Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Food & Drink

Perfect your mashed potatoes this Thanksgiving with these 3 simple tips

How to make mashed potatoes everyone will love this Thanksgiving

Lindsay Parrill
By
Image used with permission by copyright holder

One could make the argument that mashed potatoes are the true star of Thanksgiving dinner. Sorry, turkey. It seems to be the one dish everyone must have present and everyone adores. We all have our favorite Thanksgiving sides, sure. Sweet potato casserole, cranberry sauce, cornbread stuffing- they’re all wonderful. But those are the dishes that have rankings, the dishes that people will argue over being great or not. Mashed potatoes are such a Thanksgiving staple that they’re never even part of the discussion. Their holy presence and deserved respect are just a given. Because it simply would not be Thanksgiving dinner without buttery, delicious, creamy mashed potatoes.

Perhaps you already have a flawless, beloved mashed potatoes recipe that’s been passed down for generations and Great Grandma Gertrude would roll over in her grave if you dared to try another version. This recipe probably isn’t for you.

Recommended Videos

But maybe you’re one of the many for whom your Thanksgiving mashed potatoes have always been a bit lackluster, somewhat bland, maybe even a little lumpy. To you, we say, there’s hope. Read on to learn how to make mashed potatoes so perfectly delicious that even Grandma Gertrude wouldn’t be able to resist a second helping.

Mashed Potatoes
Better Crocker

Mashed potatoes tips and tricks

  • For the creamiest and most flavorful mashed potatoes, use Yukon Gold. They whip up beautifully and have a natural butter flavor that’s perfect for mashing.
  • Be sure to cut them into even pieces before cooking to ensure consistent texture. Smaller pieces will reach fork-tender consistency far more quickly than larger ones. If you have a mixture of perfectly cooked, undercooked, and overcooked potatoes, that’s where lumps are born.
  • Mashing your potatoes with a good potato masher is the way to go. As tempting as it may be to use an electric mixer, these make it easy to over-mix, creating a gummy consistency to your potatoes. It’s best to do it by hand.

Mashed potatoes recipe

This is a wonderfully simple, perfectly flavored recipe for mashed potatoes, but feel free to mix it up by adding fresh herbs, sauteed onions, cheeses, or anything else that strikes your fancy. Otherwise, heap a big pile next to your turkey and enjoy the food coma that follows.

Ingredients:

  • 4 pounds Yukon Gold potatoes
  • 3-4 cloves garlic
  • 1/2 cup (1 stick) butter, melted
  • 1 cup heavy cream
  • Salt and pepper to taste

Method:

  1. Peel and quarter potatoes, then place in a pot of cold salted water.
  2. Peel garlic cloves and add them to the pot.
  3. Bring to a boil, then reduce heat and cook uncovered until fork-tender, about 15-20 minutes. Drain well.
  4. Melt butter either on the stove or in the microwave, then combine it with the cream.
  5. Mash potatoes with a potato masher, adding the cream/butter mixture gradually. Season with salt and pepper.
  6. Serve warm and enjoy!

Editors' Recommendations

Lindsay Parrill
Lindsay Parrill
Contributor
Lindsay is a graduate of California Culinary Academy, Le Cordon Bleu, San Francisco, from where she holds a degree in…
10 benefits of sweet potatoes that prove you should eat more of them
Sweet potatoes: This little vegetable is packed with delicious health benefits
Sliced raw sweet potato.

Sweet potatoes may just be one of nature's greatest gifts, as they are one of the sweetest vegetables, versatile, and easy to cook. They go well with a wide variety of ingredients, and they can essentially be enjoyed at any time of day. Whether you prefer them as fries, in a stew, in a pie, or in a different recipe, rest assured that you get to enjoy the many benefits of sweet potatoes.

Read on to learn why sweet potatoes are so good for you (and remember this list the next time you pass a pile of these starchy little gems at the store).

Read more
What are capers, anyway? Learn all about the briny ingredient that will transform your favorite dishes
Sure, they're delicious, but what exactly are they?
Capers

Every olive-obsessed, bring-on-the-brine fan of a flavorful vinegar punch loves a caper. These weird little briney beads are the perfect addition to anything that needs an added zip. Salads, sandwiches, sauces, pork, fish, and chicken all pair beautifully with these little green gems, and we can't seem to get enough.
While you may only know them as the star of your favorite chicken piccata recipe, capers are actually so much more than an absentminded garnish that only serves as an afterthought for the sake of tradition. They're actually delicious little flavor bombs, packing a real punch of power if you know how to use them.
Have you ever wondered, though, what exactly capers are? Are they seeds? Some strange sort of seaweed? Nuts that somehow lost their way? A strange gift from space that has gone unquestioned all these years?

What are capers?
Actually, capers are far less exciting than any of those theories, but that doesn't make them any less delicious. They're actually the green flower buds of a bush called capparis spinosa that grows wild across the Mediterranean and some parts of Asia. The buds are harvested and dried, then preserved in a salty brine that gives them that deliciously pickled and tart flavor we adore.
Though not as common as capers, you may sometimes see caperberries on the shelf next to the capers. These are simply the fruit of the caper plant when it has been left to bloom. Caperberries are much larger than capers, usually about the size of an olive, and make for an absolutely stunning cocktail garnish.

Read more
Elevate your pizza night: A mixology expert reveals how to choose the right cocktail pairings
Cocktail expert and author Jason Hedges gives us the scoop on mastering this amazing pairing.
wood-fire pizza on board

Mozzarella di bufala pizza at L'Amico. lamiconyc/Instagram

While wine and beer are generally seen as excellent pizza pairings, next time, try mixing some cocktails instead. Think herbal Negroni cocktails or the citrus brightness of a spritz — all delicious when sipped alongside savory pizza. In fact, according to Jason Hedges, author of The Seasonal Cocktail and Beverage Director of LT Hospitality, including restaurants like L'Amico and Skirt Steak, this wide range of flavors makes pizza and cocktails the perfect pairing.

Read more