Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Food & Drink

I learned the secrets of the Mai Tai at Hawaii’s most iconic beachfront bar

You can try three variations of a classic Mai Tai

By
Mai Tai Bar
Emily Caldwell / The Manual

The Mai Tai is one of the most popular Tiki drinks in the world, known for its sweet and slightly almond-flavored flavor. Until I visited the Royal Hawaiian, I had no idea just how much history lies behind this fruity cocktail. Initially created by “Trade Vic” Bergeron in 1944, the Mai Tai drink later made its way to Hawaii in 1953.

When Bergeron was hired to develop menus for the Royal Hawaiian, he introduced the classic Mai Tai recipe to Hawaii’s most iconic beachfront bar, now known as the Mai Tai Bar. During my visit to the Royal Hawaiian, I stopped by the Mai Tai Bar for a special look at how the bartending team makes three of the most popular Mai Tai variations available on their menu today. You can’t go wrong with any of these three drinks — whether you prefer something more subdued or something fruity and sweet.

Recommended Videos

Royal Hawaiian Mai Tai

Mai Tai Bar
Emily Caldwell / The Manual

The most popular drink at the Mai Tai bar is the Royal Hawaiian Mai Tai, a drink that bartenders make every day from opening to close. Made with fresh pineapple and orange juice, oregat, Bacardi light rum, and Whaler’s dark rum, I don’t think there’s ever a bad time to enjoy this drink. Though this is surprisingly my least favorite of the three Mai Tai’s I tried, it’s still delicious. If you close your eyes, you can taste that slight bit of almond flavor from the oregat.

Related: 
Upgrade your daily routine with the best smartwatches for men

The classic Mai Tai is a great option for those who enjoy a drink with a sweeter taste. If you’ve tried Mai Tais at other bars, the Royal Hawaiian Mai Tai is most similar to what you’d expect. Our bartender also informed us that Royal Hawaiian participates in many fundraising challenges with this variation — simply because they sell so many. For example, $1 from each Mai Tai sold is often donated to a local charity.

Ingredients

  • 1oz Old Lahaina Light Rum
  • 1oz Old Lahaina Dark Rum
  • ½oz Orange Curacao
  • ½oz Orgeat
  • 2oz Pineapple Juice
  • 1oz Orange Juice

Method

  1. Roll the shaker
  2. Pour in a large “bucket” glass.
  3. Float with Whaler’s Dark Rum
  4. Garnish with a parasol with cherry, pineapple and lime wedge.
  5. Close your eyes, take a sip and enjoy!

Vic’s 44

Vic's 44 Mai Tai
Emily Caldwell / The Manual

Next, I learned how to make the “Vic’s 44” Mai Tai, a drink that is closest to the original 1944 mai tai recipe invented by Trader Vic. Made with Pyrat xo reserve rum, myer’s Jamacian dark rum, ferrand dry curacao, orgeat, and freshly squeezed lime juice, this drink has a stronger rum taste and is not quite as sweet as the Royal Hawaiian Mai Tai. Since it’s not as sweet, this drink goes down so smoothly and so easily — almost too easy. If you prefer a more citrus-forward cocktail, you’ll likely appreciate this variation of the original Mai Tai over the sweeter Royal Hawaiian Mai Tai.

Ingredients

  • Fresh lime
  • 1/2 oz Ferrands Dry Curacao
  • 1/2 oz Orgeat (almond syrup)
  • Splash of water
  • 1 oz Meyers dark rum
  • 1 oz Pyrat Rum
  • Roll in tins

Method

  1. In a shaker, combine all ingredients.
  2. Roll the mixture between two tins at least three or four times.
  3. Squeeze fresh lime into the glass, then pour the mixture in.
  4. Garnish, if desired.

