Skip to main content

The Manual may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site.

Museum finds wines from the 1700s hidden behind Prohibition-era wall

Old wines are treasures. The latest finding involves 18th Century Madeira, hiding in New Jersey

Image used with permission by copyright holder

There have been some great wine discoveries over they years, often involving bottles hundreds of years old. We’ve seen everything from vintage Champagne in sunken ships to wine jars buried in the pyramids with the great King Tut. The most recent tale involves very, very old Portuguese wine.

Some 50 bottles of Madeira were found during a demolition exercise in New Jersey, the oldest dating back to 1769. It happened after workers smashed through a Prohibition-era wall at Liberty Hall Museum. The oldest bottle of the found bunch is older than the United States.

Recommended Videos

The bottles are in good shape, considering, and it’s been reported that some may fetch $20,000 a piece at auction. Being a fortified wine, Madeira is known to age very well, especially when stored properly. There’s a good chance that many of these bottles are still in good drinking shape.

Many fortified wines were made for that very purpose: to age well. In the early days, they needed to stand up to long journeys by boat to get to their destination. It’s likely that this particular find would drink a bit like fine sherry, complex and oxidized.

Why the hidden stash? This was common practice for collectors around the Prohibition era as it was a means to protect their illicit bottles. Apparently, the museum staff had no idea there was such a collection and would not have found it if not for the most recent renovation project.

It makes you wonder how many more collections like this have yet to be unearthed. There are old homes all over—on the east coast especially—where incredible bottles may be lurking beyond plain sight. The latest New Jersey find (not to be confused with the bizarre pasta discovery in the same state) certainly will not be the last.

Like the best Scotch or rare, one-off lots of bourbon, these bottles of Madeira are extremely valuable. What’s more, they seem to be in good health, with proper seals and not much in the way of damage. That means the liquid inside, while in some cases 254 years old, might be in its prime.

Let’s break down what drinking something this old really means. The year 1769 predates even the electric telegraph. Hot air balloons had not even been invented yet, nor flush toilets. Soda water was only in its infancy, invented two years earlier. The Revolutionary War was still six years out.

To sip something from then would be to time travel way, way back. We won’t get to because we don’t have the cash to buy those bottles, but we’ll be looking at the walls of old buildings a bit differently from now on. There could be liquid treasure in them there walls.

Mark Stock
Mark Stock is a writer from Portland, Oregon. He fell into wine during the Recession and has been fixated on the stuff since…
How To Pair Wine With Beef, From a Steakhouse Expert
The dining room of Tuscany Steakhouse in NYC.

The dining room at Tuscany Steakhouse in New York City. Image used with permission by copyright holder

Whether cooking a special dinner at home or enjoying an indulgent meal at a restaurant, nothing says celebration like steak and red wine. Rich and full-bodied, this food and drink combination is truly one of the best pairings in the culinary world. It's also a complicated topic, one which encompasses many options and flavor profiles. To guide our readers through this intricate culinary space, The Manual has sought out a steakhouse professional. Besides being experts on all things beef, most high-end steakhouses also employ wine masters, with most establishments featuring an in-house sommelier whose sole job is to explain the restaurant’s wine list for customers; making wine pairing suggestions based on each customer's preferences.

Read more
Looking for a perfect sear on your steak? This surprising pantry item is the secret
The secret is already in your pantry
Grilled juicy marinated angus beef flank steak on wooden board. Finished juicy medium rare meat is resting before it is cut and sliced.

We already know that there are countless ways to cook a great steak. Whether you prefer the grill, a good old-fashioned cast-iron pan, or your beloved broiler, if you know what you're doing, you'll end up with a delicious meal. But if you've ever felt like your steak could use a bit more in the way of a perfectly crisp, deeply golden, ultra-crispy crust, the answer is probably already sitting in your pantry right now: cornstarch.

Why it works

Read more
How this 100-year-old syrup brand continues to revolutionize the coffee industry
The story behind your favorite coffee syrups
Torani syrup bottles

Recognized for its colorful, nostalgic glass bottles found in thousands of cafes around the world, global flavor company Torani has a rich history that dates back 100 years. Maintaining its reputation in the beverage industry means staying ahead of changing coffee trends and developing new flavors to meet consumer needs. For a look inside the history behind this 100-year-old syrup brand, I chatted with Andrea Ramirez, Consumer and Customer Insights Manager at Torani. Ramirez is directly involved in brand development and product innovation for the brand.
As Torani’s seasoned flavor expert and trend guru, she leads her team in tracking trends from various spaces, from grocery store shelves to fine dining menus, and everywhere in between. Here's what she shared about how the brand has revolutionized the flavored syrup industry over the last century.
Torani's innovative approach

As a brand, Torani has remained relevant for 100 years and counting by staying deeply attuned to consumer behavior and evolving taste preferences. "We leverage a mix of proprietary insights and industry data to identify emerging trends and shifts in how people enjoy beverages. One of the clearest patterns we've seen over time is the growing desire for personalization — consumers increasingly want the freedom to craft drinks that suit their tastes."

Read more