Skip to main content

This Fish Pie Recipe is Perfect for Cold Weather Dinners

As the weather turns from mild chill to polar vortex, you’re inevitably going to start spending more time inside and what better way to stay warm than by cooking (and standing in front of the oven)? Okay, bingeing food shows on Netflix under a blanket is a good idea, too, but it won’t fill you up.

When cooking during the colder months, we’re always on the lookout for hearty meals that stick to your bones and fill you up. One of those that does it for us every time is a nice meat pie. Whether chicken pot pie or shepherd’s pie, we’re big fans of pulling it out of the oven and digging in. One type of meat pie that’s often overlooked (at least here in the U.S.) that we think should be getting more credit, though, is a good, classic fish pie.

fish pie recipe
Alison Attenborough

It might not be the first type to come to mind, but after checking out this recipe, we’re going to be putting it in top consideration for favorite meat pies from now on.

This recipe comes to us from New York City-based food stylist Alison Attenborough, who uses pollock as her fish of choice.

Wild Alaska Pollack Fish Pie Recipe

fish pie recipe
Alison Attenborough


  • 4 (three-ounce) fillets Wild Alaska Pollock, cut into one-inch chunks
  • 3 leeks
  • 1 sheet frozen puff pastry, thawed
  • 2 c chicken stock
  • 1 c frozen peas
  • .5 c dry white wine or dry vermouth
  • .25 c butter
  • 2 tbsp flour


  1. Preheat oven to 425 degrees Fahrenheit. Slice the leeks in half lengthwise, and then slice into quarter-inch half-moons. Rinse the sliced leeks in cold water and drain to remove any silt. Melt two tablespoons of butter in a sauté pan, and cook the leeks over medium heat until they become soft and fragrant, about seven minutes. Add white wine and bring to boil to burn off the alcohol. Remove from heat, add the peas, and set aside.
  2. Melt the remaining two tablespoons of butter in a saucepan or skillet. Stir in the flour and cook for two to three minutes. Slowly whisk in the chicken stock, stirring constantly, until sauce thickens, about three minutes. Add the pea and leek mixture and Wild Alaska Pollock, and simmer for one minute.
  3. Spoon the mixture into a greased eight-inch casserole dish. Remove the pastry from freezer and gently unfold onto a floured work surface just enough to smooth out creases. The pastry may take a minute or two to soften. Roll the pastry gently so that it is large enough to fit over dish with some overhang. Drape the puff pastry sheet over the filling and crimp the edges under the side of the dish to create a seal. Cut two or more vents in the center of the crust.
  4. Set the casserole dish on a baking sheet and cook on center rack for 25 minutes, or until the pastry is golden brown. Enjoy!

Editors' Recommendations

Sam Slaughter
Sam Slaughter was the Food and Drink Editor for The Manual. Born and raised in New Jersey, he’s called the South home for…
Guy Fieri’s Breakfast Burrito Recipe Is the Comfort Food We Need
guy fieri breakfast burrito recipe family food cookbook

During these tough times, a little comfort food can go a long way. Whether it’s a bowl of popcorn with your favorite cheese dust or something else, remember to take care of yourself in that sense now perhaps more than ever. (If you need other ways to practice self-care, check out our guide.)

One of the areas we’ve been looking to in terms of being mindful about making comfort food is breakfast. Now that all-you-can-drink mimosa brunches are a thing of the past (remember how cool they were?), we’ve decided to direct our efforts toward making top-notch breakfasts at home. Enter the Mayor of Flavortown himself, Guy Fieri.

Read more
A Cannabis-Infused Lobster Mac and Cheese Recipe For 4/20
Kitchen Toke Cannabis Infused Lobster Mac and Cheese

It's a special day tomorrow for many in a certain amount of states around the country. 4/20, the day that celebrates cannabis culture. And even if you are already planning to smoke it, vape it, or taking it in in some way, may we suggest cooking it into a meal as well? Now, we're not talking cookies or brownies -- though those are amazing, too -- we're talking about a staple on tables across the country, macaroni and cheese.

Not only do you have two of the best food groups — carbs and cheese — but you can customize the dish to fit the rest of the meal. You can easily go from a multi-cheese mac to a barbecue chicken mac and cheese to almost literally anything else (as long as you have the ingredients you want). The sky is the limit with mac and cheese ... or in this case, the sea is the limit!

Read more
How to Make Spatchcock Chicken in One Easy and Delicious Recipe
spatchcock chicken recipe

For most people here in the States, it's been less than a week of quarantines and isolations. By now, you've probably gone to the store and stocked up on things. But what happens when you get there and they don't have the pre-cut chicken pieces and only the whole birds? Well, you make lemonade out of lemons (figuratively) and cook that bird up. Don't know how? We've got one word for you: spatchcocking.

The name -- and if you can say it without giggling then bravo for you -- dates back to the 18th century and was a shortened version of the phrase "dispatch the cock." (Get your laughs out now. We'll wait.) The first references to the phrase come to us, according to scholars, from Irish cookbooks. Now, when we talk about spatchcocking, we are talking about splitting the bird down the middle so that it lays flat in the roasting pan.

Read more