret to every method
Enjoy tamales just as much the second time around
Our Place tamales.

Tamales are one of the tastiest and most popular dishes for a night out on the town, complete with a few frosty margaritas. A traditional Mesoamerican dish, tamales are stuffed with meats or beans and cheese and wrapped in a banana leaf or a corn husk. Steamed and served with pico de gallo and rice, they make for a delightful dish that's easy to make and packed with flavor and spice.

Tamales are easy to prepare and a great option to make ahead of time and reheat for a quick meal on the go. Whether homemade or store-bought, there are a few tips you'll want to know when reheating them so that you can savor all the goodness these little flavor pouches have to offer. Whether you want to use a steamer, microwave, stove, oven, or air fryer, here are the best ways to make sure you get the perfect hot tamale.

Read more