Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Food & Drink

How to make the ultimate Halloween cocktail, according to Death & Co.

We got some expert advice on making the perfect Halloween cocktail for 2022

Mark Stock
By

Halloween is here, so break out the ghost costumes and spiderwebs. And while you’re at it, fix up a drink that matches the spooky aura of the season. But not just any drink will do, as Halloween calls for something equal parts chilling, festive, and a little over the top—much like the holiday itself.

Enter the Zombie, a tiki classic (no, not that kind of zombie). This rum-based drink was born in 1934, in the tender post-Prohibition years. Cocktail guru Donn Beach is credited for having invented the drink, which gained a big following at the 1939 World’s Fair in New York. Like so many classic drinks, there’s great folklore involved. Apparently, the drink was whipped up to cure the hangover of a local businessman who needed to get through a meeting. He returned later saying the drink had turned him into a zombie.

The Death & Co. Zombie cocktail, served flaming.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

It’s not an impossible story, given the high-octane nature of the cocktail. It’s deceptive, with tropical goodness masking a decidedly alcoholic beverage. Many tiki bars place a cap on how many Zombies you can order in one sitting because they have a tendency to turn patrons into, well, the walking dead. Because they are so high-proof, they’re often served aflame, a great trick to add to your Halloween festivities.

Related

It’s one thing to throw some dry ice in a drink or dye it red to make it look like blood. It’s quite another to make a cocktail that you and your friends won’t soon forget. So, we reached out to our friends at Death & Co. for insights on the ultimate Halloween drink. And they delivered.

Recommended Videos

Javelle Taft is the head bartender at Death Co.’s NYC outpost. He loves sherry, getting a good bike ride in, and is known for making some seriously good cocktails. “The backbone of a Zombie is built on the rum split,” he says. “Traditionally it’s made with a white or un-aged rum from Puerto Rico or Cuba, Jamaican rum, and Guyanese demerara-style rum. Each rum plays a significant part in the quality of the cocktail, so choose wisely. The remaining ingredients—Don’s Mix, Falernum, Grenadine, lime juice, and bitters—that work in harmony don’t waiver much.”

So about that rum. “For white rum I like Probitas,” he says. “It’s a blend of rums from two powerhouse Caribbean rum operators, Foursquare in Barbados and Hampden Estate in Jamaica. That’s the x-factor for me. Lemon Hart 151 demerara-style rum is my pick for its savory, full-body characteristic and Smith & Cross Jamaican rum for its ripe banana and cocoa notes.”

As mentioned, there are many ways to Zombie, so play around and dress it up however you like (although we strongly suggest the recipe below). “The Zombie cocktail has been riffed on many times before,” Taft says. “So the main takeaway here: have fun with it!”

Death & Co. Zombie Punch

There are many versions of the Zombie but this one is hard to beat. It’s all about a lovely balance of rums, candied fruit flavors, and the refreshing nuttiness only Falernum can provide. The drink can be scaled up easily, whether you need a spare for your partner or a big punch batch for the whole group. And you can always tone it down a bit by halving the rum ratios, or even diluting the whole thing with a bit of soda water or extra ice.

Ingredients

  • 1 ounce Plantation OFTD
  • 1 ounce Cana Brava
  • 1 ounce Smith and Cross
  • 1 ounce Don’s Mix (cinnamon syrup and grapefruit juice)
  • 3/4 ounce lime juice
  • 1/2 ounce Falernum
  • 1/4 ounce Grenadine
  • 2 dashes Absinthe
  • 1 dash Angostura bitters

Method

  1. Combine all ingredients except Absinthe and Angostura bitters with ice and shake vigorously.
  2. Stain into a glass, preferably a skull.
  3. Garnish with mint, orchid, or pineapple and light it up if you feel like some flames.

Editors' Recommendations

Mark Stock
Mark Stock
Contributor
Mark Stock is a writer from Portland, Oregon. He fell into wine during the Recession and has been fixated on the stuff since…
The 6 best non-alcoholic drinks to order at a bar, according to the pros
Want an NA drink a bit more complex than bitters and soda? Try on of these bartender-endorsed options
A pair of mocktails.

The non-alcoholic drink spectrum has become broader than ever. In the last few years, we've seen an influx of zero-proof beers, wines, and spirits, and the quality keeps improving across the board. That means now's a great time to order a non-alcoholic drink while out on the town, whether you're sober curious, or simply the designated driver for the night.

As we tend to do when seeking quality info, we reached out to some of our favorite bartenders and drinks pros for some wisdom on the topic. They offered a slew of mocktails and other NA options that can be ordered and enjoyed at just about any bar out there. These are drinks that often resemble signature drinks or classic cocktail recipes, just no alcohol. And, when made right, they rival most of the best drinks out there -- period.

Read more
The 6 best Marsala wine cocktail recipes to make
With good Marsala wine, you can make some quality cocktails
Florio Marsala barrels.

Marsala is a fortified wine from Italy that we in the U.S. pretty much use only for cooking. But the Sicilian liquid can be great as both a sipper and a cocktail base. After all, the Portuguese love a good port and tonic, and the Spanish mix with sherry all the time. Why should we treat Marsala any differently?

The answer, of course, is that we shouldn't. Marsala is a dynamic animal, sometimes rich and hearty, other times lighter and more savory. It's practically as old as time in its native land -- conveniently called Marsala (located in western Sicily in southern Italy). But it wasn't until English importers caught wind of the stuff in the 18th century that Marsala wine was significantly exported. It remains a lesser-known fortified wine, less popular here than, say, port, vermouth, or even sherry, but it should really carry more appeal.

Read more
10 floral gin options to help make what’s left of summer truly epic
The best floral gin options for late-summer drinks
A glass of gin

Summer is almost over—emphasis on almost. There are still a few weeks to enjoy everything the season has to offer (and depending on the temperature where you live, perhaps even more than that). For us, this means drinking a lot of gin and gin-based cocktails. And, while there are different types of gins and seemingly endless herbs and botanicals added, when we drink gin, we prefer it to be fresh, floral, and flavorful.

When you taste a gin, in most cases, the first flavor you'll notice is that of juniper berries. Gin is most known for its piney, spicy aroma and flavor. But any good gin has myriad other aromas and flavors backing juniper up. We're talking about angelica root, orris, coriander, and many other fruits, herbs, and flowers. The latter is what we're interested in today.

Read more