Skip to main content

The Best American Aged Rum

The Manual Spirit Awards recognize the best craft liquors distilled in the U.S. We blind-tasted bottles from around the country in eight categories — Bourbon, Single Malt Whiskey, Rye Whiskey, Gin, Vodka, Unaged Rum, Aged Rum, and Liqueur — to determine our champions. Each of the winners was judged on aroma, palate, and finish. Cheers to your next drink and to American craft spirits.

Best Aged Rum

Boston Harbor Distillery Lawley’s Small Batch Dark Rum

Dorchester, Massachusetts

The Manual Spirit Awards 2019 Best Aged Rum
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Aged rum is a distillate made from fermented sugar cane juice, sugar cane syrup, molasses, other sugarcane byproducts, or some combination thereof. The product is distilled at less than 190 proof and bottled at no less than 80 proof. The rum is then aged in a wide range of barrels — new or used, depending on the distillery — for varying periods of time.

Lawley’s Small Batch Dark Rum, the winner of the Aged Rum category in The Manual Spirit Awards 2019, is made from 100% distiller’s grade molasses before being aged in Putnam New England Rye barrels (another product from Boston Harbor Distillery). We enjoyed this rum for the balance of sweet, tropical flavors with the spice and oak dryness from the rye barrels. It makes for a great sipping spirit and a wonderful base for any number of cocktails, such as an Old Fashioned, where an aged rum can work as a substitution.

Lawley’s Small Batch Dark Rum is 40% alcohol by volume and available in Connecticut, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, New Hampshire, Vermont, and Maine.

About the Distillery

Boston Harbor Distillery’s founder’s name, Rhonda Kallman, might ring a bell if you’ve held even a passing fancy in the craft beer world at any time over the past few decades. Why is that? Oh, just a little brewery named Samuel Adams (OK, technically it’s Boston Beer Company, but still). Boston Harbor Distillery is Kallman’s current project and it’s housed in a historic building on the banks of Boston Harbor. In addition to Lawley’s Small Batch Dark Rum, Boston Harbor Distillery also makes Small Batch Rum (unaged rum), Coffee Liqueur, Maple Cream Liqueur, Putnam New England Whiskey, and the Spirit of Boston series, which are spirits distilled from Sam Adams beer.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Tasting Notes

Nose Tropical elements initially, with notes of cane sugar and pineapple overlaid by vanilla and caramel.
Palate A smooth body exudes vanilla, some oak, and caramel. The tropical notes from the nose translate to the palate, with light spice to balance it out.
Finish Dry oak and baking spice notes on a medium-long finish.

How to Enjoy It in a Cocktail

Is there any cocktail more emblematic of tropical relaxation than the piña colada? We think not. While there are varying stories of its origin (some say it was invented by a 19th-century pirate, others say its inventor was a bartender), people have been enjoying this (most likely) Puerto Rican delight for decades now. The vanilla and caramel flavors from the rum round out the tropical notes of the fruit juices. If it’s toasty outside, the piña colada can easily be made into a frozen drink.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Piña Colada

Glass: Collins

Tools: Shaker

  • 1.5 oz Lawley’s Small Batch Dark Rum
  • 3 oz pineapple juice
  • 1 oz coconut cream
  • Pineapple slice, for garnish
  • Cocktail cherry, for garnish

Method: Add ingredients to a shaker with ice. Shake well and pour into a Collins glass with ice. Garnish with a slice of pineapple and a cocktail cherry.

Best Aged Rum Runners-Up

Queen’s Share Rum

Allegheny Distilling Maggie’s Farm Rum – Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Image used with permission by copyright holder

This overproof reserve rum boasts a wonderful heat wrapped in caramel, oak, and more.

Ålander Aged Rum

Far North Spirits – Hallock, Minnesota

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Aged for up to one year in rye barrels, this rum is rich in toffee, caramel, and spice flavors.

Credits

Written by Sam Slaughter

Copy editing by Nicole Raney and Jeremy Abrams

Photography by  Riley Young and Dan Baker

Video by Riley Young

Art direction and page layout by Genevieve Poblano

Creative team: Will Hawkins and Chris Raymond

Editors' Recommendations

Sam Slaughter
Sam Slaughter was the Food and Drink Editor for The Manual. Born and raised in New Jersey, he’s called the South home for…
The Best Spirits for Spiked Hot Cocoa and Why
Hot chocolate served in vintage mugs with marshmallows

For the times when your hot cocoa needs some hooch and you don't want to make a full-blown cocktail: This one is for you. And you're in luck, as there are some great quick additions you can douse your mug of chocolate with for a tasty, grown-up adulteration of the cold-weather drink.

Related Guides

Read more
The 7 Best Dark Rum Cocktails to Drink in 2022
Zombie Tsunami Cocktail being lit.

Dark rum is much more than what you might throw into a Dark and Stormy or cook up some fried plantains with. It's a signature spirit that can turn just about anything it touches into a tropical treasure. This is especially the case in cocktails, where dark rum can add depth and tie together multiple ingredients seamlessly.

Billy Rockefeller is the bar manager at The Longboard in South Carolina. The seafood restaurant and craft watering hole has a special place in its heart for rum. He offered The Manual a few of the recipes on the list below, along with some bottles to have on hand at your home bar.

Read more
8 Best Rums for Making Piña Coladas Delicious
best dark rum cocktails rums for pina coladas 2021

A good Piña Colada depends heavily on the rum selected for the job. Choose the right one, and you can take the Puerto Rican classic cocktail to glorious new heights. Blending coconut, pineapple, and rum, the Piña Colada is about as tropical as mixed drinks come. And a good rum cocktail can transport you straight to a warm San Juan beach. The key is to find a rum that works in harmony with the decidedly distinctive and sunny flavors of the other two main ingredients.

Problem is, many bartenders keep their specific rum selections under lock and key. Further, some of the best Piña Colada recipes incorporate a plurality of rums from different regions (often the Caribbean and Hawaii). While we don't exactly expect you to craft something as perfect as what is engineered behind the bar at places like Tropicale, Lost Lake, or Polite Provisions, you can make a better Piña Colada. And a major first step in that process is grabbing the right rum.

Read more