Skip to main content

Can a human overtake a horse in a long-distance race? Here’s the theory.

The Man Vs. Horse Marathon has continued since the 1980's — Have there been any winners?

white and brown horses running together outside fast
Kubrarkan / Pexels

Horses can sprint fast with their powerful leg muscles. Picture a wild horse galloping through an open field with the wind in their mane. You might wonder, can a human overtake a horse? The answer is yes. A paleoanthropologist has a theory to explain the evolutionary adaptations that allow humans to build endurance and run long distances without stopping. 

Man Vs. Horse Marathon

man horse riding horse running fast
Mathias Reding Man / Unsplash

The race began following a debate over a few pints in a British pub in 1980. The first person to overtake a horse on foot and win the race was Welsh marathoner Huw Lobb, who took the title in 2004. The course is a little shorter than a traditional marathon at 22 miles over rougher terrain, and Huw Lobb completed the race in 2 hours, 5 minutes, and 19 seconds, leaving the riders on horseback behind him. He won the prize fund of £25,000. Three years later, German participant Florian Holginger crossed the finish line 11 minutes before the first horse. John Parkinson from the UK was just one minute behind him. Those who had bet on the horses were surprised and less enthused by these human victories.

Recommended Videos

More recently, Nicole Teeny won a 50-mile ultramarathon race against horses. After her epilepsy diagnosis, she became determined to race a horse. Her incredible success is detailed in ESPN’s ‘Girl V. Horse’ podcast series. 

The theory

man running outside grey clouds on road
Jenny Hill / Unsplash

Harvard paleoanthropologist Daniel Lieberman and biologist Dennis Bramble joined forces and proposed that certain evolutionary adaptations allow humans to run long distances and even outrun horses. These adaptations include long legs, short toes, big, strong Achilles tendons, upright posture, and specific muscle fibers that are more advantageous for sustained running. Humans can cool down through sweating, whereas horses are more likely to overheat and slow down or stop. Humans also have cardiovascular systems that can efficiently deliver oxygen to the muscles and larger gluteus maximus muscles to ensure stability on two legs, unlike chimps for example with much smaller glutes.

Daniel Lieberman proposed that we developed these traits in part because our hominid ancestors would hunt and chase prey until the animal became too fatigued. Others aren’t so sure and believe it’s more likely humans developed to walk longer distances rather than running. They point out some of the potential risks and problems associated with ultramarathon and marathon running. 

Humans are built for long-distance running

man running on mountain outside
Alessio Soggetti / Unsplash

Research reveals the many benefits of running. Humans dissipate heat through sweating and have spring-like tendons and long legs that help us in sustained runs. Running causes your brain to release endocannabinoids and opioids, which are feel-good chemicals that contribute to the runner’s ‘high.’ This could be one of the factors that motivated our hominid ancestors to push on to secure food. Endurance training over time allows you to increase the maximum rate at which your body can use oxygen. You’ll also grow the number of mitochondria, which are the powerhouses of your cells.

While a human can’t outrun a horse in a short sprint, those with impressive stamina and athletic prowess can outlast horses in long-distance races.

Topics
Steph Green
Steph Green is a content writer specializing in healthcare, wellness, and nutrition. With over ten years of experience, she…
Can exercise help with insomnia? Which exercise is best? Researchers explore
Lifting those weights might just help you drift off to dreamland.
Tired man insomnia head in hands

According to the CDC, in 2020, 14.5% of adults had difficulty falling asleep most days or every day for the previous 30 days. Some of us just flop on the bed, and others have ways of trying to get ready for bed and lull ourselves to sleep. Insomnia is a sleep disorder involving trouble falling asleep, staying asleep, or both. People with long-term or short-term insomnia are more tired during the day and might also have difficulty concentrating.  

In a brand new study, researchers explored whether different types of exercise can improve sleep quality and help with insomnia in older populations. Let’s delve into the latest research.

Read more
The truth about daily weigh-ins and why they can hinder your weight loss
The scale isn't the only way to measure progress
Weight loss scale black and white doctor office weighing scale

When you’re trying to lose weight, weighing yourself regularly can be stressful. Daily weigh-ins show major up-and-down movements that leave you confused, and you have three different Excel spreadsheets to average your progress over time. We’ve all been there. But what are you supposed to do?

As a trainer and nutritionist, I stress to my clients that there are other ways besides a scale to track their weight loss progress. In fact, I believe some of them are much better than weighing yourself, and others help fill out a fuller picture. Here’s everything you need to know about different ways to track your progress — and how to avoid obsessing too much over any of them.
What are the downsides to only weighing yourself?

Read more
Can you trust the data your fitness tracker is giving you? An expert weighs in
Here are the answers to your questions about fitness tracker data
Man wearing EMS (electrical muscle stimulation) suit while working out

When it comes to fitness trackers, few people have more expertise than Tim Rosa. As the former CMO of Fitbit, he researched the reliability of the data they provide constantly, both individually and in larger studies.
Given his expertise, Rosa felt like the right person to approach to learn more about the reliability of fitness tracker data. He’s also deeply involved in sleep research in his current role as CEO of Somnee, so we asked him a wide range of questions about fitness tracker reliability, how sleep-related wearables are becoming part of the information equation, and the evolving role of AI in this technology. The following is everything that Rosa shared with us.

The lowdown on fitness trackers

Read more