Skip to main content

6 Coffee Liqueurs and Spirits to Drink Right Now

hot coffee cocktail
Clay Banks

When it comes to coffee liqueur nowadays, the options available go far beyond that old classic, Kahlua. Bartenders in particular have come around to the joys of using coffee liqueur and other coffee spirits in cocktails, adding a bit of caffeine and some roasted chocolate notes to drinks like an Old Fashioned, Manhattan, and many others. Here are six coffee spirits to try now, from classic infused liqueurs to a bourbon that is cut with cold brew.

Mr. Black Single Origin Cold Brew Coffee Liquor

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Mr. Black’s original Cold Crew Coffee Liquor became a hit here in the U.S. when it first came out a few years ago. The Australian brand uses a cold extraction slow-drip method, with no other added flavors, to produce this sweet coffee liqueur. Well-known bars like Dante and The NoMad have fallen in love with it as well. The latest expression is this single-origin version of the original. There are just 6,000 bottles available, 600 of which are for sale here in the States.

Rhine Hall Coffee Liqueur

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Rhine Hall is a distillery and bar in Chicago that focuses on fruit brandies, with expressions made from apple, plum, pear, cherry, and apricot. A new release from the distillery is this coffee liqueur that was originally an exclusive only available at Alinea and The Aviary, but is now for sale at the distillery and other shops. It’s made using the distillery’s Barrel Aged Pineapple Brandy, which is infused with coffee and vanilla beans. This gives it a strong spirit-forward character, with a touch of sweetness and caramel, and a nice coffee jolt in every sip.

Maggie’s Farm Coffee Liqueur

Maggie's Farm Coffee Liqueur
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Pittsburgh seems like an unlikely home for a rum distillery, but that’s where you’ll find Maggie’s Farm. The rum is distilled from raw cane instead of molasses using pot stills, and no sugar or flavor is added. The distillery’s coffee liqueur is made by blending cold brew coffee with white rum, then adding brown sugar and vanilla extract. The result is a coffee liqueur that has a decidedly funky rum undercurrent, setting this apart from others of its kind.

Jägermeister Cold Brew Coffee

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Jägermeister has been getting a reboot over the past year or two, starting with the release of Manifest, which is barrel-aged and uses more herbs than the original. The latest new product is Jägermeister Cold Brew Coffee, which basically adds coffee and cacao beans to the formula resulting in a liqueur that is decidedly recognizable as Jäger, but with an undercurrent of coffee. This will not appeal to everyone, but fans of Jäger, and amaro in general, should give it a try.

St. George NOLA Coffee Liqueur

St. George NOLA Coffee Liqueur
Image used with permission by copyright holder

This spirit from California’s St. George Spirits was inspired by the flavors of New Orleans. It’s made using coffee beans, chicory root, Madagascar vanilla, and organic cane sugar, and the final product is a drink that can be served neat or used to make a cocktail. The distillery chose to use Yirgacheffe coffee beans, based on what it describes as their bright and fruity qualities.

FEW Cold Cut Bourbon

FEW Cold Cut Bourbon
Image used with permission by copyright holder

FEW Cold Cut is barrel proof bourbon distilled at the Evanston, IL distillery that is cut using cold brew coffee instead of water after maturation. According to founder Paul Hletko, the bourbon comes out of the barrel at about 120 proof and is proofed down to 93 after adding the coffee. This makes it a “distilled specialty spirit” according to the TTB, but it is just bourbon and cold brew with no flavoring, sugar, or anything else added. This spirit is an odd one. There are some chocolate and cherry notes on the palate, but at first sip the coffee element is fairly subtle, although you can tell there is something different going on here. But try this in a cocktail like an old fashioned or Manhattan and the mingling of coffee and bourbon starts to make a bit more sense.

Editors' Recommendations

Jonah Flicker
Jonah Flicker is a freelance writer who covers booze, travel, food, and lifestyle. His work has appeared in a variety of…
Need a Treat? Try Dalgona Coffee, the Internet’s Most Shareable Drink
iced dalgona coffee

In the immortal words of Agent Cooper, as played by Kyle Maclachlan, “Every day, once a day, give yourself a present. Don’t plan it, don't wait for it. Just let it happen.”

Never has this advice been more vital than right now, as we languish under the woeful uncertainty of a public health crisis. But with shelter-in-place conditions having closed off most “treat yo’self” venues, where and how do you source these gifts to self?

Read more
9 Creative Ways to Cook With Coffee, According to Chefs
coffee beans closeup.

