Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Food & Drink
  3. Best Ofs

A Chef’s Tips for the Best Thanksgiving Stuffing and Gravy

Thanksgiving meal with turkey breast, pies and casseroles on a table.
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Thanksgiving meal with turkey breast, pies and casseroles on a table.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Thanksgiving is a fun but stressful time of the year. The entire meal can be a time-consuming and strenuous culinary event. To help streamline this Thanksgiving, chef Noah Zamler from The Press Room in Chicago is here with some insider chef secrets to making that perfect Thanksgiving feast. A culinary professional since the age of fifteen, Zamler’s food philosophy is all about seasonality and high-quality ingredients. With experience ranging from Metro-Detroit to Chicago and Rome, Zamler has cooked everything from pasta and sourdough bread to whole animal butchery and seasonal seafood.

A Chef’s Thanksgiving Tricks

Turkey being carved on a cutting board.
Claudio Schwarz / Unsplash

Chef Noah’s biggest advice for Thanksgiving is to prep before the big day. Thanksgiving should be a day of relaxation and spending time with family. To enjoy the holiday as much as possible, prep in advance as much as possible to avoid feeling stressed out on the actual holiday.

Brining the Turkey

Since a whole turkey is large with plenty of bones, rubbing salt on the outside isn’t enough to season the bird thoroughly. One way to achieve perfect seasoning is by brining the turkey. When properly executed, a brined turkey is juicy and seasoned to the bone. But how do you make sure the salt level is correct? And what about other flavorings?

“Make sure to brine your turkey 3 days before the big day with a simple 3, 2, 1 approach (3 gallons of water, 2 pounds of salt, and one pound of sugar) while adding your favorite spices,” said Zamler. For spices, Zamler likes to flavor his brine with clove, nutmeg, Calabrian chilis, and lemons. To achieve that bronzed, crispy skin from a brined turkey, Zamler recommends pulling the turkey out of the brine and letting it sit uncovered for one day before cooking. This will ensure perfect skin, every time.

Making Stuffing

While a lot of stuffing recipes are baked in a casserole dish separate from the turkey, there’s something uniquely delicious about stuffing when it’s done the old-fashioned way — cooked inside the turkey cavity. As the turkey roasts, the fat and juices will melt into the stuffing, giving it an extra boost of rich savoriness. A few tips Zamler recommends is to make sure to stuff the bird as full as possible, minimizing the air pockets to keep everything moist. He also recommends not adding eggs because they will likely overcook inside the turkey. While stuffing recipes can range from cornbread to rice, Zamler’s favorite is 60/40 whole wheat sourdough (60% stone-ground wheat and 40%  bread flour) with lots of herbs, such as rosemary, thyme, parsley, oregano, shallots, garlic and sherry vinegar. As a plus, the stuffing will also help season the inside of the turkey.

Cooking the Turkey

One key to cooking a succulent turkey is to make sure to roast your turkey on a resting rack so the juices don’t inundate the bottom of the turkey. Zamler advises a multi-temperature roasting process. Start off by roasting the turkey at 350 degrees Fahrenheit for 4 hours. Then, crank the temperature to 450 F for 30 minutes before turning on the broiler for an additional 5 minutes. This process will crisp up the skin while still guaranteeing juicy meat. Also, be sure to rest the turkey for at least 15 minutes after its been taken out of the oven.

Making the Gravy

Finally, the gravy, that wonderful sauce that should smother everything on a great Thanksgiving plate. The art of making a good gravy requires technique and experience. A few missteps and the gravy can easily be overly salty or watery. One key to great gravy is to separate the fat and liquid from the turkey drippings. Then, measure the fat and add half that amount in flour. Also, toast your flour in the fat for around 45 seconds (this gives the gravy an extra depth of flavor) before slowly adding in the liquid (constantly stirring the whole time).

Hunter Lu is a New York-based NYU graduate with a Master’s degree in food studies. As a features editor for both The Tasting Table and Chowhound, he explores the city for the best of the best in the restaurant world. His journalism has appeared in Foreign Policy Magazine with On the Front Lines of the China-Taiwan Food Fight, and and The War Horse An Army Interrogator, His Grandfather, and a Bond Across Two Wars. In 2022, Hunter was awarded the The 11th Hour Food, Farming and Environmental Journalism Fellowship from the UC Berkeley School of Journalism. As a published fiction writer, his stories has appeared in The Line Literary Review with Chicken Parm, The Bangalore Review with Hiring a Hitman in Chinese, and The Horror Tree with Seeing Hands. He is currently working on a novel.     Read Full Bio
Bowmore is bringing a new 20-year-old Islay single malt to the US
Whisky, Scotch, Bottle

Twenty years is a long time to wait for anything, let alone a whisky, but Bowmore is betting its newest release is one worth the delay.

The distillery, founded in 1779 in the town of Bowmore, is the oldest licensed distillery on Islay. It’s also the second-oldest in Scotland, and one of the few that still runs its own floor maltings, using peat smoke to dry the barley on-site.

Read more
Holladay Distillery is celebrating its 170th birthday with its oldest bourbon to date
Ben Holladay 10 Year Bourbon

Holladay Distillery was founded way back in 1865 in Weston, Missouri. To celebrate its 170th birthday, the historic brand is launching its oldest bourbon yet. This week, it’s kicking things off by releasing Ben Holladay 10 Year Bourbon.

Ben Holladay 10 Year Bourbon

Read more
Booker’s Bourbon is releasing a new, exciting release called The Southern Thunder Batch
Booker's Bourbon The "Southern Thunder" Batch

If you’re new to the American bourbon landscape, you may have never heard of Booker’s Bourbon. Well, I want to tell you about something amazing. Named for Jim Beam Master Distiller Emeritus Booker Noe, Booker’s Bourbon is an uncut, unfiltered, cask-strength (between 120-130 proof depending on the batch) bourbon that’s released multiple times per year. Recently, this iconic brand announced a new batch: The Southern Thunder Batch.

Booker’s Bourbon The “Southern Thunder” Batch

Read more