Skip to main content

The Manual may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site.

Cocktail History: Bogart’s Bitters is a Recreation of a 150-Year-Old Recipe

If you’ve ever made a cocktail, you’ve probably used bitters before. Maybe you added a few dashes of the old standby, Angostura bitters, or perhaps you’re a bit more experimental. Maybe you used Thai bitters or maybe you made your own from leftover Everclear and those Chia pets your mom got you when you finally left her basement. Regardless, bitters were used.

But did you ever think about what the some of the first bitters (ever called for in a cocktail book) tasted like? Now you’ll have a chance.

Recommended Videos

Introducing Bogart’s Bitters by The Bitter Truth, a recreation of the bitters called for in the first-ever cocktail book: The Bar-Tender’s Guide: How to mix Drinks, or The Bon-Vivant’s Companion, written Jerry Thomas in 1862. At the time, the brand of bitters that was sold was known as “Boker’s bitters,” but historians believe that Thomas spelled the name wrong, thus it became Bogart’s bitters. In honor of Thomas, The Bitter Truth decided to name their recreation as he had spelled it.

bogarts bitters
Image used with permission by copyright holder

This product is as close to historically accurate as possible. According to Jamie Boudreau of Canon: Whiskey and Bitters Emporium in Seattle, “The formula has been analyzed and interpreted, and [any potential changes] in flavor profile due to age were subtracted and the liquid formulated in the way it authentically resembles Jerry Thomas’ favorite bitters of more than a century ago.”

This wasn’t the first bitters ever, though. At the time, there were many different types of bitters for sale (much as there is today), though in the late 1800s, they were all considered medicinal. With the creation of the FDA in 1906, though, it wasn’t long until many brands were forced to close. Because the FDA forced brands to take the word “medicinal” off their labels, when Prohibition hit, a large number of brands went down quicker than a free shot of whiskey, Boker’s included.

Some bottles remained, though, and the people behind The Bitter Truth were able to find one. The team then worked to recreate not only what was inside (the original recipe was long lost), but also to craft a bottle to resemble the one that Boker’s was originally sold in. (Fun fact: The style of bottle is known as a “lady leg.”)

Ten years in the making, Bogart’s bitters has chocolate and coffee notes mixed with dark spices. Released in limited quantities, a 375-mL bottle retails for around $35.

Sam Slaughter
Sam Slaughter was the Food and Drink Editor for The Manual. Born and raised in New Jersey, he’s called the South home for…
Tired of sweet drinks? Get on the savory cocktail train with these gin recipes
Savory flavors take center stage in these unusual recipes
Hendrick's scales with Teatime Martini Glasses

We're all in on the trend of savory cocktails for spring, embracing the use of vegetables, herbs, and spices for the upcoming season. And as a big fan of both savory drinks and gin, I'm all in favor of using a savory-led gin like Hendrick's, with its cucumber flavors, to create these vegetal delights.
Pepper Snapper

Created by Liz Pearce, Hendrick’s Central U.S. Ambassador

Read more
Red vs. green: Choose year team with these tequila cocktails
Show your team some love with these color-themed cocktails
Green Avocado Blitz

If you go all out for Super Bowl day and love to decorate your place in support of your team then you'll want to check out these tequila drinks, which come in team-supporting colors for the game today.

These cocktails from Tequila Cazadores use the brand's blanco variety which is perfect for mixing, and they come in two fun colors: red or green, so you can show your support for your chosen team. The green option for you Eagles fans uses avocado plus other traditional Mexican flavors like cilantro, jalapeño, and lime for a refreshing, savory-noted drink. And the red option for the Chiefs fans uses pomegranate for color and flavor, along with grapefruit and elderflower liqueur for a fruity, floral drink.

Read more
6 Marsala wine cocktail recipes that prove it’s not just for chicken
With good Marsala wine, you can make some quality cocktails
Florio Marsala barrels

Marsala wine is often considered a cooking ingredient — who doesn't love chicken Marsala? — but this rich, fortified wine from Sicily deserves a spot in your cocktail glass, too. Like port or Madeira, it is considered a dessert wine. But you can make Marsala wine cocktails, even if they aren't commonly seen in the U.S.

"We like to mix with Marsala. It is a wine that gives a drink elegance, mouthfeel, and sweetness -- and some spiciness," said bartender Marco Fabbiano in Lecce, Puglia (translated from German). In Sicily, where the wine originates, bartenders embrace Marsala both neat and in cocktails. According to Fabbiano, locals enjoy its depth whether sipped straight or shaken into something creative in their bar, the Laurus Cocktail Experience.

Read more