Skip to main content

The Manual may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site.

Relying on gym equipment for weight loss data? Study says ‘fat burning zone’ recommendations may be totally wrong

It's probably best to have personalized weight loss metrics

Man running on a treadmill
Pexels / Pexels

No doubt, hitting the gym is a solid move if you’re looking to get fit and shed some pounds. But, according to a new study, relying on the gym’s equipment to reach your weight loss goals may not be the best approach.

Up until now, it was commonly believed that the “fat-burning zone” recommendations displayed on gym machines were a foolproof way to lose weight and keep it off. However, new evidence suggests that those recommendations may not work for everyone.

Recommended Videos

This article breaks down the study’s findings, defines the “fat-burning zone,” and gives you some tips on how to get the most out of your workouts with an individualized approach.

What is the fat-burning zone?

The fat-burning zone is a heart rate range where your body taps into its fat reserves for energy during exercise. It’s typically defined as 60–70% of your maximum heart rate, but this number can vary from person to person depending on factors such as age, weight, heart rate, and gender.

The problem with this is that not everyone’s body functions the same way when it comes to burning fat. Some people may burn more fat at lower intensities, while others may burn more at higher intensities. Stress, sleep deprivation, and genetics can also affect how your body metabolizes fat during exercise.

So, here’s the takeaway: If you’re serious about getting your fitness and weight loss on track, it’s time to personalize your approach. Consider teaming up with a healthcare professional to determine your maximal fat oxidation (MFO) rate, also known as your Fatmax score.

According to the study, the average difference between what the traditional fat-burning zone recommends and your actual Fatmax can be up to 23 heartbeats per minute. This means that if you were to follow the traditional fat-burning zone recommendations, you might not be burning as much fat as you could be (or thought that you were).

An Apple Watch SE being worn on someone's wrist with the apps displayed on its screen.
Apple

What’s the best way to burn fat and lose weight then?

A personalized Fatmax assessment from a healthcare professional is a great starting point, but there are also some general guidelines you can follow to boost your fat-burning efforts during your sweat sessions.

For example, you don’t need a doctor to tell you your heart rate or how hard you’re working out. There are tons of tools out there, like an Apple Watch or any other wellness tracker, that can do that for you. Makers of these accessories also keep adding new and better features for fitness enthusiasts of all kinds, like Apple’s recent watchOS 10 updates for cyclists.

By tracking your heart rate during exercise, you can get a sense of your fat-burning zone. And once you have an idea of where your Fatmax range lies, you can tailor your workouts accordingly.

Here are some other things to keep in mind:

  • Listen to your body. If you’re in pain, stop. Pushing through it can lead to injury and set you back.
  • Take rest days. Start slow, work your way up, and don’t forget to rest and recover.
  • Stay hydrated. Drink plenty of water, Gatorade, or whatever keeps you hydrated during workouts.
  • Do something you enjoy. Find a form of exercise that you actually enjoy doing. If you don’t genuinely like it, you’ll have a harder time sticking to it.

The bottom line is that everyone is different, and what works for one person may not work for another. It’s important to listen to your body, be patient and persistent, and don’t give up.

Tabitha Britt
Tabitha Britt is a freelance writer, editor, SEO & content strategist.
5 effective fat-burning workouts to help you lose weight
Guide to your weight loss journey
Man doing fat-burning workout

Burning fat and gaining muscle is a common goal among men, and knowing which are the best workouts to lose weight can speed the process up. Dropping weight can lead to you both looking and feeling better, in addition to reducing your risk for various diseases that sometimes accompany excessive body fat.
When paired with a nutritious, calorie-controlled diet, exercise is a highly effective way to lose weight and burn fat. A workout burns calories and can also impact your metabolic rate. However, when it comes to fat-burning workouts and weight loss, not all forms of exercise are created equal. Certain workouts and exercises will help you torch calories and shift your metabolism into a fat-burning mode more than others, so if you have big weight loss goals, keep reading for a list of the best fat-burning exercises and workouts.

How does exercise burn fat?
Before delving into the specific exercises and weight loss workouts that burn fat, it’s helpful to address what is meant by "fat burning." When most people say they want to lose weight, they mean they want to lose body fat. "Weight" refers to lean mass as well, which includes muscle, bone, organs, etc., so fat-burning workouts are designed to help you lose body fat.
Exercise can help you lose body fat in several ways, as described below.

Read more
Noom, WW, MyFitnessPal: Do you really need a weight loss app?
Or will exercise and counting calories a day work just as well?
Man smiling to the camera with woman working out behind him

In a world where every bite and movement can be measured, weight loss apps hold an allure that cannot be denied. You’ve seen the ads, the testimonials, and the unbelievable before and after photos. But as you swipe through another set of dazzling transformations, a question lingers in the back of your mind: do you really need a weight loss tracker to reach your goals? This isn’t just about shedding pounds; it’s a quest for a leaner, more vital, healthier you—and the path you choose matters. 

Let’s dive into the digital age of fitness and nutrition to see if these high-tech aids can help you lose weight or if they are just another fad promising more than they deliver.

Read more
Is the key to weight loss a great mindfulness routine? Here’s what doctors and therapists say
Mindfulness and weight loss: What experts say
Man doing yoga on deck

Weight loss made headline after headline in 2023 with the rise in popularity in GLP-1s like Wegovy. The drugs certainly have evidence to show effectiveness for losing weight in ways diet and exercise alone have not worked for some patients. Experts share maintaining a healthy weight (or getting to one) is essential.
“Weight maintenance/loss is important for overall health because it reduces the risk of insulin resistance and diabetes,” said   Dr. Jared Braunstein, D.O., a board-certified internist with Medical Offices of Manhattan and contributor to Labfinder.com. “Also, obesity has been linked to heart disease and strokes.”
Though diet, exercise, and medication can help, what about mindfulness? Stress reduction is another oft-recommended part of a weight loss program; mindfulness can reduce stress. Can being more mindful, therefore, help you lose weight? Experts weighed in.

Is there a link between stress and weight?
Doctors and mental health professionals believe there is.
“I am a firm believer that our mental health and physical health run parallel with one another,” Adrine Davtyan, LCSW, said. “When our mental health is compromised, it impacts our physical health. Conversely, when our physical health suffers, our mental health may experience distress.”
Experts delved deeper into why increased stress may lead to fluctuations in weight.

Read more