Skip to main content

Why are eggs so expensive? What pasture raised eggs, cage-free eggs, and organic eggs mean

All the egg marketing terms, explained

Eggs in a carton
LightField Studios / Shutterstock

Marketing terms can be tricky to understand, but understanding marketing terms in the egg section at the grocery store is a whole new level of confusion. Claims made on packages such as “cage-free” and “organic” can confuse many of us. Aren’t all eggs just eggs? As much as we’d like the answer to be yes, several differences exist in the eggs in your grocery store. Beyond the considerable range of prices for eggs, each of the classifications of eggs holds a different meaning.

Shopping for eggs, however, doesn’t have to be confusing forever. Once you understand what each term means, you’ll find it easier to choose the best eggs in any grocery store you frequent. If you’ve ever wondered why one carton of eggs is more than double the price of the one sitting beside it, here’s why.

Eggs in a bakset
Cara Beth Buie / Unsplash

Egg classifications

Cage-free, organic, pasture-raised, and free-range are three of the most commonly seen labels on egg packaging. Eggs can also be classified as more than one of these, so don’t be surprised if you see combinations of terms, such as organic and pasture-raised eggs. You may have seen these terms before but haven’t thought much about them, but once you’re aware — it’s easier to make smarter choices when selecting your egg carton.

Cage-free eggs

The term cage-free means that the hens are not confined to cages. USDA’s cage-free standards detail that hens cannot be held in battery cages, but this doesn’t necessarily mean they are allowed to roam freely. Even eggs that are labeled “cage-free” may still mean that the animals were left in dark spaces or poor conditions that are not optimal. Beware of this term on egg cartons, which doesn’t always hold much meaning.

Many farms producing cage-free eggs are raising thousands of chickens at once, which means very few actually make it outside. In some cases, chickens might only have access to concrete and have no grassy areas to roam.

Free-range eggs

Free-range is not the same thing as cage-free. Unlike the term cage-free, free-range hens have access to the outdoors and have more flexibility to roam around. Free-range also automatically means cage-free, so a product should not say both. Since free-range is not regulated (unless it has a USDA organic designation, too), what free-range truly means can vary quite a bit from brand to brand.

Organic eggs

Organic eggs will have a USDA Certified Organic circle symbol on them. Any farm producing USDA Organic Eggs must adhere to strict regulations and undergo regular inspection. The USDA Organic label tells you as a shopper that the chickens have been fed an organic grain feed that does not contain fertilizers or pesticides. The feed that is given to chickens when producing conventional eggs often contains GMO corn, soy, or other harmful pesticides. For eggs to be USDA-Certified Organic, they must also be free to roam around and have access to the outdoors.

Pasture-raised eggs

Chickens who produce pasture-raised eggs are free to roam around on the pasture and eat grass, worms, and other insects. This is the ideal environment for these animals. Many pasture-raised egg cartons may also say “certified humane raised and handled.” This is a separate certification that farms can get, requiring them to adhere to standards such as using no antibiotics and allowing chickens to behave naturally and roam freely. Ideally, if your budget allows, pasture-raised eggs are the best option. Feeding chickens GMO grain feed is far less expensive than raising pasture-raised chickens, hence the major price difference between these two egg cartons.

Other tricky marketing labels with little meaning

You might also notice some other labels on egg cartons that are not true classifications. These terms are used as part of marketing tactics to trick buyers into thinking eggs are of higher quality than they actually are. For example, the terms “all-natural” or “farm-fresh” have no legal meaning.

farm fresh brown eggs
Jakub Kapusnak / Unsplash

Health benefits of pasture-raised, organic eggs

Not only are pasture-raised eggs the most humane choice, but pasture-raised eggs also contain more nutrients. Studies have found that the yolk of pasture-raised eggs has a much lower omega-6 to omega-3 fatty acid ratio than conventional eggs. Consuming more Omega-3 fatty acids and less Omega-6 fatty acids is important for fighting inflammation and warding against chronic disease. Pasture-raise eggs also contain more Vitamin A, Vitamin E, and carotenoid content than traditional eggs.

In some cases, you can even tell the difference between a conventional egg and a pasture-raised egg by examining the yolk. The yolk of a pasture-raised egg will have a deeper yellow color, whereas conventional eggs have a paler yellow color. This is due to the carotenoids these animals get from grazing on grass. Cool, right?

Boiled eggs on toast.
Foodie Factor / Pexels

Finding high-quality eggs at affordable prices

Eggs are expensive, especially if you wish to purchase high-quality, organic, and pasture-raised varieties. Shopping at your local farmer’s market or straight from local farms is a great way to get quality eggs at discount prices. Many discount grocery chains such as Aldi and Lidl also offer organic, pasture-raised eggs at prices less than those of larger grocery stores. Investing in your health with quality eggs is worth the price!

Editors' Recommendations

Emily Caldwell
Emily is a full time freelance writer with a special focus on health, fitness, lifestyle, food, and nutrition topics. She…
The 5 best pork cuts, ranked: Here’s what you should be cooking
Which one is your favorite?
Pork in butcher counter

Bacon, ribs, ham, sausage, chops. For all of the incredible gifts pork provides, it's still one of the most under-appreciated meats on the market, and that just doesn't make sense. Not only is this gorgeous meat delicious, but in a world where grocery store prices are still absurdly high, and most proteins cost far more than they did just a few short years ago, trusty pork seems to be holding steadfast in its mission to make both our wallets and our mouths happy.

The gifts from the other white meat are hearty and diverse, ranging from tender and delicate, elegant bites to hearty, rich, and saucy barbecue fare and everything in between. But with all of the options behind the butcher counter, how do you know which pork cuts are best? How do you know which cut to choose when it comes to impressing your guests at this weekend's dinner party? Or which to select for the best pulled pork sandwiches that your kids will devour with glee?

Read more
What is the healthiest fruit? 5 items you should be eating daily
Fruit Salad

Consuming a variety of fruits can contribute to a healthy gut microbiome and reduce the risk of chronic diseases. But do you know which are the healthiest fruits for you? Let's look at how many and what type of fruits you should be eating for optimal health. 

What is the healthiest fruit?
The healthiest fruit is not a single fruit but rather a variety of fruits that offer a range of nutritional benefits. According to the American Heart Association, adults are recommended to consume 4-5 servings of fruits and vegetables per day.

Read more
Bacon and eggs? Bobby Flay serves this meat instead (and we have thoughts)
There's nothing better than bacon. Or is there?
Big breakfast with bacon, bagels and scrambled eggs on the table overhead

Love him or hate him, Bobby Flay is one of the biggest celebrity chefs in the world, and he's probably taught us all a thing or two about cooking. I remember being in culinary school and the instructor asking a fellow student why he'd chosen to enroll. My eager classmate had a two-word reply, "Bobby Flay." Admittedly, his response warranted a few eye-rolls around the room, but the guy was passionate about cooking because of Flay, and there's something wonderful in that. And according to Facebook, that old classmate of mine is now an executive chef at a fantastic San Francisco restaurant. So, thanks, Bobby.

If you can get over the haughtiness, Bobby Flay is a tremendously talented chef, in part due to his ability to give ordinary dishes a special touch. He has a gift for adding unexpected ingredients that transform a dish completely or giving a new spin to a cooking technique that turns out to be a total game-changer. According to a recent TikTok video, the Iron Chef's desire to be different translates to his breakfast table as well. While bacon and eggs are the quintessential American breakfast pairing, Flay prefers an alternative to bacon - pan-fried prosciutto. Yum.

Read more