Skip to main content

Our simple hot toddy recipe is an instant winter classic

What exactly is a hot toddy?

Dewar's Hot Toddy
Dewar's

In terms of warming and wintry cocktails, there’s no beating the appeal of the classic hot toddy. If you’ve never had one (and don’t have it as one of your winter go-to’s), this is likely because either the old-timey name turns you off or you simply just don’t know what a hot toddy is.

Why is a hot toddy? Historically used as a cure-all medicinal drink in Ireland, Scotland, and the southern US, this simple hot cocktail is made from whisk(e)y (usually Scotch or Irish whiskey, but any whiskey will do), honey, lemon, and hot water. Some drinkers add spices and herbs to make it more of a spiced whiskey tea, but we believe simplicity is the key when preparing a hot toddy.

History of the hot toddy

Its history, like many classic cocktails, is murky at best. The first recipe for a drink similar to the hot toddy was published in the late 1700s. It consisted of liquor, hot water, spices, and sugar (instead of honey and lemon). The word “toddy” comes from the taddy, a drink made of fermented palm sap that was imbibed in India in the 1600s when the British controlled the country.

As for the medicinal qualities, it’s more than simply people believing this drink was a cure-all for colds and flu symptoms; the drink was even prescribed by doctors in the past. On top of that, Dewar’s (the famous blended Scotch whisky brand) ran advertisements in the 1930s touting the hot toddy as a cure for the common cold. We’ll take a steaming hot toddy over traditional, foul-tasting cough medicine any day.

And while prescribing this drink to cure winter disorders might not be better than contemporary medicine, it does have medicinal value. The steam from the drink is good for opening up your sinuses. The vitamin C from the lemon can help you feel better quicker. If you have spices like ginger, you’ll help with your cough and aid in any inflammation. Honey is an antioxidant that will help soothe a sore throat.

Even if you don’t have a cold, you can still enjoy the warming, sweet, boozy flavor of a well-made hot toddy. In its most basic sense, if you want to know how to make a hot toddy, the drink consists of whiskey, honey, lemon, and hot water. Simple, perfect, but easily adaptable to fit your palate. You can also treat it like a spiced wine or cider and add a cinnamon stick, a lemon wheel, ginger, or other spices.

Ballantine's Hot Toddy
Ballantine's

Hot toddy recipe:

Ingredients:

2 ounces of blended Scotch whisky
3 teaspoons of honey
2 teaspoons of fresh lemon juice.
Hot water topper

Preparation:

Using a teapot on a pan, heat water until it’s hot. In a mug, add honey, lemon juice, and blended Scotch whisky (or whatever whiskey you prefer). Pour hot water to fill the rest of the mug. Stir to combine all the ingredients. Add more honey or more lemon juice after you taste it if you prefer. Also, add a cinnamon stick, lemon wheel, or if you want. Enjoy the warming, boozy, and potentially medicinal qualities of this classic drink.

Christopher Osburn
Christopher Osburn is a food and drinks writer located in the Finger Lakes Region of New York. He's been writing professional
Summer whiskey cocktails: These are our favorites
Summer weather was meant for whiskey cocktails
Whiskey cocktails

You might not immediately think of whiskey as a summery spirit, and we get that. When you imagine nuanced single-malt Scotch whisky or spicy, warming rye whiskey, you likely envision a cold (possibly snowy) evening. You probably also have thoughts of drinking it neat. What about using whiskey as a summertime mixer?

If you only reach for gin, vodka, tequila, and rum for your mixing needs during the warmer months, you’re missing out. That’s because myriad blended Scotch whiskies, single malts, rye whiskeys, bourbons, and various other types of whiskey are perfect for mixing. Don’t believe us? There are countless summer whiskey cocktails perfect for now until the leaves start falling (and beyond).
Our favorite summer whiskey cocktails

Read more
The best new non-alcoholic drinks for a happy hour without the hangover
NA drinks are better than ever
Wilderton Aperitivo and citrus.

Within the vast realm of drinks, the most evolved as of late is arguably the non-alcoholic category. While we've seen exciting new cocktail trends and useful new beer hop varieties, it's the NA world that's made the biggest strides in the last couple of years. That means we no longer have to shutter when seeing things like zero proof on labels, as the options now are better than ever.

Why the upswing? A perfect storm, really. Wellness trends continue while tech continues to evolve, making the creation of such drinks all the easier. The non-alcoholic drinks sector has proven itself to be a major player in the marketplace, and the producers have responded accordingly, giving these beverages the TLC they deserve.

Read more
Is international bar acclaim worth it? Some of the world’s best bars weigh in
The pros and cons of bar fame
Mirate bar staff.

There was a time after Double Chicken Please opened its brick-and-mortar spot in the Lower East Side where you could get in pretty easily. Since, in the wake of numerous accolades, including being named the best bar in North America in 2023, the establishment is routinely swamped. A line stretches from the bouncer at the door along velvet rope several blocks long.

Was it worth it? Is the experience the same after the fame? That all depends on the bar and what the drinker is after. Acclaim like this can change the very nature of a place, turning it from neighborhood hot spot to internationally-coveted destination. Suddenly, it's not so much about taking in a deftly-made cocktail in a unique setting as, well, saying you've been there.

Read more