Skip to main content

How to make the New York Sour, a leveled up whiskey sour

Elevate your usual Whiskey Sour

New York Sour
iStock

We love a good whiskey sour. This reasonably simple cocktail consists of whiskey, simple syrup, and freshly squeezed lemon juice. Some bartenders and home mixologists add a garnish of a cocktail cherry and a lemon wedge and some even add an egg white into the mix. Regardless of how it’s made and what ingredients and garnishes you use, it’s a tart, sweet, boozy cocktail perfect for all seasons. While the drink is perfect as it is, there’s one variation that we enjoy almost (if not more) than the original. We’re talking about the iconic New York Sour.

The original whiskey sour has been ingrained in the fabric of the cocktail landscape since the mid-1800s. While there’s a bit of mystery about its true origins, the first time the drink appeared in print was in Jerry Thomas’ ‘Bartender’s Guide’ in 1862. Since then, there have been a few alternatives to the classic recipe including The Libertine, Baltimore Bang, and the New York Sour.

Recommended Videos

The New York Sour

Whiskey barrels
Josh Collesano/Unsplash

Created in the 1880s as an offshoot of the Whiskey Sour, the drink was originally referred to as the Continental Sour. Legend says that even though it’s now referred to as the New York Sour, it was actually created in Chicago. This simple take on the whiskey sour keeps all the flavors you’re used to while changing things up and adding an extra flavor dimension with a float of dry red wine.

What does it taste like?

New York Sour
Brent Hofacker / Shutterstock

While the classic whiskey sour is known for its mix of citric tart flavor, sugary sweetness, and sweet corn booziness, the New York Sour adds one more dimension to bring everything together nicely. All of those other flavors are elevated by the tannic, dry, ripe fruit flavor of the red wine topper. You’ll find different flavors and expressions with each sip you take.

What you’ll need to make a New York Sour

  • 2 ounces of bourbon whiskey
  • 1 ounce of fresh lemon juice
  • .5 ounces simple syrup
  • .5 ounces dry red wine

The New York Sour recipe steps

1. Put ice in a shaker.
2. Add the bourbon, fresh lemon juice, and simple syrup into the shaker.
3. Shake vigorously to combine.
4. String it into an ice-filled Old Fashioned or rocks glass.
5. Top with dry red wine poured over the back of a bar spoon so that it floats on top.
6. Add a lemon peel for garnish.

Bottom line

New York Sour
iStock

The best thing about the New York Sour is that it elevates the original cocktail without requiring you to purchase a handful of new ingredients while learning new techniques and procedures. To make it, you simply mix up the cocktail the way you always do and add the topper of dry red wine at the very end. It’s a whole new cocktail with one simple step.

Christopher Osburn
Christopher Osburn is a food and drinks writer located in the Finger Lakes Region of New York. He's been writing professional
Topics
Mississippi’s Cathead Distillery is launching a new 100% wheat whiskey
Cathead's new whiskey features a 100% wheat mash bill
Cathead Distillery

If you don't know about Cathead Distillery, it's the first legal distillery in Mississippi since statewide prohibition in 1907. Founded in 2010 in downtown Jackson, it's well-known for its award-winning, small-batch spirits, including Bristow Gin, Cathead Vodka, and the popular Old Soul Whiskey. Recently, the brand announced the launch of an exciting new whiskey expression: a straight wheat whiskey.
Old Soul Estate Collection Straight Wheat Whiskey

It's called Old Soul Estate Collection Straight Wheat Whiskey, and it's made with a mash bill of 100% wheat. This grain-to-glass whiskey features wheat grown in Mississippi. On top of that, the distillation, aging, and even bottling was all done in the southern state. This limited-release small batch whiskey isn't just an exceptional expression. It's the first of this type of whiskey to be distributed to other states.

Read more
NBA legend Dominique Wilkins is teaming up with Old Fourth Distillery to launch a whiskey
Dominique Wilkins is partnering with an Atlanta-based distillery to launch his own bourbon
Old Fourth

If you're a younger NBA fan, you might not know how amazing it was to watch Dominique Wilkins play in the 80s and 90s. He was referred to as "The Human Highlight Film" and was named to nine all-star teams during his career.

He was well-known for his gravity-defying dunks. Now, he'll be known for a limited edition whiskey. The NBA legend is partnering with Atlanta's Old Fourth Distillery to launch a whiskey aptly named Nique's Batch.
Old Fourth Nique's Batch

Read more
Frey Ranch Distillery is celebrating a decade of distilling with a new limited-edition whiskey
Frey Ranch is launching a whiskey made with all five grains grown on-site
Frey Ranch

If you don’t know about Frey Ranch Distillery, now is a good time to get on the bandwagon. The Nevada-based farm-to-glass distillery is celebrating ten years of award-winning distillation and five generations of farming by launching a new limited-edition whiskey.
Frey Ranch Harvester Series: 10th Anniversary Edition

It’s called Harvester Series: 10th Anniversary Edition, and it’s already won numerous awards, including a Gold Medal at the 2025 San Francisco World Spirits Competition. The whiskey is made with all five grains grown on-site at the farm: non-GMO dent corn, winter wheat, winter rye, barley, and oats. This American whiskey is a blend of the team’s favorite single barrels, featuring more than 100 barrels and fourteen different mash bills.

Read more