Skip to main content

The Godfather cocktail is an underrated gem (and you only need 2 ingredients)

You only need two ingredients to make the Godfather

Whiskey
Kelly Visel / Unsplash

If you’re anything like us, when you think of whisk(e)y cocktails, your mind tends to head towards bourbon or rye whiskey-based drinks. This is because iconic cocktails like the Manhattan, old fashioned, and mint julep seem to get all the acclaim from cocktail enthusiasts. But if you’re not mixing with Scotch whisky, you’re missing out.

Not only is the penicillin one of the greatest contemporary cocktails, but you can also use single malt Scotch whisky and blended Scotch whisky as the base for any of your favorite whiskey-based cocktails to give them a Highland, Islay, or Speyside twist. And while you can mix up an elaborate, smoky whisky sour with a Lagavulin 16 or an Ardbeg 10-year-old base, you can also whip up a classic, boozy Godfather cocktail even easier.

What is the Godfather?

Whiskey
Timothy James / Unsplash

When it comes to flavorful, simple cocktails, it’s difficult to top the elegant, nuanced palate of a well-made Godfather cocktail. To make this drink, you don’t need an advanced degree in mixology (if that even exists). You also don’t need any bitters, shrubs, tinctures, herbs, or any other specialized ingredients. All you need are amaretto and Scotch whisky. That’s it. The drink typically calls for the two ingredients half and half.

A Hollywood history

Whiskey in glass
Andres Haro Dominguez / Unsplash

You might have guessed it already, but the Godfather does have its roots in Hollywood. While we don’t know who actually invented the drink, it was named after the iconic 1972 film The Godfather. Disaronno (the famous Italian amaretto brand) claims the drink was a favorite of actor Marlon Brando, who played the titular godfather Vito Corleone, but there’s no proof that this is actually true. The first appearance of the drink was in 1977 in Complete Bar Guide by Stanley M. Jones. Regardless of who and when it was created, it remains a warming, complex cocktail today.

What you’ll need to make the Godfather cocktail

Whiskey bottles
Adam Wilson/Unsplash

Ingredients:

  • 1.5 ounces Scotch whisky
  • 1.5 ounces amaretto

The Godfather recipe steps

Whiskey
S. Tsuchiya / Unsplash
  1. Add ice to a mixing glass.
  2. Add Scotch whisky and amaretto to the glass.
  3. Stir to combine.
  4. Add ice to a rocks or old fashioned glass.
  5. Strain the ingredients into the ice-filled glass.

Picking the right whisky

Whiskey
Claus Grünstäudl/Unsplash

While the classic recipe calls for Scotch whisky and amaretto, what you use as the whisk(e)y element is up to you. If you’re going traditional, you’ll pick a nice single malt Scotch whisky or a complex blended Scotch whisky. But if you really want to get wild with it, you’ll use a different whisk(e)y.

Bourbon adds even more sweetness to the already sweet, almond-flavored liqueur. Rye whiskey gives the drink a spicy, peppery kick. The whiskey you choose is really up to you. We suggest trying it the traditional way and then experimenting to see which version you prefer.

Editors' Recommendations

Christopher Osburn
Christopher Osburn is a food and drinks writer located in the Finger Lakes Region of New York. He's been writing professional
Why you need to try Michter’s new 10 year bourbon
You'll want to try this limit-release whiskey
Michter's 10 Year

The bourbon marketplace is saturated (pun intended) with outstanding, award-winning brands. And while you can’t go wrong with an expression from the likes of Four Roses, Old Forester, or even Eagle Rare, we always get excited to try limited-release expressions from Louisville’s Michter’s.

That’s why we were so stoked to see that the brand is once again releasing its 10-year-old Kentucky straight bourbon this April. For those unaware, this small-batch whiskey is sold in limited quantities and is highly coveted by bourbon aficionados.
Why is it so great?

Read more
How to make the Earthquake cocktail in just 4 simple steps
Make this simple cocktail to start and end your gatherings with a bang
Earthquake cocktail

According to legend, the Earthquake cocktail was a favorite of Post-Impressionist painter Henri de Toulouse-Lautrec, who served it at the frequent parties he hosted. Originally a 50/50 blend of cognac and good absinthe, the two-ingredient cocktail certainly had the potential to start and/or end the evening with a bang.

Over the years, drink makers have mellowed the recipe for those looking for less inebriating libations. Whether you stick to tradition or tinker with the ingredients, the Earthquake makes a brilliant cocktail to add to your repertoire. And who knows, it just might make you a better painter as well (although we doubt it).
The Earthquake cocktail

Read more
Here are the best cocktails to drink during the upcoming solar eclipse
Any one of these drinks will get you through the solar eclipse with joy
Pulp Friction

Every now and then, we all get a bit lonely. Our hands just feel empty without a drink, especially when there’s something as important as a once-in-a-lifetime total solar eclipse. Luckily, hardworking bartenders and ambassadors across the country have come to the rescue.

Whether you’re one of the 40 million who will be in the direct path of the totality of the upcoming total solar eclipse or not, you can still celebrate (and watch as NASA streams it live). Some of the best cocktails to drink during the solar eclipse are nods to the totality of the eclipse’s path, or as with many of the cocktails we're featuring, are just plain fun.

Read more