Bakers and dessert chefs -- both amateur and professional -- know very well that adding the benefits of coffee to any chocolate treat will provide a welcome balance and highlight the chocolate’s flavor complexities. That said, chocolate isn’t the only ingredient that benefits from a coffee counterpoint. Plenty of savory dishes also thrive with the addition of coffee, including some that you might never expect. We surveyed a group of professional chefs to discover their favorite under-the-radar ways of using coffee in their cooking, and they gave us 9 recipe suggestions that we can’t wait to try.
Don’t be afraid to add coffee to a shellfish spice rub.
When it comes to using coffee as an ingredient in savory, meat-based dishes, some diners believe that the nutty, somewhat-bitter taste of our favorite caffeinated beverage is a natural fit for red meat, but that it doesn’t really suit more subtle proteins like shellfish. However, chef, TV host, and cookbook author Stephanie Harris-Uyidi wholeheartedly disagrees, recommending coffee as a key ingredient for a rub marinade to use on shrimp. “Adding coffee to your seafood spice rub or marinade incorporates a touch of smoky, robust flavor to your meals. It has an additional level of delectable complexity that is surprising to your taste buds and blends well with chili, cinnamon, brown sugar, garlic, and pepper!” Harris-Uyidi explains. She uses this spice rub for her Oaxacan-Style Jicama Shrimp Taco recipe, which you can find here.

Using a coffee crust on fish offers both moisture and rich flavor.
Shellfish aren’t the only ocean proteins conducive to a coffee rub or marinade. According to executive chef David Burke of David Burke Tavern in Brooklyn and Woodpecker by David Burke in Manhattan, “We routinely save coffee grinds and re-purpose them into dishes because they add an intriguing smokiness and aromatics. In the case of the coffee-and-coriander crust [we use on our] sea bass, it keeps [the fish] moist, and you can use it on any fish. [It functions] like a salt crust.”
Coffee highlights the natural sweetness in roasted root vegetables and brings a new dimension to a light vinaigrette.
Coffee may not seem like an obvious flavor element for a refreshing spring salad, but chef Emily Ferrari of Maritana in St. Pete Beach, Florida considers it a perfect match for a salad with crisp greens and roasted root veggies. “Coffee has an amazing bitter note to it that when used in rubs or lightly sweetened goes amazingly with root vegetables. It can work almost like an acid to enhance the other sweet flavors in a dish and tone down the fatty notes that can sometimes overpower a dish and make it too rich. In this case, adding some sherry vinegar and brown sugar [to] the coffee for the dressing makes it this wonderfully rich sauce that coats the greens lightly. Then, adding a coffee rub with chili powder, salt, and brown butter to the vegetables before roasting them and adding them to the salad brings out their natural sweetness and gives a great contrast in flavor with each bite,” Ferrari advises.
If you need an extra dose of savory flavor in a mushroom dish, coffee will solve your problem.
Thanks to their woodsy bouquet and appealing natural funk, mushrooms are very popular meat alternatives, and their inherent savory taste can get a major boost from the addition of coffee. “My all-time favorite [thing about cooking with coffee] is the way it complements mushrooms so very well. Incorporating brewed coffee to a mushroom dish of just about any kind is a wonderful way to bring more depth to the flavor of the mushrooms,” insists executive chef Joey Molteni of Hathorne in Nashville.

Read more
A Brief History of Chicory Coffee, a New Orleans Staple
cafe du monde chicory coffee beignets

When the going gets tough, the toughest know how to ration. This culinary notion has been proven time and time again, during the grimmest stretches of wartime or the most meager hours of drought and famine.
Chicory coffee came about under such less-than-ideal circumstances and has since become an edible celebrity along the historic streets of New Orleans. Born of restrictive laws that prohibited coffee imports, chicory filled the gap. While it contains no caffeine, it does offer woodsy flavors and a mouthfeel not unlike coffee. To stretch out limited coffee supplies, folks would add chicory to the mix. Like lard, chicory had an ability to extend the lifespan of prominent pantry items.
Napoleon’s blockade in the early 1800s resulted in very small amounts of beans making landfall in France. Similar moves by the powers-that-be at the time in other parts of the world kept coffee away and citizens were, well, jonesing for some. They got creative and went with something that, at the very least, resembled coffee.

The flower of the chicory plant. Ed Reschke/Getty Images
What is it? Chicory is like a root vegetable, grown in France, South Africa, and increasingly stateside in places like Nebraska. A relative of endive and a member of the dandelion family, it’s essentially a salad leaf and green snack for livestock above ground. Below ground, it contains a root system that’s dug up, cut, dried, roasted, and ground.
Egyptians found medicinal uses for chicory as far back as 5,000 years ago. In the American South, people found it extra useful amid a naval blockade during the Civil War. Locals needed their java, even if it was an adjusted version. The trend stuck and it wasn't long before New Orleans residents relied on a chilled riff during the stuffier summer months. 
The Cafe du Monde chicory coffee container is now iconic, with its orange glow and vintage print of the Jackson Square location. The containers double as silverware tins in southern-inspired eateries all over the country. Du Monde claims the chicory adds a chocolate-like flavor to the coffee, an ideal complement.

Read more