Skip to main content

5 Easy Ways To Elevate Your Pasta Sauce

Image used with permission by copyright holder

You can always improve your pasta sauce. It may never reach the heights of Grandma’s, but you can get really close. And with a few extra things in your pantry at the ready, elevating your sauce is shockingly simple. Here, we set you up with some simple ways to elevate your pasta sauce. Generally, we’re thinking red sauce, typically tomato sauce, but many of these thoughts translate to lighter sauces as well.

Related Guides

Add Some Brine

I cannot believe there was a time when I didn’t add at least a handful of capers or some diced-up olives to my pasta sauce. In hindsight, it feels criminal. The addition of brininess brings balance to the sauce, taking the sting out of the acid with some salty goodness. Be mindful of other salty ingredients, however. If, for example, you’re already planning to use some heavily seasoned sausage in your sauce, dial down your briny additions accordingly. You can always taste as you go to find that ideal balance. You can always extend that briny addition by including some of the juice from the caper or olive jar as well. And don’t stop there; clams and a bit of clam juice can make for a surprisingly good addition as well.

Go Fresh

fresh vine ripe tomatoes.
Photo by Tom Hermans / Unsplash

Store-bought spaghetti sauce is filled with additives and preservatives. With freshness, it’s about more than just the basil you may top your dish with during plating (although that is highly recommended). It starts from the ground up. Opt for fresh pasta if you can. Making it at home is an ordeal, this we know, but try some of the homemade stuff in the refrigerated section of your grocer. Better, hit up the local Italian specialty store. And don’t stop there in terms of freshness. When possible, use fresh tomatoes (can some sauce next summer and fall, if you didn’t this year), vegetables, and other produce.

The pre-diced additions you can get at the store—the garlic, the onion, the Parmesan—are wildly convenient. But they don’t taste as good. Set aside a few extra minutes beforehand and cut those things up yourself just before adding them to the pan. And while we’re talking about cheese, it’s advised to have a wedge of Parmigiano-Reggiano or Pecorino-Romano in your fridge at all times. You’ll want it to snack on and throw into salads as well as shred up fresh for pasta-topping.

Related Reading: How to Make Spaghetti Sauce

Try Better Oils

bottles of Italian olive oil sitting on the shelf.
Photo by Claudio Schwarz on Unsplash

Good oil is vital. It may seem secondary as there are so many other ingredients in the mix, but it sets a solid foundation atop which the rest of the pasta can be flavorfully made. You don’t need to buy the most expensive oil directly from a mill in Umbria. But experiment with some higher-shelf brands at the store and conduct a little taste test at home with a loaf of crusty bread. The same idea applies to balsamic, an oil you should be adding—at least in moderate doses—to your sauce (red sauces especially). It deepens the overall flavor and offers a touch of welcome sweetness.

Nail Your Pasta Ingredients

Knolling style of italian pasta.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Pay attention to your ingredients. Any onion will do, but a mix of Cipollini onions and shallots tastes better than your standard-issue red variety. A general Italian seasoning is fine, but you can fine-tune your own. Play around with different ratios of basil, tarragon, thyme, and rosemary. Instead of just using black pepper, add a touch of zing with some lemon pepper. Give your sauce some extra life with the addition of fresh Italian parsley, especially late on. Using a can of sauce? Fine, but give it some added life and texture by throwing in a dozen cherry tomatoes.

If you’re using meat, be thoughtful. Not any sausage or cut will do. The former should be available pre-seasoned at the meat counter of your local store (in other words, don’t throw in breakfast sausage just because it’s in the fridge, it’s too sweet). If you want a meat substitute, the plant-based options work great. That, or try some vegetables with some chewiness, like eggplant or mushrooms.

Let it Simmer

This one is a stereotype for a reason. Generally, the longer you let the flavors marry, the better. Once things are cooked, let the sauce simmer, at least for 30 minutes but for several hours if you have the time. Just remember to stir occasionally and monitor the consistency, as you may need to feed it some liquid (brine, wine, oil, etc.). Doing this basically turns the volume up on your sauce, concentrating flavors and making the whole thing sing, far louder than most store-bought sauces. If you’re hosting, start your sauce early, before company arrives, and let it do its thing while you catch up over cocktails.

Editors' Recommendations

Mark Stock
Mark Stock is a writer from Portland, Oregon. He fell into wine during the Recession and has been fixated on the stuff since…
You should know how to make these 5 sauces
Mastering these sauces will make you look like a pro in the kitchen
il principe lasagna bolognese recipe bechamel sauce over getty images

A good sauce is a core component of culinary culture. Knowing how to make a handful of them can elevate your kitchen game to unforeseen heights. Often, a good sauce is the star of the show. After all, what would Thanksgiving turkey be without gravy? Or Eggs Benedict without hollandaise?

Now, we don't expect you to pull a Béarnaise sauce out of your hat at a moment's notice. But you should be able to whip up a solid tomato-based sauce for pasta, or a good teriyaki sauce for rice and veggies or skewered proteins. We know, there are great pre-made options out there, from complex fish sauce to throw-it-on-anything Japanese Barbecue Sauce. Yet, you know as well as we do that when you pull it off from scratch, it's more rewarding and can even taste better.

Read more
The 5 best Indian butter chicken recipes we’ve tasted
Master an Indian cuisine favorite with these chef-curated butter chicken recipes
Indian butter chicken in a black pan with a spiral of cream being added.

Creamy and savory, Indian butter chicken is a must-order for any fan of Indian cuisine. An extremely popular dish at most Indian restaurants in America, this combination of tender chicken and rich sauce is equally delicious with basmati rice or Indian naan. While butter chicken can be time-consuming to make, the results are deliciously fulfilling and perfect for leftovers.

To help us navigate this classic dish, The Manual has collected five amazing recipes from various chefs and Indian cuisine professionals, including Maneet Chauhan, a Food Network star, and restaurateur Gaurav Anand. With the expert guidance of these chefs, butter chicken can be a great addition to anyone's dinner repertoire.

Read more
The best spiced rum cocktails to spice up your palate this fall
It's time to rethink spiced rum: The complex spirit is great in a number of fall-ready cocktails
Lava Roasted Manhattan cocktail.

Goodbye summer, hello fall. AKA, farewell pilsners, Sauvignon Blanc, and Margaritas, what's up Scotch, Cabernet Sauvignon, and spiced rum cocktails.

That's right, it's time to transition to darker, heftier sippers to get us through the offseason. For rum drinkers, that means something aged longer and often hit with a complimentary batch of spices. You see, spiced rum can be a beautiful, complex, soothing drink, when it with just the right ratio of additives. Like a great gin, it can take on (or be infused with) a number of great aroma and flavor-building ingredients.

Read more