White Wash

White Wash Mai Tai
Emily Caldwell / The Manual

The last of the three variations of the Mai Tai I tried, the White Wash, was my personal favorite. Looking at the description, I already knew this one would be a winner when I saw “signature coco-loco foam” listed. When you order a White Wash here, it’s made with Bacardi light rum, ferrand dry curacao, orgeat, fresh lime and pineapple juices, topped with a float of Whaler’s dark rum and our signature coco-loco foam. The coconut foam on top makes this drink truly exceptional. You can also order this drink while dining at Azure (which shares a space with Mai Tai bar in the evening).

Ingredients

  • 1 oz white rum 
  • 1/2 oz lime juice             
  • 1/2 oz orange curacao 
  • 1/2 oz orgeat (almond syrup)    
  • 2 oz pineapple juice      
  • Roll in tins          
  • Float 1 oz dark rum        
  • Top with Coco Banana Foam   

Method

  1. In a shaker, combine white rum, lime juice, orange curacao, oregat, and pineapple juice.
  2. Roll the mixture between two tins at least three or four times.
  3. Strain and serve. Add dark rum floater on top.
  4. Add a layer of Coco Banana Foam on top.
  5. Garnish, if desired.
Emily Caldwell
Emily Caldwell
Contributor
Emily is a freelance journalist with a focus on food, travel, health, and fitness content. She loves to travel to new…

Editors’ Recommendations

What’s most surprising about Starbucks’ new secret Iced Lavender Oatmilk Latte
How (and why you should) order this variation
Starbucks Iced Lavender Oatmilk Latte

If you follow Starbucks on social media, you might've caught the brand's post yesterday about how to order a new (secret) variation of the traditional Iced Lavender Oatmilk Latte. I'll admit, I've never tried lavender coffee, nor did I have a deep urge to do so until I saw the Instagram post. I'm unsure if the bright purple for springtime or the curiosity around lavender coffee intrigued me to order this. Regardless, I'm glad I tried this drink because it doesn't taste anything like I thought it would. From the looks of this drink, I expected it to be super sweet and overpowering. Yet, after one sip, it's safe to say I'm hooked on the taste of lavender in coffee. The drink is light, smooth, and sweet enough without tasting like a whole dessert.

The Instagram post starts by ordering a Grande Iced Lavender Oatmilk Latte. When ordered right off the menu, this drink is crafted with Starbucks blonde espresso roast, creamy oatmilk, ice, and infused with sweet and subtle floral notes of lavender. Despite heading to Starbucks several times over the last month, I'm ashamed to admit I've never tried this springtime favorite beverage.

Read more
I tried the new ChefsTemp ProTemp Plus meat thermometer and here’s what I learned
How to up your meat-cooking game
ChefsTemp Pro Temp 2

Digital meat thermometers were first invested in the 1990s, which marked a significant shift for home cooks seeking quick and accurate temperature readings while cooking. Recently, however, a new wave of meat thermometer technology has arrived: the wireless smart meat thermometer. As someone who cooks meats at home nearly every night of the week, I love cooking my meal to the perfect temperature and avoiding the guessing game of "Is it cooked enough?" I tried the new ChefsTemp Pro Temp Plus 2 meat thermometer, and here's what I learned.
Design

I've tried several other meat thermometers before trying the ChefsTemp Pro Temp Plus 2, including many of the top brands on the market. Immediately, I was impressed with the probe-holder device and the large display on the device. The charging device comes with a magnetic backing, which makes it easy to put right on the front of your fridge. Throughout the cooking process, you can view the current temperature of your food either from the device itself or through the mobile app for remote temperature monitoring. In contrast, other brands of wireless meat thermometers I've used only display the temperature on the mobile app.

Read more
Shake up your St. Patrick’s Day with a Jameson mai tai twist
A tiki drink given the Irish treatment
Mai tai

St. Patrick's Day is on the horizon, so look out for the green beer and NCAA Tournament brackets. We love the traditions based around this springtime holiday, but — like a good cocktail — we also like to shake things up. This year, try something new with an Irish twist on a tiki classic.

Naturally, we reached out to some quality mixologists for inspiration. And not just any cocktail crafters. We chatted with Three Dots and a Dash, one of the very best American bars. The Chicago institution makes some of the best tiki drinks you'll likely ever taste.

Read more