Skip to main content

Cognac vs Whiskey: The main differences between them

Whiskey in a crystal glass sitting on a rock in front of a fire.
Thomas Park/Unsplash

When you compare and contrast cognac and whiskey, there’s a fair bit to unpack. The Venn diagram of the two would have plenty of content in every area, from similarities (both classic spirits, both with a sense of regionality) to stark differences (base ingredients, where they are made). Here, we’ll keep things simple and give you a general breakdown of the two.

These are two heavyweight drinks that can be enjoyed neat or mixed up in a great cocktail. Either way, their distinctive characteristics can be seen, smelled, and tasted. And when you know a little more about each category, you’ll likely appreciate both cognac and whiskey a bit more, not to mention whip up better-resulting beverages.

Get your best sipping glasses together and set up a proper tasting, it’s time to examine the main differences between cognac vs. whiskey.

Differences in ingredients and production

Let’s start with the general makeup of the two spirits. Whiskey is made from grain, most often barley. Corn, rye, and other ingredients—and varying combinations thereof—can serve as the grain base as well. Think of whiskey as a cousin of beer: They both are the product of fermented grains. Cognac, on the other hand, uses wine as its base ingredient. So, in order to make Cognac, you must first grow, harvest, and ferment grapes into wine.

With whiskey, the production process starts with malting, which involves sprouting barley. Mashing comes next, which extracts the sugar. Then, the processes of fermentation and distillation, followed by aging. The end product is almost always aged in oak, where it can take on color, complexity, and intriguing flavors. Cognac begins at the winery, where one of three approved white grape varietals is fermented. It’s then distilled, aged, and often blended.

Pouring a glass of whiskey.

Cognac is regional, whiskey is global

One of the most unique traits belonging to Cognac is its stark regionality. Cognac refers to a region in France, in the Charente department set in the southwest of the country. Only here can the lauded brandy be made, in a specific manner that’s been practiced for hundreds of years. Meanwhile, whiskey can be made anywhere on earth, from the country of Japan to Canada and beyond.

Within the sprawling universe of whiskey, there are many subcategories or types of whiskey that are made a certain way, often in a certain place. Rye, bourbon, Irish whiskey, Japanese whisky, and Scotch whisky are a handful of the major sub-genres, although there are many more. Cognac; however, is a subcategory. It’s one of three major types of brandy, all set in Europe. It’s joined by Armagnac, also made in a specific enclave of France, and Lourinha of Portugal. You may encounter other wine-based spirits elsewhere in the world, such as the burgeoning scene in California, and these spirits will simply be called brandies (although, given some time, they may give the quality of Cognac a run for its money).

Ferrot XO Cognac Flaviar
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Tasting notes

Whole websites could be devoted to the flavor variations between Cognac and whiskey but we’ll keep things 101. Think back to how Cognac is more like wine and whiskey is more like beer. It’s a fair comparison not only in terms of how they’re made, but how the two taste. Cognac can offer a lot in the way of fruitiness. Sure, there are added components from barrel aging, but you’ll almost always detect some stone fruit (think plum), floral qualities, and some citrus and spice. Because it’s essentially a concentrated version of wine, there are tannins at play, too, which can offer structure and a subtle, grippy sensation on the palate.

Whiskey can share some of these tasting notes, especially the lighter bourbons and ryes of the world. Citrus and spice elements are especially common, but largely, whiskey shows less fruit and more in the way of toffee, malt, and vanilla. Given the grain base, you’re like to get some cereal-like flavors, along with hints of herbs, honey, or nuts. Because there are so many kinds of whiskey, the flavor spectrum is much broader. For example, you’re unlikely to encounter much smokiness in a Cognac. But with a whisky like Scotch, it’s practically guaranteed, given the ingredients and production techniques.

In the glass, they can look similar, but whiskey will often be a bit more amber or brown in color while Cognac can take on more reddish or yellowish tones.

Mark Stock
Mark Stock is a writer from Portland, Oregon. He fell into wine during the Recession and has been fixated on the stuff since…
The difference between an Old Fashioned and a Manhattan: These two classic cocktails, explained
The differences between the old fashioned and manhattan
Manhattan

It’s okay if you don’t know the intricate differences between classic whiskey-based cocktails. Unless you’re an avid home bartender or professional mixologist, no one will fault you for not knowing how to make a Sazerac, Boulevardier, Mint Julep, or any other whiskey-based drink. Also, don’t worry if you don’t know the differences between the two most well-known whiskey cocktails: the classic Old Fashioned and beloved Manhattan.

This is because these two drinks, on the surface, seem very similar. Both are made with whiskey and have some of the same ingredients, but they are surprisingly different in flavor and appearance.

Read more
The differences between bourbon and brandy, explained
Brandy and bourbon are quite different
Brandy

Like most aged spirits, brandy and bourbon look the same. If you’re a drinking novice and someone puts a glass of bourbon and a glass of brandy side by side, you might even have a little difficulty figuring out which is which. Both are golden to caramel in color depending on the age. The two spirits also carry some of the same aromas and flavors, like oak, caramel, and fruity flavors. That being said, the two spirits couldn’t be more different.

A very different base
Bourbon is often referred to as America’s “native spirit”. If you didn’t already know it, this is a reference to its history and cultural significance in the US. It’s also a reference to the rules of bourbon whiskey. That being that it must be made in the US (not just Kentucky). While there are various other rules and regulations, the other most important rule is that, to be called a bourbon, the whiskey must have a mash bill of at least 51% corn. So, it’s a corn-based spirit.

Read more
Beer 101: What’s the difference between an ale and a lager?
Both are great - but not the same thing
Beer

Even if you have only the most basic knowledge of beer, you probably know the simple ingredients that you need to have to brew it (even if you’ll never brew any yourself). They are grain (barley, corn, rice, etc.), yeast, hops, and water. If you enjoy drinking beer and like talking about it with any authority, it’s a good idea to have this kind of base information because beer gets more complicated after this.

There are countless styles and offshoots, including IPAs, stouts, sour ales, barleywines, and everything in between. Including well-known beer styles and their various offshoots, there are currently more than 100 defined types of beer. And while we could spend a dozen (or more) articles explaining all the styles (don’t tempt us), today, we’re most interested in sticking with the basics—specifically, the age-old questions of the differences between lagers and ales.

Read more