Skip to main content

The Manual may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site.

ButcherBox vs. Good Chop: Which meat delivery service is the better choice?

How to decide between these two popular meat boxes

Steak levels of doneness
alex9500 / Adobe stock

I love steak. In fact, I would eat it every day if I could. But I despise shopping for it. If you hate shopping for meat as much as I do, you might’ve considered a meat delivery box such as ButcherBox or Good Chop. Meat delivery boxes are a great way to avoid running around to 3 different grocery stores to find the exact cut or quality of meat you want.

Nowadays, there are plenty of places to order meat online, making identifying the best delivery service challenging. ButcherBox is well-known in the world of grass-fed, grass-finished beef, yet many know Good Chop for its 100% customizable boxes. But where should you start? Below, I compare ButcherBox vs Good Chop to help you determine which box is better for you.

Recommended Videos

Selection of meats

ButcherBox
Emily Caldwell / The Manual

Comparing ButcherBox vs Good Chop in terms of selection is a challenging task, as both brands have an excellent selection of beef, poultry, seafood, and more. Regardless of which size of Good Chop box you order, you can hand-select your cuts for every box. This means I don’t have to get tired of eating the same thing every week or end up with meats that are not my favorite. While there’s the most selection regarding cuts of steak, Good Chop offers a great variety of other categories, including organic ground chicken, bratwurst sausage, and fresh sea scallops. The selection of sides, such as mac & cheese or potatoes au gratin, makes it easy to make an entire meal out of the contents of your box.

ButcherBox’s selection leans more heavily on red meat, with over 20 cuts of 100% grass-fed, grass-finished beef. They certainly offer a more premium selection of specialty meats like brisket and bavette steaks. The selection of ButcherBox is better for the true carnivore who wants the best selection of fresh red meats, with the occasional pre-made options such as ButcherBox’s grass-fed meatballs. Additionally, ButcherBox offers premium varieties of seafood that Good Chop does not, such as fresh lobster.

Sourcing of meats

Good Chop Steaks
Emily Caldwell / The Manual

Both ButcherBox and Good Chop are transparent about sourcing their meats, which I appreciate. ButcherBox offers only meat from pasture-raised cows that are either 100% grass-fed or grass-fed and grain-finished. All beef is of exceptional quality, and cows are never confined to feed lots or given antibiotics or hormones. 100% grass-fed beef is sourced from cattle born, raised, and harvested in Australia; however, the brand’s pasture-raised, grain-finished beef is a product of the USA. All seafood from ButcherBox is harvested sustainably and responsibly farmed, too, with wild-caught options sourced from the USA or Canada and responsibly farmed options sourced from Norway.

Good Chop’s meat and seafood are exclusively from independent family farms and fisheries, focusing on supporting local economies and offering premium quality products. This is an attractive advantage for those who want to support American farmers and support compassionate animal welfare practices. The downside, however, is that most of Good Chop’s beef products are only grain-fed and not grass-fed. Grass-fed beef generally has a darker color when compared to grain-fed beef. As you make your selections, take notice of which cuts are grass-fed or grain-fed.

Price and value

Good Chop Box
Emily Caldwell / The Manual

Given the differences in availability of grass-fed, grass-finished options, it’s tough to compare the price and value of ButcherBox vs Good Chop. Of course, 100% grass-fed beef will cost more than conventionally raised, grain-fed beef — no matter where you buy it. Both sites run lots of promotions throughout the year, which include free add-ons to your box at no additional cost.

Overall, Good Chop is cheaper at face value, with a medium box (up to 14 lbs of meat) priced at $99. The classic-size Butcher Box (custom-curated) includes 8 to 11 pounds of meat and is priced at $146 per box. Again, this isn’t an apples-to-apples comparison, though, as ButcherBox offers a better selection of higher-quality meats. Good Chop could be a better choice if keeping costs more affordable is of interest. However, ButcherBox is a better choice for the health-conscious meat eater.

ButcherBox vs Good Chop: Final thoughts

Steak on a cutting board
Emrevonal / Pixabay

Overall, I thoroughly enjoy ButcherBox and Good Chop and have made excellent meals using meat from both boxes. Selecting the best meat subscription box for you depends on your preferences. I recommend considering what is most important to you when shopping for meat.

For the best selection of grass-fed, grass-finished meats, ButcherBox shines as a clear winner. In addition to meat quality and selection, I prefer ButcherBox’s reliable delivery system over the shipping via Good Chop. On the other hand, Good Chop may be a better option for cost-effective meals and planning for meals for families or groups. Additionally, Good Chop’s “USA-only” approach may appeal more to some buyers who want to support American farmers.

Another thing to note is that Good Chop is more than just a “meat box”; it offers other things to complete your meal, such as desserts like pecan pies and specialty butter like Roasted Garlic Herb Butter. I also like the customizable nature of Good Chop on all plans, whereas you must sign up for the most expensive ButcherBox to choose your specific cuts of meat.

All in all, it’s a close tie between ButcherBox vs Good Chop for me. Both boxes offer high-quality meat and convenience, two things I value. Both boxes are worth it, each with its advantages.

 

Emily Caldwell
Emily is an accomplished freelance journalist focusing on food, beverage, health, fitness, and travel content. She loves to…
Copperworks Distilling Co. launches Washington Peated Single Cask No. 497
Fans of peated Scotch will love this new release from Copperworks
Copperworks

Seattle's Copperworks got its name because it makes small batch whiskeys, gins, vodkas, and other sprits using traditional copper stills. Recently, this popular brand announced the launch of an exciting addition to the American single malt whiskey marketplace.
Copperworks Washington Peated American Single Malt Whiskey Single Cask No. 497

This limited-release, single barrel American single malt whiskey was made with 100% Fritz variety barley sourced from Washington's Skagit Valley. Like the famed single malt whiskies of Islay, the barley was smoked during the malting process using peat sourced from Washington State. It spent four years and three months maturing in a new American oak barrel referred to as "Single Cask No. 497".

Read more
Veritable Distillery is launching its first two spirits
Veritable Distillery is releasing a bourbon and a gin
Whiskey in a glass in a dark room

Connecticut-based Veritable Distillery is all about keeping things as authentic as possible. That's why it makes its spirits using only traditional methods and exclusively natural ingredients. Recently, the brand announced it was set to release its first two expressions: a gin and a bourbon whiskey.
Veritable Distillery's new expressions

The first two expressions from Veritable Distillery are Ship's Bell Bourbon and Southwick's American Gin.

Read more
Booker’s Bourbon launches the first batch of 2025, “Barry’s Batch”
Booker's newest release was made to pay tribute to former Beam Chairman and CEO
Whiskey in a glass by a fire

There are few small batch, limited-release bourbons as beloved as Booker's.  This highly sought-after bourbon is released four times per year with no batch the same as the one before. Recently, the Jim Beam brand announced its first batch of 2025. It's called "Barry's Batch," it was created to pay tribute to Barry Berish, former Beam Chairman and CEO and friend of Fred Noe, Beam Family 7th Generation Master Distiller.
Booker's "Barry Batch"

Barry Berish, the man the whiskey is named for, was a legendary figure at Jim Beam. He spent more than forty years working for the company. He passed away last year, and it seemed only fitting to release a bourbon in his memory.

Read more